It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Telafree
Risperdal does help people too.
Not all drugs are bad mmkay?
Originally posted by Mynaeris
You are right Risperdal has been proven to help with Schizophrenics. I have not seen any autistic child helped by Risperdal, if this were the case the autism pandemic would be over.
reply to post by skeptic1
I couldn't agree with you more. Parents have quit the role of parenting and started medicating instead. I am currently busy with a study where parents are bringing in their children for treatment because of annoying habits, like cracking their knuckles, or clearing their throats and it has been labelled Tourettes. All we can do is wait for the Tourettes pandemic to strike. I am of the opinion parents are in search of Stepford Children with the least amount of work. And the drug companies are eager to assist.
[edit on 4-2-2009 by Mynaeris]
Originally posted by spacecowgirl
Got a problem, take a pill?
or
Got a problem, try to deal with it, adjust, cry, feel the pain and get through it, sadder and wiser, drug free.
Life is not a feel free zone. Sometimes it hurts and is painful dealing with it but I would rather have my brain intact than take some lousy med that screws you over far worse than the original issue in the first place.
As for the OP, your friends daughter should have been helped through the issues of the father with counselling. Sure, it is hard realizing that the Dad is a moron but at least after a few months of processing, it's accepted and finished with unlike brain burning meds.
Originally posted by Xcalibur254
When a person is prescribed psychotropic medication, it is generally by their physician. Now, a physician is an expert in bodily ailments. They did not go to medical school however to learn about psychological disorders. So, a lot of this misprescription of medicine can be accounted for because people would rather visit their physician for psychological advice as opposed to a psychiatrist who did go to school so they could prescribe medication for psychological disorders. Or better yet a clinical psychologist, who won't prescribe any medication at all and will instead use cognitive-behavioral therapy in most cases. When it comes down to it most people are woefully ignorant when it comes to psychology. Most disorders, except for things like schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and severe cases of depression, can be helped without the use of medication. People today however want that quick fix and aren't willing to do the work that traditional therapy requires.
Originally posted by paxnatus
What line of work are you in ? You say you haven't seen any autistic children helped by resperidone? Well then you obviously haven't seen mine and the many others who have been helped.
Originally posted by paxnatus
If you look objectively at the trend, you will see quite the opposite. The ones who care, are the ones who do take their children to doctors in search of some kind of help. Do you honestly think parents who don't care take time out of their day for their childrens doctor's apointments? No. Parents who don't care to parent are typically the picture of neglect.
Originally posted by paxnatus
As far as your niece being treated for depression, they obviously think she has a mood disorder maybe she is bipolar (sic) . Atypical antipsychotics are
not just given for schizophrenia, they are very effective in managing mood
disorders. 'Atypical' meaning they don't have the same side effects, or act on the brain the same way as your first generation antipsychotics use to; such as thorazine or haldol these were considered the heavy hitters and the only drug docs could turn to. Thank goodness there are better medications available.
Originally posted by paxnatus
Really!! And who are you to give advice? Having a bout or two of mild depression is normal. Having a major mental illness, such as bipolar disorder or schizophrenia just to name two, is a completely different ball game! You need to research just what depression is then speak to this issue, You don't have your information right.
I do agree with counseling along with meds.
Originally posted by Mynaeris
Originally posted by paxnatus
What line of work are you in ? You say you haven't seen any autistic children helped by resperidone? Well then you obviously haven't seen mine and the many others who have been helped.
I work in this line of work. It helps with a specific symptom of autism not with autism or even any variant in the autism spectrum. In fact you might be interested in doing some research on the ABA (Applied behavioral analysis) program (www.behavior.org...) They have been getting striking results without the need for drug use. Also look at www.nycli.org...
Though if Risperdone is working for your autistic child then it's a good thing. I would never suggest without seeing the child that you are doing the wrong thing.
Originally posted by paxnatus
If you look objectively at the trend, you will see quite the opposite. The ones who care, are the ones who do take their children to doctors in search of some kind of help. Do you honestly think parents who don't care take time out of their day for their childrens doctor's apointments? No. Parents who don't care to parent are typically the picture of neglect.
Originally posted by paxnatus
As far as your niece being treated for depression, they obviously think she has a mood disorder maybe she is bipolar (sic) . Atypical antipsychotics are
not just given for schizophrenia, they are very effective in managing mood
disorders. 'Atypical' meaning they don't have the same side effects, or act on the brain the same way as your first generation anti psychotics use to; such as thorazine or haldol these were considered the heavy hitters and the only drug docs could turn to. Thank goodness there are better medications available.
I will definitely take note of your Dx on my niece. (1) I am assuming that you also have a PhD in clinical psych ( I do) and (2) Doctors don’t study psychology and should not have the power to prescribe medication for mental disorders.
I work in this line of work. It helps with a specific symptom of autism not with autism or even any variant in the autism spectrum. In fact you might be interested in doing some research on the ABA (Applied behavioral analysis) program (www.behavior.org...) They have been getting striking results without the need for drug use. Also look at www.nycli.org...
Originally posted by paxnatus
Just because you have a phD in clinical psych. doesn't make you an expert
in Autism or Psychiatric medicine.
I have a Masters in nursing, so I do have some experience my self. I also have a 12yr. old autistic son, and that makes me pretty much an expert in autism. Yes, I am very aware of ABA therapy it has been proven very effective IF started at a very young age usually around 2; which according to your article backs this claim up.
"An Applied Behavior Analytic Intervention Program for Pre-School and School-Age Children with Autism"
My son did not receive a diagnosis for autism until he was 5. Please feel free to check into the qualifications needed in order to receive ABA therapy.
Seven years ago Insurance companies refused to pay for it, unless there were extraordinary circumstances. The cost out of pocket is $100,000 plus. He was seeing one of the top specialist in the world Dr. Mary Megson a developmental pediatric specialist. You can do some research on her if you like. From there we went to Children's Hospital in Richmond Virginia. He now sees a Psychiatrist who is Board Certified in Child Adolescent , Adult Psychiatry. Board Certified in Forensic Medicine, Board Certified Forensic Examiner, Certified, American Society of Addiction Medicine. He attends therapy with a doctor who specializes in Autism in Children and Adolescents.
His doctor uses Cognitive Behavior Therapy and Personal Construct Psychology. He also uses Behavioral Modification therapy. These therapies in addition to medication are working well to help him understand his "Theory of Mind" issues. He also attends a specialized program for children with autism. I hope this helps you see I do know a little of what I am talking about and NOT just looking for a quick fix.
As far as resperidone HELPING these kids. Here are some links, if you care to research. [autism.com...].
"As a result, atypical anti psychotic drugs are being studied as off-label medications to treat autism because of their increased safety and efficacy over conventional neuroleptics. Risperidone is becoming one of the more popular atypical anti psychotic drugs prescribed for treating disruptive behavior in autistic children. This discussion will explore the use of risperidone as a possibly safe and potentially effective treatment for disruptive behavioral symptoms in children with autism."
link:findarticles.com...
As far as your idea regarding Munchausen's byproxy. I am very aware of this disorder. To think the average lay person is using this, IMO is kind of ridiculous. The occurrence of this is quite rare.
Was not talking down to you or anyone for that matter, I apologize for offending you.
To be perfectly honest, I am surprised that you, based on your qualifications
are not more informed about atypical anti-psychotics and their use in treatment of mood disorders. Bipolar disorder usually presents when depressive symptoms are present only. Meaning this is when most decide to seek treatment. Manic symptoms do not usually manifest for several weeks to months after diagnosis of Depression. This is the number one reason Bipolar diagnosis is missed.
But hey, you already knew all this, right?
[edit on 6-2-2009 by Mynaeris]
Originally posted by paxnatus
As far as your niece being treated for depression, they obviously think she has a mood disorder maybe she is bipoalr.
Originally posted by Mynaeris
You are right Risperdal has been proven to help with Schizophrenics. I have not seen any autistic child helped by Risperdal, if this were the case the autism pandemic would be over.