Fed Judge Throws Out Berg v. Obama Lawsuit? Or did he?

Originally posted by redhatty


Well, actually... The US Senate DID worry about it, and they passed a resolution, S. Res. 511, to confirm McCain as a Natural born citizen.

Wow, seems like a verifiably natural born citizen would be able to just umm... prove it. Especially being 'born on a military base' don't they keep records?

reply to post by southern_Guardian


And that's the problem. I've gone to blogs that have been covering the issue and attempted to inject a bit of reason into the dialog, but no one listens. No one questions McCain's qualifications because they BELIEVE that he is qualified to run for POTUS. They at least think that his eligibility is good enough. Even though federal and/or state courts have not ruled on the matter, and have dismissed McCain's cases in the same manner as Obama's.

When presented with a genuine document that the Dept. of Health of the State of Hawaii issued to Barack Obama, they're all screaming conspiracy! Rational people who would turn their noses up at the tinfoil hat crowd are doing this! They have indicted in their court of public opinion, the DNC, the FEC, the Dept. of Health of the State of Hawaii, the Governor of Hawaii, the Democratic Party, Obama, and Joe Biden. Those caught up in the insanity BELIEVE that all of these institutions and people have put their careers and lives on the line for Barack Obama, to the point where they would commit fraud on his behalf!

The rage and hate is quite overwhelming. The main feature of it, is that those folks actually BELIEVE that they are being rational. And the absurdity of it is compounded by the fact that everything that can be considered is being considered EXCEPT that which can be substantiated and verified.

The blogs that I've been to pretend to focus just on the eligibility issue, but in fact they do not. The eligibility issue is just one more thing. Obama is a Marxist, is Joseph Stalin, a murderer (pro-choice/pro-abortion), a shifty liar (not showing his birth certificate by "ducking and dodging through legal procedure"), a charlatan, a usurper, a harbinger of death, a rapist (against the US Constitution), the anti-Christ, a Muslim, a terrorist, etc., ad nauseam, ad infinitum.

It is just plain ugly. The fact that Obama has not shown his long form birth certificate is not important at all. Those people hate Obama, and do not know what to do with themselves because of it. Their disdain is so bad, and they are so ashamed of it, that they are trying to come across as being reasonable people. That they think asking a question like, "If he doesn't have anything to hide, why won't he just show it and get this mess over with?" That is the result! Clearly the statement of irrational people.

Obama didn't create the mess. But I understand Obama's strategy. He's allowing people to eat themselves alive at their own expense. He's not willing to jump into the middle in an attempt settle things. He knows that he would be eaten alive as well. Obviously, that wouldn't be a reasonable thing to do.

reply to post by Lucifer Rising


74 yrs (or whatever it is) ago, they kept records, but I don't think anyone anticipated at the time of McCain's birth that being born on a military base in another country would become an issue for him. I am sure that when he was born, they didn't say...Wow in 74 (or whatever it is) yrs, our child will be running for President of the USA.

Pretty sure this has already been hashed out somewhere else on the forum

Something serious; Mccain probably KILLED somebody and the Navy buried it. So say first hand accounts from witnesses, and the fact that the Navy hides his records and won't release them (parts). THAT is a serious issue. SUPPOSEDLY he drank, then drove and killed somebody. Lets stay in lala land though where we try to come up with how a U.S. SENATOR, and law school graduate just HAPPENED to lie his entire life. Oh, and Palin committed ETHICS violations with TRAVEL, the Monegan firing, and MANY other firings. Focus on issues. The judges MUST laugh at how ridiculous Berg is. I called BERG, and he is a LOONY toon full of hatred. He sounded like the KKK leader or something. Probably has a Hitler poster on his bathroom wall. THE same people who think this is funny, to question a guy's citizenship, they are on the level of stupidity as the girl who CARVED HER OWN FACE. Careful what you wish for guys and girls, life has a way of giving you what you ask for. BE stupid. It is one thing to question typical conspiracies, BUT when HATRED is spread on boards with people seek KNOWLEDGE and a little excitement in CONSPIRACY theories, wow, that is truly sick.

reply to post by Lucifer Rising


all i asked for was for the presidential candidate that went to school at a place where citizenship was mandatory to show his proof of citizenship.i was denied a license because of a problem with my middle name.so why does someone questionable get a pass?
so rattle your sabre,scream from the mountain top,but i still want it verified.
oh and by the way from what i understand, there are 8 other suits going on about this. if mc cain was not born a natural citizen,he deserves the same,but i havent seen a picture of him in a foreign school.

i have never bought anything from an infomercial,and i ain't gonna start now.
JUST PRODUCE THE DOCUMENT,ITS THAT EASY. stop asking for dismissals in the courts. if you dont have anything to hide,you will hide nothing.
ever stop to consider what will happen to this country if he gets elected and its found out he's ineligable????

WHY IS THIS THE WORST THING THAT CAN HAPPEN TO HIM?
SHOW ME THE MONEY...........

[edit on 30-10-2008 by Spectre0o0]

reply to post by AdmiralX

sorry you're so angry,but 'i don't get how you equate this with hate?
i'll rebutt that with ayres,acorn,his wife stating publicly that she hates america,his reverend wright,and his god damn america statement. i guess he turned out to be reverend wrong,the way obama dumped him after 20 years. HIS WIFE IS LUCKY HE DIDNT DUMP HER!
BUT WHAT'S A FEW BOMBS THAT KILLED AMERICANS,A LITTLE VOTER REGISTRATION FRAUD,AND A FEW SLURS ON THE COUNTRY,
BUT ITS OK ,HE'S OBAMA, HE GETS A PASS.
AND IF YOU THINK QUESTIONING THIS GOVERNMENT AND THIS ELECTION IS SICK,you are either very young or very gullible. and you're right ...you may get what you ask for.
and i must be the only one that thinks like this. there's probably another reason for gun sales to be up 10%.

STILL WAITING FOR PROOF. WHATS THE BIG DEAL?
PS you should also have to prove your citizenship when you vote.
also you accused mc cain of killling someone,can you cite your source?(there goes my SICKNESS again)
and wouldn't it have been adventageous for obamas mother to portray him as a citizen,considering the benefits he would have lost if he was not?

[edit on 30-10-2008 by Spectre0o0]

[edit on 30-10-2008 by Spectre0o0]

[edit on 30-10-2008 by Spectre0o0]

reply to post by Spectre0o0


Hey, I am not arguing with you. Sure, demand he produce it for you. Also demand to see McCain's proof too. Otherwise, you are just looking for another excuse to keep Obama out of office. If your querry is legit, then you need to ask it of both candidates since the question comes up with both.

Thanks for acknowledging what a doubel standard you are applying. You do not really care about this, you just do not want Obama to win. Otherwise you would be just as worried on both sides of this fence but you are not.

Better be careful, your bias is showing.

ever stop to consider what will happen to this country if he gets elected and its found out he's ineligable????

Yep, so either get over it and vote or accept that you are choosing between a Kenyan and a Panamanian.

[edit on 30-10-2008 by Lucifer Rising]

reply to post by Truther


I cannot see any official signature, and the document is not even dated fully as to when the decision was made. I think people are getting ahead of themselvevs here. You would think that if the order was authenti or ruled on then it would show some sort of signature or official stamp and or markings.

reply to post by Spectre0o0

Originally posted by Spectre0o0
WHY IS THIS THE WORST THING THAT CAN HAPPEN TO HIM?
SHOW ME THE MONEY...........

It's as if you're thinking this case is similar to a creditor demanding to be paid back a loan. That all the borrower has to do is show up with the canceled checks to show that the loan was repaid.

In fact this case is just the opposite. Berg has tried to prove that he has a right, that he is owed, the viewing of Obama's birth records. Obama's says that he doesn't owe anything to Berg and filed a Motion to Dismiss. The judge then decides that Berg has not suffered harm or loss at the fault of Obama, and then denies Berg relief.

Why should Obama have showed up in court in an effort to demonstrate that he paid a debt that never existed? Or, more precisely, why should Obama have showed up in court to pay a debt that he did not owe?

People do not pay what they do not owe.

reply to post by Spectre0o0


We've covered all of that Berg nonsense.

You should read this thread from the beginning. And if you have, read this one because you clearly missed some details.



[edit on 30-10-2008 by Areal51]

reply to post by Areal51


keep it up areal! I love the way you continiously take these rumors apart one by one..

reply to post by redhatty


gotta give it to you redhatty. until i read the hypnotic suggestion thing i was stumped as to why these people cling to obama the way they do. that was a great find,and the videos that it refers to are spectacular proof that it is true.i read the entire paper.
i'm 54 and i still learn something new every day. NOW---how do we start a wave of logical thinking?
and please ,those of you who continue to put jfk and nobama in the same light ,don't. i was alive for both and there is no comparison. not in your wildest dreams
[edit on 31-10-2008 by Spectre0o0]

[edit on 31-10-2008 by Spectre0o0]

As someone that has at least been a long time reader of this site. It has become saddly clear that the IQ levels and the ability or desire to deny ignorance are all but gone from this place. The fact that thread like this gets this far is a sad testament to people's ability to understand and think critically.

reply to post by Spectre0o0




What a laugh. Hypnotized? Here you are denying evidence that has been substantiated and verified, that supports a simple explanation. Instead you believe in a conspiracy spanning nearly five decades, involving three governments, most of their government agencies, and an entire US state. A conspiracy of all involved that made sure that a child born to a White American and a Black Kenyan would, from the day of the child's birth in 1961 -- to the present year of 2008, be escorted to the highest levels of US and global power as a fraudulent US citizen.

Stop making sense.

Obviously as this man has gone to American Univeristies and worked his way through American politics, this has just gone unnoticed. Not once has anyone ever checked or they just are not going to speak up. After all this time, successfully slipping through the cracks, he is right where he needs to be. How perfectly this all worked out. It is so simple, so logical, how can you deny it. The next logical step is that some fraudulent author with no credibility or some random ATS poster is going to rip this case WIDE open. Why aren't these people looking for Bin Laden with all this wisdom and resources?

reply to post by Lucifer Rising


I ABSOLUTLY AGREE WITH YOU ON THAT. AND THANKS FOR PROVING THAT HYPNOTIC SUGGESTION WORKS. which of the four excuses did you use?
there are over 100 facts in that paper,there,long timer.


YOU HAVE BEEN ASSIMILATED.
ps sorry i have my opinion, forgot that its all you.next time i will read your opinion and replace my obsevations with your conjecture.thank you for the ridicule and guidance,i will cherish it
and by the way,IQ does not measure intelligence.if you were educated,you would know that.
[edit on 31-10-2008 by Spectre0o0]

[edit on 31-10-2008 by Spectre0o0]

reply to post by Areal51


please explain how that not believing one thing,leads to all that lol blowing something up to ridiculous proportions does not make it false. what is your logic that asking someone to produce proof of citizenship creates a conspiracy theory?. when you tell them you're under 12 at the movies, dont they make you produce id?
you tin foil hatters sure have a lot to say,apparently without looking at anyone else's views.
your inability to see things another way,is that a denial of ignorance?




[edit on 31-10-2008 by Spectre0o0]

reply to post by Lucifer Rising


hey iqusmaximus,he didnt have to prove citizenship till now.welcome to my ignore list

Originally posted by Spectre0o0
reply to post by Lucifer Rising

 

hey iqusmaximus,he didnt have to prove citizenship till now.welcome to my ignore list

Wow, I have never been ignored for simply making a point first. Usually I at least have to address someone and specifically make them look like an ass first. I guess my posts making sense and being logical really upset a person to alert me that they will be ignoring me from now on when...I did not realize I was fighting for your attention to begin with.

Have fun ignoring people that make sense, point out facts, and generally disagree with you.

Ignoring people is the best way to deny ingorance right?


P.S. what society do you live in where he did not have to prove it until now?

Seriously? I have had to prove my citizneship several times in my short life and I am not running for president. I guess you never went to school did you?

[edit on 31-10-2008 by Lucifer Rising]

reply to post by Spectre0o0


I suggest you read Berg's now dismissed complaint to find out exactly where all the nonsense you been spewing comes from. Berg ventured conspiracy. First by implication. He named as defendants, the DNC, the FEC, and, of course, Obama.

Berg then filed an amended complaint about seven weeks into the court proceedings, where he added yet MORE defendants:

1. Secretary of the Commonwealth, Pennsylvania Department of State,
Bureau of Commissions, Elections and Legislation, 210 N. Office Building,
Harrisburg, PA 17120;

2. Pedro A. Cortés, Secretary of the Commonwealth, for the Pennsylvania
Department of State, located at 210 N. Office Building, Harrisburg, PA 17120;

3. The U.S. Senate, Commission on Rules and Administration, 305 Russell
Building, United States Senate, Washington D.C. 20510;

4. Diane Feinstein, Chairman, U.S. Senate, Commission on Rules and
Administration, 305 Russell Building, United States Senate, Washington D.C. 20510;

Berg screams conspiracy and by the mere fact that you support his claims, you support the conspiracy charges also. This is what the judge, Honorable R. Barclay Surrick, said in his memorandum dismissing Berg's claim.

Various accounts, details, and ambiguities from Obama’s childhood form the basis of Plaintiff’s allegation that Obama is not a natural born citizen of the United States. To support his contention, Plaintiff cites sources as varied as the Rainbow Edition News Letter, (id. ¶ 39), and the television news tabloid Inside Edition (id. ¶ 45). These sources and others lead Plaintiff to conclude that Obama is either a citizen of his father’s native Kenya, by birth there or through operation of U.S. law; or that Obama became a citizen of Indonesia by relinquishing his prior citizenship (American or Kenyan) when he moved there with his mother in 1967. Either way, in
Plaintiff’s opinion, Obama does not have the requisite qualifications for the Presidency that the Natural Born Citizen Clause mandates. The Amended Complaint alleges that Obama has actively covered up this information and that the other named Defendants are complicit in Obama’s cover-up.

docs.justia.com

The conspiracy charges are completely Berg's own, and anybody else who subscribes to his claims. (Download the PDF of the judge's memorandum dismissing the case, and highlight the term "conspiracy" to gain a deeper understanding of where Berg was going with this case.

If you do not accept or believe the certified, authenticated, substantiated, and verified documents that support that Obama was born in Hawaii, then you are sympathetic to the claims laid out by Berg. And if you aren't, you have to believe in a conspiracy of some sort, because Obama and his mother couldn't pull off such program that spanned nearly 50 years without the willing and able assistance of others.

So do yourself a favor and actually read the case before submitting opinions based on misinformation that has been provided by the lawyer pursuing this case. The fact that you question Obama's citizenship is a result of Berg's public campaign to turn the tide of the elections by asserting, without reliable evidence or proof, that Obama is an "illegal non-resident alien".

[edit on 31-10-2008 by Areal51]