It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Grimnal
id like to see those british sas deal with weather in australia let alone iraq i mean most of australia is 35 degres celcius everyday and can reach 49 in the inner country australia is a desert man i live here those british dont train in wagga wagga or desert climates for years (live there).
Originally posted by Captain_Sensible
Originally posted by Grimnal
id like to see those british sas deal with weather in australia let alone iraq i mean most of australia is 35 degres celcius everyday and can reach 49 in the inner country australia is a desert man i live here those british dont train in wagga wagga or desert climates for years (live there).
You do realise that one of the SAS's first and most distinguished campaigns (A full campaign, not just a mission!) was in Africa in WWII don't you?
link
Mention ‘Special Forces’ and the intrepid Israelis, the gung-ho Americans or the secretive British come to mind. But, it appears that it is the Indians who are the toughest of them all. This is what a gruelling contest determined last week.
The Israelis were not there, but a team of India’s 10 Special Forces (SF), led by Captain Krishnadas, outshone their counterparts from the US, South Africa, U.K., France, hosts Botswana and a clutch of African nations in the Kalahari desert.
A proud Special Forces officer says this is all the more creditable since the teams, each comprising of an officer, a non-commissioned officer and three paratroopers “were pulled out of active duty and given just two months to prepare.” This is the first time India has been invited to participate in the event. Last year’s competition was won by the South African Special Forces.
The event required a trek of 87 kms over three days with full combat load of 50 kg, all the activity being conducted under the desert sun during the day. The contest was kicked off on June 8 by a paradrop of the teams close to the border with Namibia. The events then progressively moved them east towards the Okavango Delta.
Here the team led by Major Animish Ranade suffered a mishap at the outset when Commando Mool Singh’s parachute did not open and his emergency parachute landed him so hard that he fractured his ankle. Despite the mishap that cost the team points, it won the individual prize in the 35 kms endurance march that followed.
On June 9, Capt Krishandas’s team, scored with the individual prize for the navigation segment where the commandos have to move through 20 kms of trackless desert with just a compass, Ranade’s team stood second. This was topped by a casualty evacuation exercise that required them to carry a 50 kg deadweight, simulating a casualty, for 10 kms. Krishandas’ team stood first and Ranade’s second. On the last day the teams did a 17 kms speed march and Krishandas’ team again scored a first.
The Indians performed well in the other elements of the competition as well. These included a rifle and pistol firing competition, a 400 metre an observation lane exercise requiring them to spot seven targets and a final 5 kms home run that makes the grand finale of the gathering.
A senior officer told TNN that such competitions “which deal with our core business,” are a great boost for the professional elan of the force. India currently has four SF units that have traditionally been asked to do the toughest jobs in the battlefield.
Currently they specialise in counter-terrorist work where using their own intelligence, they operate independently against terrorist concentrations in remote mountain and jungle regions in Kashmir and the Northeast.
Originally posted by American Mad Man
Originally posted by Private_parts
Who are the best??
Ok first of all US Special Forces are trained in very small areas - there are jungle units, desert units mountain units etc. ---they cannot do everything!
While all special forces are extremely tough and determined men - there are several units throughout the world that have really distinguished themselves on the battlefield.
This is just plain incorrect and false.
You act like the SEALs haven't participated in operations in Vietnam (jungle), South America (Jungle), Afghanistan (Mountains), and Iraq (Desert).
SEALs are trained for every type of insertion, that includes from submarines and HALO jumps. You act like they are only underwater demolition specialists, or CT specialists. You are just plain incorrect here.
If you want to get down to the TRUE differences, it is mainly philosophy. The Brits tend to be more cautious then others. Americans tend to be more gung-ho. Russians tend to be more ruthless. Isrealis tend to be more cunning.
Like I said before, the differences in operation capability are very small. Maybe for underwater demolition you want SEALs slightly above SBS. Maybe you want Delta force slightly ahead of SAS for CT. Maybe you want SAS slightly ahead of the Green Berrets for recon. Maybe you want the GBs slightly ahead of so and so for spurring a local uprising.
As it is, the AS were the ones that trained US special forces originally. They wrote the old testament on it. Most of what the US does is based on their training. The US has more experience now how ever in the last 2 decades.
Frankly, to really say who the "best" is, you have to go down to specific unit vs unit, and even soldier vs soldier.
Originally posted by johnwalker Christ the U.S. SF get medals for flying over countries at war! never mind fighting in them..
SAS/SBS are also the most valued and respected security personnel by far. just look at Iraq every one wants a SBS or SAS guy , nobody wants an x seal or Delta as they ride round in big shiny new 4x4 and then they wonder why they get shot to #!
Best intel- Mossad! sneaker #ers..
Best para reg - UK paras/green berets
Best mountain warefare - Mountain leaders Royal marines - simply brilliant
Best sea- SBS by far
Best ground -SAS/ASAS
Best Counter-terrorism- SAS they fire more rounds in a day than SWAT do in a year
Best Blue on Blue - US marines they #ing love it..
Originally posted by johnwalker
Best Blue on Blue - US marines they #ing love it..
Originally posted by WheelsRCool
The United States Special Operations Forces have the most funding, the most modern equipment,
the most wide amount of capabilities, and to help them they have the best aircraft, the most capable Navy, the most capable Air Force,
the GPS system which many other countries don't have
also it is the fact that the U.S. itself has so much to offer. Many countries don't have the funding to have lots of different Spec Ops forces,
they don't have the terrain to train them.
The U.S. has jungle
Great Dividing Range, extends almost the length of our east coast (tick)
mountains
Hmm, Simpson, Tanami, Great Sandy, Western, Gibber. Say, have you looked at a terrain map of Australia lately? (tick)
desert
Okay, we don't have perma-frost, but we do get snow and the Commandoes and SAS have to train there in winter. I supose we could spend the money sending them to our other continent (Antarctica), but that's a bit extreme on the budgetary side of things (so, tick)
frigid cold (Alaska)
I'd point out that the Royal Marine Commando Arctic and Mountain Warfare Cadre do (and did) their training in northern Norway, exactly where they would have been deployed to fight the Soviets and their weapons (Accuracy International L96) were designed specifically for this extreme cold.
....all right at home here in the good 'ole USA, and all that is very helpful for the training of the soldiers. Army Mountain Warfare School is on the East Coast. Marine Corps Mountain Warfare School is on the West Coast.
Originally posted by HowlrunnerIV
But USAF, the most capable? These are the guys that fly into cable cars, blow up Warriors full of Fusiliers, bomb Canadian troopers and hit BBC convoys travelling with Special Forces teams in northern Iraq...If that's the most capable support available in the world...
Originally posted by rogue1
BTW, who is the 22ASAS ?
Originally posted by HowlrunnerIV
Originally posted by rogue1
BTW, who is the 22ASAS ?
I'm assuming you know exactly who I mean.
but for anybody else, try this:
22NZSAS, 22ASAS
Getting the picture? It's a way of differentiating the numerous 22nd Special Air Service regiments in the world.