It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Anonymous ATS
There are some facts you are all ignoring.
1. Hamas broke the cease-fire and fired hundreds of rockets into Israel in a few days.
2. Hamas built the warehouses near civilian population as they don't care about civilian deaths knowing full well that Israel would eventually defend themselves.
3. Israel targetted Hamas and not civilians.
4. Any country including the US and Britain would defend themselves and retaliate against such rocket attacks.
5. Fairly low number of deaths caused by rocket attacks in Israel are irrelevant as Hamas intend to kill each time they fire and so they must be stopped.
6. All civilian deaths are a tragedy.
7. 1/3 of casualties are civilian and 2/3 are Hamas. Not too bad in comparison to USA's efforts in Afghanistan and Western Pakistan, and much less ratio of civilian deaths relative to militant deaths.
8. This would not have happened had Hamas stopped firing rockets.
9. Gaza has a border with Egypt to get supplies thru'
10. They use this to get weapons instead of essential supplies.
11. Israel are not responsible for looking after another state/country (Gaza)
12. Israel has the right to defend itself, including retaliations.
OK, logical conclusions drawn from these facts:
1. Hamas are to blame for not honouring a cease-fire, and are entirely to blame for all the deaths.
2. This tragedy would have been prevented had Hamas stopped hating Jews and lived in peace as civilised people.
3. Hamas only understand killing, and have no compassion even towards their own people in Gaza.
4. Israel responded in the only way Hamas understands, and so now has the mindset to destroy them as Hamas shows no rational behaviour. And why should Israel wait forever for Hamas to live in peace?! They have given them long enough.
5. The solution is for Hamas to stop firing rockets and then there can be peace. Simple as that. Just as the US have stated today.
6. If you don't conclude the same you are lacking logical and rational thinking. The most simple and obvious causes and solutions are correct.
7. Yes it's a humanatarian disaster if this continues, and if Iran supplies more rockets to Hamas and Hezbollah it will get worse. Israel may have to bomb Lebanon again, and maybe go to war with Syria and/or Iran with US and British support.
8. You know what, it will be the fault of the Arabs because they started the latest battles when we and Israel wanted peace. But Israel and the West will finish it.
9. China and Russia to get involved at their peril, and ours as well.
I'm amazed no one sees this is classic guerilla warfare, and Hamas WANTS civilian casualties on their side. It’s a propaganda coup. why else would they starve their own people in favor of getting more rockets to chuck at Israel instead of food?
Does no one recall that this whole mess started because HAMAS broke the cease fire? On what basis do the Palestinians lay claim to the land?
Everywhere the Palestinians have gone, they've caused trouble. Jordan and Lebanon come to immediate mind, not to mention the West Bank.
Why do you think no Arab countries want them?
But back to the propaganda angle. That's what drew me to this thread to begin with. The headline was masterful. I've not beheld propagandistic eloquence of that caliber since the Soviet Union fell. Now to be honest, propaganda has gotten a bad name as being equated with untruth, but that isn't strictly so. Propaganda can be wholly true, partially true, or bold faced lies. The best propaganda is always based in truth, but it's the packaging that counts
No, I am not Jewish, and yes, I know what it's like to have your ancestors lands taken. The only thing that matters is what's real on the ground NOW. I'm going to bed . . nenothtu out
Originally posted by donwhite
Jews Continue to Engage in the Ethnic Cleansing of old Palestine
Originally posted by Kailassa
Zionists have worked for years to increase their land and eliminate Palestinians, always using the holocaust as the excuse.
Not saying Israel hasn't been overly aggressive, maybe I've understated that, but don't you think if they wanted more land they could have really taken it by now if they wanted? They still haven't given back Golan, and probably won't, and they could have held onto Sinai as well. I never understood this argument because of this. From past wars if they had held onto their gains, they could have doubled the size of their country.
Hamas has smuggled Chinese and Iranian rockets into Gaza that are longer range than the previous generation that they were accustomed to firing randomly into Israel.
Israel was pressured to withdraw from Gaza, now they get shot at from there.
Does anyone have a realistic idea of how to stop this conflict? Dialog and concessions don't seem to work with Hamas, they understand force only.
The Palestinians, almost none of whom are descended form the tiny number of people living in the Sinai before 1948, have developed a political culture that has stifled any development for themselves.
Backing down in Lebanon showed the Muslims that Israel was not invulnerable, that they could be beaten. Israel is now forced to show that in military strategy they are unbeatable. Israel does not want to appear aggressive, but has found painfully that they can only achieve respect and be left alone by the Muslim world when they put the fear of God into them.
The tables will be turned; Israel will look like the bad guy, the aggressor. World sentiment is already shifting to Gaza as they take a pounding but look heroic in their resistance. Israel seems to be in another no-win situation. The world watches them and expects them to act like charitable humanitarian Christians, while Hamas is exempt from critique.
But now Israel finds itself in the same entrapment as in Lebanon. They can't keep going on after the initial volleys. Hamas will still be standing, even if on crutches, and they will claim they won by default.
Billions will flow into Gaza for rebuilding, and it will all move towards an anticipated rematch.
The cards were stacked against the state of Israel in 1948. The Arabs have been defeated but have eliminated compromise and co-operation as a viable option.
Only Iran wants to see this masochistic scenario continue.