It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by drac88
reply to post by DrainMaster
Well that's already been answered as you may see from my previous posts.
Originally posted by Daisy-Lola
reply to post by drac88
Well, going through a list of films, featuring aliens in one guise or another meeting with humans, I've actually concluded that the majority of films are in fact neither positive or negative, and are actually more neutral.
The majority of the films do in fact feature both good and bad aliens (e.g. Star Trek has both Vulcans & Klingons)
Alf I considered positive, even though he ate cats
The list of the films is from here:
Wiki- films featuring extraterrestrials
Why Wall-E is listed I don't know, I don't remember seeing an alien in it
So not counting the films that I haven't seen (or Wall-E), I counted :
-----Positive 30
-----Negative 51
-----Neutral 73
So the Positive encounters are in last place, with Neutral in first.
If you add just the negative films, as per your thread, then you find negative alien interaction is dumped far behind.
I can supply a list of my findings, but it would take two posts to do
I've also come to the conclusion that I watch far too many films
Originally posted by DrainMaster
It doesn't really matter how neutral they try to make the films or how many good alien films they try to make. What really matters is how much we are affected by any presence of evil extraterrestrials even in films as neutral as Star Trek and Star Wars.
[edit on 28-10-2009 by DrainMaster]
Originally posted by NightVision
I don't think there's been a positive ET movie out of Hollywood since Contact in 96-97.
Originally posted by drac88
DISCLAIMER 1: This is not a thread about how good the movie looks, or how hot Milla Jovovich is.
DISCLAIMER 2: I don't want to hear anything about how great it is that this movie has 'real archived' footage, because it doesn't. Anyone who really believes that footage shown in the trailer is real needs to get their eyes checked. It may be based on real 'events' (obviously I recognize that abductions have happened) but that doesn't mean the footage you see is legitimate.
DISCLAIMER 3: This is not a debate whether ETs are 100% benevolent or not. As far as my knowledge and research goes, I do not believe in malevolent extra terrestrials. It's been proven to me that those negative abduction experiences are and have to be - government controlled MILABS. (if you don't know what that is by now, go search up on it and come back to this thread. But basically, they involve frightening experiences with beings that are NOT from outer space.)
DISCLAIMER 4: I know there is already a topic on this movie, but I want this thread to be different - and about a very particular discussion, as you can see from my previous disclaimers.
So, on to the topic of discussion. The trailer depicts obviously a story revolving around very negative abduction experiences. I really hope this isn't just some horror movie that will end up inducing fear of ETs into the minds of movie goers. That being said, it's also possible this movie will go in a totally different direction, to end up having a surprise twist that will actually clarify the government's involvement with the negative abductions, and how unrelated they are from actual ETs. That would be quite an enlightening thing to show in a hollywood movie.
To sum that last paragraph up, this movie could go both ways. I hope the writer/director actually did their research free of mainstream sources because this movie has the potential to be really eye opening. However there's a huge possibility (since it's clearly a horror film) that it will depict ETs as evil and harmful. This is just not good. We need LESS hollywood movies doing this.
"A remarkable movie that boggles the mind and changes your opinion on UFOs."
-Larry King (Larry King Live)
If this film is going to be as profound as to 'change people's opinions on UFOs', I SURE AS HELL HOPE that it's for the better. But since this movie is backed with supposed actual events that appear to be extremely frightening and harmful, it also has the power to induce a heavy subconscious fear of aliens in movie-goers.
When the Blair Witch Project came out it was extremely well done (considering the budget and concept) and innovative for it's time. Not to mention it succeeded in scaring half the country into ever going into the woods again. I know every kid my age was petrified of the woods. These are the kinds of subconscious fears the movies can instill in our minds. For people who don't know right from wrong regarding UFOs, 'The Fourth Kind' could be pretty detrimental for the time being.
I hope I'm not sounding outlandish with this post, but ever since I first saw the trailer I keep saying to myself "this better not be yet ANOTHER disinformation film". And like I said, it could go both ways. Let's hope it goes the right way. I'm definitely going to see it because I'm curious as to see what either 'garbage' or 'gold' these filmmakers have created.
Please, discuss this with me.
[edit on 24-10-2009 by drac88]
[edit on 24-10-2009 by drac88]
Originally posted by Daisy-Lola
Knowing was positive, as was Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, Superman Returns and K-pax and Muppets from Space
Originally posted by Jauqx
Disinformation????
WTF is your premis for the question? It's a movie, a story, art, etc..
Didn't they teach you the difference between reallity and make believe in school? Home schooled maybe...
Originally posted by Armour For Victor
I just saw this movie last night, and thanks to all the scare I couldnt sleep last night. The footage shown on the movie looks and feels real, but I also have my hand on the fence just in case I need to jump back over. Some of the footage is disturbing and begs the question, is it really real? Would they show this in a movie? I too feel that there isnt an over population of "bad" aliens, but I guess thats really up to the believer.