It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
The devil appeared to Jesus in the wilderness and asked Jesus to worship him.
Where do these concepts of evil and desire come from?
Originally posted by Dark Ghost
Where do these concepts of evil and desire come from?
Why the need to judge us then? Why judge a creation of your own that has not been given the same power and capabilities as the creator?
Just like desire and evil, deception has to have come from somewhere. Where did these phenomena come from? The snake was only able to use desire because he was created by God. What does that tell us?
I agree that's what she should have done. However, this does suggest that God made a grave error in giving Free Will to his creations.
People use the "we are not robots" (my wording, not yours) argument, but in truth God wants us to be like robots that love Him and follow His laws. He wants us to choose his Way and only his Way or he will not love and protect us. It sounds to me that God truly does desire obedient robots.
Originally posted by LeoVirgo
If there was a 'perfect garden' surely this was not a place where we were a creation without a purpose. Were we as pets to a higher power?
Plus we see later more confussion when God in the OT assures us....that God creates peace and makes evil, creates light and makes darkness (paraphrase so forgive). This leads back to the idea that Satan, what ever this Satan is (a worker for God? that brings the purpose of our present experience), has no real blame that can be placed upon it.
For things of not of God to of been present, then we are already seeing a place that was 'not' all perfect and 'not' all good. Which was the 'tree' since it held within it a 'possibly' very very dark purpose. This darkness, the possibility of it being there, shows all things, manifest from ONE true source, which is God.
When there is understanding of 'why the purpose', 'why the mistake'....then one see's that....because it was meant to be this way. There are no mistakes, it all serves Gods plan. It is, all perfect, without shame on man or God.
What ever state our world is in this very moment....is obviously needed. Somewhere within our diseases, our crimes, and corruptions....there is purpose. And to think that its not serving help to us that we cant see in this moment, or bringing us experiences that are catalysts to make us see with a different eye, a reaping that has been sown ect....is something I just cant see or understand.
Originally posted by Dark Ghost
Thank you for the very good answers you gave. They are among the best I have received after asking these types of questions. Thank you for taking the time to address them.
I think a lot of your answers are based on the idea of there being polarity in the world. The problem I see, though, is that God would have known when creating the concepts of love, prosperity and happiness that there were opposites to these things. So it appears He was negligent in allowing us to have Free Will because inevitably many would choose not to obey Him. This would lead to people experiencing the opposite things of those I mentioned above.
Another argument against the "polarity" concept is when examining the idea of colour. How do we describe something that lacks colour? Even Black+White refers to colours. We know there are many shades of colour, but how do we make the decision that colour ends? Do we need to witness a non-Colour to appreciate the Colours we do see? Can we actually experience non-Colour?
Originally posted by JesusisTruth
hell is a reality. It's like a jail for evil. They don't trun into non exstince or divine justice is irrelevant.
Originally posted by miriam0566
ok, but what about the other side? what about those who choose to love him?
how do you feel about your friends? dont you appreiciate the fact that they WANT to be around you and to share thier life with you?
i was once talking to someone about God and he said to me that the thought of having anyone tell him how to live his life "chaffed" him. in the end he said "i would rather die then have to answer to someone" i found the statement interesting because i began to see things from a different light
God has the right to determine what his creation should look like, after all it is his creation is it not? same way you have the right to treat or misteat or discard any of the posessions you own. it sounds cold and callous but its true. but god, doesnt mistreat us, he simply says, "love, or get out of my creation". is that really unreasonable?
do we really have some ingrown right to mistreat others that God is obligated to respect?
its like a landlord, he says " you can stay here, just keep the place clean and try not to damage the apartment" are those somehow unreasonable requests? if the tenent refuses to follow those rules, doesnt the landlord have the right to ask the tenent to leave (even by force if nessesary)?
i dont think black and white are colors. i thought they were just extremes. black absorbs all color and white reflects all color.
but in relation to good and evil, yea, i can see how that applies.
many decisions we make dont fall into "good" or "bad".
Originally posted by JesusisTruth
It says they will be punished in hell.
that was my point.
peace.
Originally posted by JesusisTruth
It says they will be punished in hell.
that was my point.
Originally posted by Dark Ghost
But I did not create my friends. I did not decide their nature and how they would react to me. I did not choose how their emotions, feelings and mind would work. My friends and I are all human beings with the same capabilities in this physical world. God created us with the knowledge that he is above all that we can perceive.
i was once talking to someone about God and he said to me that the thought of having anyone tell him how to live his life "chaffed" him. in the end he said "i would rather die then have to answer to someone" i found the statement interesting because i began to see things from a different light
I know those types of people. That is not where I am coming from. I am saying it is unfair for God to expect us to accept and follow his rules without questioning anything. Why do we have minds? Why do we have the ability to reason and consider things? Why do we have the ability to DOUBT?
God has the right to determine what his creation should look like, after all it is his creation is it not?
He does have that right. But if he chooses to favour certain creations over others when both are humans, then he is not a righteous God. You cannot say that God is benevolent if he chooses not to love those who do not follow His word.
do we really have some ingrown right to mistreat others that God is obligated to respect?
Any rights we do have were given to us by God. If we mistreat others, it is because He enabled us the ability to do so. If he did not, then he is not omnipotent. If he did, then he is not righteous.
Again your analogy - even though I quite like it - is not fitting. That landlord did not create his tenants. He did not decide their nature. He has a right to evict those who don't follow the rules, but if he evicts too many people on the most basic of reasons, how many people would want to stay there?
That is a good explanation. But what about the colour grey? Is that not the sum of two extremes at the same time?
Another reason why I say the notion of Free Will is very problematic. Not only are all our actions judged as good or evil, the actions we do not take are judged in the same manner
Originally posted by JesusisTruth
Miriam, I know what they mean. personal interpretation is different with every soul. Those passages are as plain as day.
Originally posted by JesusisTruth
Now as for dark Ghost. On the contrary. Hell means God is just and true to his word.
God isn't uncle tom. Some people on Earth let alone hell are so evil that they get life in prison.
Dark ghost with all due respect again it's a case where the human lacks understanding what hell is.
It's mans denial of God. They don't want repentance because they had chances on earth so after death they are (fixed) in a state of evil without graces and love.
1 billion years pass, they still would rather be damned then to serve God.
They had chances.
Hell is a jail to hold evil. If hell didn't exist than that would prove God don't give a crap about evil and punishment which means God don't care at all.
Originally posted by JesusisTruth
Yes. Because the soul doesn't want to serve God. God can't make it love him and they chose hell. The soul becomes graceless and loveless in hell.
Hell has to exist. Some people are that evil. You have to have a place to hold evil. if not, I wouldn't want to worship a God who doesn't seperate good from evil.
Now miriam.
Come on. You know what those passages mean and say. it says souls will be punished in hell. Lake of fire. weaping and gnashing of teeth.
stop trying to beat around the bush.
I think the fire is a spiritual hatred though and not literal flames. Some saints indicate that.