It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
I see I wasn't clear on one of my previous posts; have you ever found two rocks that looked the same or had a similar peculiar shape?
Originally posted by Aresh Troxit
Find a rock, with an opening similar to the one in the pic, and with a circular rock encased, not fused, in it.
Sedimentary rocks can have many shapes and the process by which they are created is very simple.
Remember, tho: it has to be a natural process that creates this. Since it has been decided by the majority that this was a common rock, I want to see rocks that can be categorized in the same class as this fellow here...
Sure, don't you want to take the photo on Mars? It would be even closer to the photo you posted.
You should take your picture of the pipe in a park, in the sand, in a similar position so we can be better judges. My pipe isn't in an appartment!...
That is a sedimentary rock, and judging by its smell it's made of several layers of clay. I don't know why one of those layers has a much different colour.
Originally posted by Aresh Troxit
What type of rock is on your post? I'm as knowledgeable in the classification of rocks as my mom is towards the Simpson.
What round stain?
I was wondering a few minutes ago if it was wood. La tache ronde me fait penser à un noeud. ( translation: The round stain makes me think of a knot. )
At first I thought that I shouldn't post that photo, but I decided to post it to see if someone would noticed the "stain", because that's not a stain, that's a depression/hole carved on the rock, as you can see in this photo.
Originally posted by Aresh Troxit
Hi! The "stain" is on the round part, on the top half of your rock. The one beige piece that is convex.If you look at it quickly, it looks like a knot.
Not yet, I have too little time for all the things I would like to do.
Have you seen the other "rocks' I posted?
Would you be happy with a rock "in the same category"? And what that category would be?
Originally posted by Aresh Troxit
Well, here is something similar, not the same shape, but in the same category. You can see the structure is basically the same.
I think that you are misinterpreting the rock, I don't think there's a wheel in that, just a rock with piece broken and that other part that you call "the wheel" may be a different or part of the same rock. A little dust accumulated in the depression helps the mystery, hiding the connection (if any) between the two parts of the rock or the two rocks.
Now, can someone show me a similar construct as that of the "Wheeled bone". It doesn't have to be a twin. ...OR... A rational explanation to the existence of the "rock" I presented.
Thanks.
By the way, I salute your presence here and the exchanges we get. After all, you are the only "nay-sayer" that took on my little challenge. Stars for you! I'm even revisiting some stuff I hadn't seen since school!
That's part of the problem, that image is bigger than the original, meaning that it shows some distortion. Also, judging by the artefacts present on the image, it looks like it's a resized JPEG, making it even worse than a resized image without compression or with a loss-less compression method.
Originally posted by Aresh Troxit
If you go on page 6 of the thread, you'll see the WB with a bigger view.
So far so good, I understand what you mean.
If you look closely, the wheel shaped rock has some little nodules along it's rim, and they are evenly shaped. It is faint, and I wish someone better able than me would help make these details out.
But this I don't understand. What hole and small line are you talking about?
You can see a large enough hole that follows into a small line alongside the "wheel".
I don't understand this either, sorry.
It could be a "stain" effect, but the real hole connected to it, and the shape of the cut on the bone like structure, where the wheel fits in seems highly designed.
I wouldn't call it a bump, but I understand what you mean.
A question: If you look at the bone like structure, on the opposite side of the wheel, you will notice a bump.
I don't understand any of these references.
Do you also see the 90 degrees plate attached to it? And opposite to this, there is this straight wall of sand. It must be placed on something... Another plate, seeing it is aligned with the one on the other side?
I saw those photos, but I don't see any perfect circle in any of the photos, there's no source for the rocky screw, and the rusty pipe looks even less like a pipe than the first one.
Until you can go see the other pics on this page, there is the remains of a natural rocky screw... LOL ...a rock with a perfect circle with a straight pin attached to it and pointing up, resting on a plate with straight lines and angles, all mingled in rock, and what seems to be another pipe at Gusev.
I don't see that either, could you please post images pointing to those things? I think it would be easier, although some people may complain about you trying to influence the viewers.
PS: On the far side of the Wheeled bone, there is a broken plate, aligned with the ones mentioned above. I just wish there were holes in them...
Originally posted by Maddogkull
The only one that looks believable is the pipe. Everything else seems like imagination. But who knows right
Thanks for the detailed explanation.
Originally posted by Aresh Troxit
That's an interesting discovery, it looks like something got stuck in the sand recently (but I don't think there's wet sand in there, just darker sand).
What makes a straight line on top of a moving sand dune appear, with flips on both sides of the said line, even throwing a little bit of wetty sand in the direction the wind blows?
I don't know, but if I could get my hands on it, I'd be rich, and famous, and rich, and famous, and rich, rich!!!
[atsimg]http://files.abovetopsecret.com/images/member/4fe4759332a4.jpg[/atsimg]
Thanks.
And here is the one you asked for earlier tonight about the screw:
marsrovers.jpl.nasa.gov...
Originally posted by Your_Number_One_Fan
reply to post by VonDoomen
Yea how dare you blame tetrahydrocannabinol! Maybe lay of the psilocybin or lysergic acid diethylamide. But never the sweet cheeba!
To Greeneyedleo
We all know it's a very vivid imagination and a strong desire to want to find something on mars. However if your not a doctor in psychology then don't claim it's a psychological condition, perhaps suggest it.
How come you use Google to look up unusual rocks? Then link us with that. Mars and Earth have very different extremes in which ways they'll shape their own rocks.