It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by refinement
Of course it's in your own head. Magic is basically reality hacking - hacking your own reality, not objective reality.
Originally posted by refinementThe subliminal/subconscious imprinting is precisely why it works. You can be well aware of this fact and it .....
Originally posted by refinementIn a sense, it's all an illusion - so? If it works well enough to create a strong sense of an illusion, and if you can will yourself to believe in that illusion through concentration and sheer force of will, then, well, it works.
Originally posted by refinement
The reason you can't will a pot of gold to form in front of you or will someone to be resurrected (though Jesus seemed to be good enough at magic to do this) is probably because there are limits to the kind of power you can achieve with this. no one ever said it was infinite. But it is a quite useful way of actuating your desires, at getting at what you really want - and bending your will towards it. That is why the subconscious imprinting is useful, and how it works.
Originally posted by refinementAs a sidenote, demons are real in a symbolic sense. They are a framework through which the magical act can be seen and accomplished. In a sense, they are illusions.
Originally posted by refinementConsider the Mandalas of Tibetan Buddhism. You are familiar (as I see from your sig) with the Vajra, correct? I saw a Tibetan sand mandala this past year, and the focusing idea of this mandala was the Vajra, the indestructible, the diamond, the thunderbolt. However, to focus on the Vajra, in this ceremony, the monks invoked the Amida Buddha, a deity in Tantric Buddhism associated with a certain kind of wisdom (I'm not a buddhist so I'm not really familiar with all the particulars here). They certainly believed that some sort of spirit or essence of the Amida Buddha entered into them, or the room, or the mandala itself, as they went through the invoking ceremony. The overall idea was to bring about indestructibility and to focus the monks' minds on it - to do so involved a complex ritual and belief in a deity, but, well, it seemed to work for them.
Originally posted by refinementIt's not a shtick - I mean, of course demons don't exist in the sense of something you can touch or something external to the mind. But they do exist in our heads as a kind of potentiality or archetype that can be accessed in certain ways.
Originally posted by refinementMagic has been around for millenia
Originally posted by refinementand despite scientific thinking, which is very useful and important, it will remain for as long as the human race exists, even if it must survive as an occult phenomenon.
Originally posted by refinementThe earliest religions evolved from magic, and the majority of the rituals you see in religion today have magical significance. Think of rosaries or invoking a Catholic saint, or the symbol of the cross or the lighting of ceremonial candles. all of these have a sort of ritualistic significance that is useful and real, at least for the participants.
Originally posted by refinementWe're not talking about shooting thunderbolts out of our hands. This is not Dungeons and Dragons. But in the sense that I am talking about, magic is quite real, and quite useful, even if there are no forces involved other than the strengthening of one's own desires or will or connection with the universe.
Originally posted by TheBandit795
reply to post by C.C.Benjamin
Your whole post is based on the belief that there is an objective reality out there that is not influenced by our consciousness. You could be right, but what if you are wrong? Considering the possiblity that you may be wrong is what denying ignorance is really about. I'm sure lots of us (myself included) have questioned whether who's version of reality is the correct one; the materialist one (mind being a product of matter), or the metaphysical one (matter being a product of the mind). It seems that there are quite a bit of users in this thread, and in some other threads on ATS that have proven for themselves that the latter is true.
Originally posted by C.C.Benjamin
Okay, look at it like this:
When you die, do you think the universe will end for everyone else?
Exactly.
The very nature of your post is contradictory - "the materialist or metaphysical" is a silly thing to say.
Reality is defined by how we can interact with what is located around us. If we can't interact with it (the "metaphysical" universe) then it can't possibly be reality for us. It must be something else (heaven, spirituality, whatever).
This then follows that if we can't interact with it and have no way of detecting it, then, to be pragmatic about life, it probably doesn't exist.
As for the "just let it flow and it will happen" statement you made after, that just goes to show the kind of wishful thinking that goes into endevours like these. If you just wait for it to happen, it eventually will. It's called coincidence, plain and simple.
You claim I am the one without an open mind on the subject,
but you are the one in the position in which you see me.
I have not based my reality on "what if?"'s, I have based it on the evidence. The evidence shows the Standard Model of physical interactions. It's not perfect, but that's what the evidence shows.
If the evidence showed the existence of a "magic" particle, i'd be on your side. I'd be giving this massive lecture against those people who weren't accepting reality as it is to the human race.
Giving me a provable, repeatable result. Trust me, no-one would like magic more than me,
but it is a fairytale. It doesn't exist, it is a way of explaining the unexplainable, and it does nothing than harbour dangerous superstitions that five hundred years of scientific thinkers have strove to fight against.
When you die, do you think the universe will end for everyone else?
Exactly
Originally posted by C.C.Benjamin
NOTHING IS HAPPENING THAT IS NOT INSIDE YOUR OWN HEADS. YOUR EXPERIENCE IS DOWN TO YOUR OWN PERCEPTIONS ONLY, NO MAGIC HAS OR WILL EVER TAKE PLACE.