It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by undo
you ask the question: why do people on ATS believe this way or act such'n'such a way about the word "satan" or 'satanism" or any related topic. i gave you my theory on it. you translated my theory on it to be a judgement of you personally. my theory on it was, that for many people, those all carry negative connotations so you can expect a negative response. no matter whether you agree with those negative connotations or not, the fact remains, they carry negative connotations for many people. you can't force people to feel/think a different way about it but you can offer your theories on why they should. be prepared, however, to face the same type of responses you dish out, et.al, it's a theory, not a fact, or it's a fable, not a fact, or it's a myth not a fact or it's YOUR OPINION NOT A FACT (i get this one all the time. hehe).
my suggestion to you is to just present your reasons for why you believe the current teachings are incorrect and then allow your thread contributors to actually respond to that. just generally ranting about it, isn't really a discussion thread, it's just an one-sided rant. rant threads are allowed on ATS, but expect some folks will try to have a discussion with you on the topic. that's gonna happen. you ain't on this planet alone.
Originally posted by undo
hmm, changing the rules are ye? no problemo. i can follow a bouncing ball but it won't last long -- i don't like basketball. let me be clear on that (last time i enjoyed a game of basketball, it was shaquille o'neal on orlando magic, doing what he does best. when he left to LA, i lost all interest in basketball. no biggie. i'm really not a sports person, anyway. i prefer mmorpgs if i'm going to think coimpetitively and even that loses its glamour rather quickly).
you want the reason why those things are in tandem with each other? you will have to ask the ops of the threads in question. (by the way, catholics do not equal bad. the catholic people are generally just awesome folks like other folks. it's their hierarchy that raises eyebrows and draws negative attention. some people just can't differentiate between a group and a leader. that's a thread all on its own. )
by the way i did not say catholics are bad up there, apparently you cannot read
Originally posted by undo
by the way i did not say catholics are bad up there, apparently you cannot read
i didn't say you did. i'm just illustrating that not all ATS'ers think Catholic people are bad or satanic, or whatever. you were offering it up as evidence of something and I was correcting your perspective on it as far as my little corner of the world is concerned. can you refrain from insulting me please?
Originally posted by Heike
Not that I claim this to be the truth although I do see his point to some extent, I am saying that is what he is referring to/asking about in the OP.
Originally posted by Heike
reply to post by undo
Yes, as I understand it, he is saying that he has seen Satanists accused of every activity on that list, in most cases without any real evidence to back up the claims, and he doesn't understand why Satanists can get blamed for doing all that bad stuff without anyone challenging the claims or requesting evidence, proof, etc.
In other words, if you badmouth about any other religious group, people want proof or call slander. If you badmouth Satanists, everyone just accepts it.
Not that I claim this to be the truth although I do see his point to some extent, I am saying that is what he is referring to/asking about in the OP.
Originally posted by undo
the altar boys are being abused by the leadership, yes? not by the congregants. catholics can't assure that every leader in the catholic hierarchy is behaving. that's like asking you (are you male or female?) to be responsible for what other people of your gender do. or other people with your hair color or other people with your political platform or other people in your city, your neighborhood or family or simply other people who post on ATS. if your beef is generalizations and stereotyping, welcome to planet Earth.
Originally posted by undo
Originally posted by Heike
Not that I claim this to be the truth although I do see his point to some extent, I am saying that is what he is referring to/asking about in the OP.
i better wait for his response, cause he may have something else in mind and think my response to you is off topic lol
oy, it's like walking on egg shells. tippity toe, tippity toe.
anyway, as an aside, do you believe real dragons existed? (i do, but that's a topic for another thread)
Originally posted by re22666
hmmmmmmmmmm, yes, now that i think about it, you are so right. what an unfair statement for me to make. thank you for clearing it up. that would have been as bad as say....saying satanists run pedophile rings for the government and murder the children when they are too old to be any fun, or old enough to get away or talk based on the reports of a few....oh wait, there are no real reports for that. hmmmm. maybe now you see what i was getting at.
Originally posted by undo
Originally posted by re22666
hmmmmmmmmmm, yes, now that i think about it, you are so right. what an unfair statement for me to make. thank you for clearing it up. that would have been as bad as say....saying satanists run pedophile rings for the government and murder the children when they are too old to be any fun, or old enough to get away or talk based on the reports of a few....oh wait, there are no real reports for that. hmmmm. maybe now you see what i was getting at.
well let's start with the ratonale, which i'm assuming is what you are asking about. if you aren't asking about it, then you are simply ranting, which is okay provided you realize that people will STILL try to have a discussion with you on the topic. so without further ado:
in christian teaching (not sure about islamic or judaic or pagan, etc), when a person does evil, they are said to be under the influence or influential power of negative forces. some of these negative forces could be construed as demons, devils, or simply Satan, by the christian in question. it doesn't really have a common theme and as a result, there's no way to pin it down to just one type of problem or one type of perspective. for example, when a christian is dealing with a malady of some kind, that malady is seen as a force of evil, and since the scripture says all evil originates from a central source, it's assumed this central source is behind it.
now enters the picture, people who appreciate the enlightenment that "Lucifer" or "Satan" supposedly imparted to us in the "Garden", and/or who follow the concept that the real issue is one of knowledge vs. ignorance. they embrace the knowledge over the ignorance and assume anyone who doesn't appreciate "Lucifer" in that aspect as being someone who simply is ignorant and doesn't want knowledge. whatcha got here is a big case of not quite trying to understand what the other person is saying or meaning. this doesn't just happen on one side of the issue but on all sides.
allow me to illustrate:
i was being interviewed on a canadian radio show about the subject of my ebooks. the interviewer was a pretty smart guy but when i pointed out that the application of science has had just as many negative outcomes as positive ones and is by no means the end all, be all, of knowledge, he became quite irate. he said it was a damn sight better than going back to being sheepherded and he wouldn't let me say another word. he spent the rest of his time with me on the show, doing a monologue. it was a knee jerk reaction based on prior assumption. happens all the time. AND we all do it in some measure or another.
[edit on 31-7-2008 by undo]
Originally posted by undo
i posted it because you asked for the reason why there's so much attribution of satansim to specific topics you listed.
there's so much because it is assumed by christians and perhaps several other belief systems as well, that negative force is not good. it's bad, and in christianity, it's got a name.