It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
The Amish don't go door-to-door or kill...are they not religious?
Originally posted by Gazrok
The Amish don't go door-to-door or kill...are they not religious?
Yes...but you were claiming that atheism was a conspiracy for control....when in the past, religion was the tool used for control, just as it is with the Amish. Don't the Amish use religion for control of their flock? In other words, it's pretty clear to see where the real conspiracy is here....
Originally posted by NotTooHappy
What!?!? You agree with NEO even though he says that you can not know if there is/isn't a "God", yet you seem to be certain that there is. Make up your mind and quit flip flopping.
Originally posted by Hyperspace
Atheism is a religion. Whether it fits technically with the semantics or not is not a concern of mine; the practical definition of religion is what matters to me, not the letter of the law.
Fine, let's see how your "practical" definition fits in with atheism
And the practical definition, distasteful though it may be to those who disdain religion in all its forms, is that the very thing most atheists hate is what they have become: a religion, with clearly defined rules, eschatology and a philosophy by which to live.
Atheists don't hate religion, they just aren't gullible and don't fall for obvious lies of religion that others fall for. No hating!
Would you please name some of those clearly defined rules? And of course please point out WHERE that rule is defined, if it's so clear to you.
Religion is a means of understanding our existence.
Is it really? I think science is the means of understanding our existance, not religion. Religion is the means of "makign sh1t up" about our existance and then claiming it to be true under threat of heresy.
Atheism fits that bill.
It fits that bill, but religion doesn't fit that bill.
Religion is a philosophy of life.
Philosophy is based upon understanding of existing phenomena, religion is making things up that no one has ever seen, then pretending like it's a given and demanding belief.
So is atheism.
Atheism may fall in that category, but not religion. Atheism believes nothing, it strives for knowledge of all things, not gullible belief and "pretend knowledge".
Religions have its leaders, the preachers of its tenets.
Having leaders/preachers doesn't make something a religion. Governments preach. Army generals preach. Your mother preaches. Does that make everything a religion? I sure hope not!
So does atheism (Nietzsche, Feuerbach, Lenin, Marx). Religion has its faithful believers, who guard the orthodoxy of the faith.
Atheism HAS no believers, sorry to burst your bubble. The whole point of Atheism is LACK of belief, but rather scientific observation of phenomena that didn't originate in the phantasy section of your brain.
So does atheism. And religion is a matter of faith, not certainty.
Atheism is a conspiracy to control you by making you think you�re free of religion, when in reality; you�re just another religious puppet.
Atheism has no doctrines, and no one forces you into it by creating "atheistic" wars that kill millions and then kill you for not following it, as most religions did/do. Conspiracy? I'd say only blind belief/following/worship of an invisible guy whose existance can't even be detected or attributed to any natural phenomena is conspiracy.
Originally posted by Gazrok
Ahh, but if Atheism is a tool of control....how is this control used?
For example, in a normal religion, I can threaten the followers' souls in the afterlife, if they don't do my bidding.... I hardly have the same level of control over an atheist who would simply say "go f yourself"
There has to be an agenda, for there to be control...and there must likewise be consequences for not adhering to the controller. With atheism, there are no consequences, hence, no control.
Fear is a one way to control (like your example about souls in the afterlife). Another way of control is rewards. It is rewarding for some to feel that they can "sin" and not be accountable (by God). An atheist is being controlled by the belief that he/she is not being controlled (held accountable by God). A false freedom if you will. There is MANY ways to control someone and some are very paradoxical in nature.
Originally posted by m0rbid
you posted in the wrong forum, but I think you did on purpose, just to gahter points you points whore.
You're lame.
Originally posted by Mycroft
Originally posted by Gazrok
Oddly enough, I don't think you'll see people killing in the name of Atheism, nor going door to door to try and convert others....
Atheism is the ony religion that tries to convert you by calling you stupid.
Fear is a one way to control (like your example about souls in the afterlife). Another way of control is rewards. It is rewarding for some to feel that they can "sin" and not be accountable (by God). An atheist is being controlled by the belief that he/she is not being controlled (held accountable by God). A false freedom if you will. There is MANY ways to control someone and some are very paradoxical in nature.
Originally posted by Journey
I sense some conflict here- Satyr. From reading this post, and comparing it to the one in which you replied to my recent topic on Floridas' Faith based prison, and I quote you again- this is in response to my question regarding convicts rights over our childrens in school-
Posted by Satyr- Floridas' Faith Based Prison
"This is where we differ the most. You think that a repression of religion is the cause of every existing problem today. I think that living in your fantasy religion word is anti-productive, and anti-progressive. Prayer doesn't solve anything, action and understanding does. Prayer only boosts morale in those who want to believe. I can't say this enough times; religion is not morality. If anything, it's hypocrisy. The problems you face today are considerably less than those that existed when religious organizations ruled. That was a horrible time, and will always be remembered as some of the most brutal, inhumane times of all history. It's very easy for me to argue the exact opposite...that the decline of religious activity is the reason people aren't brutally tortured or stoned to death as often now."
I do realize that you did not directly say that you are a believer in God, but I feel something here, and I wanted to pass this on to you and all the others-
You will never be sorry -
for thinking before acting,
for hearing before judging,
for forgiving your enemies,
for being candid and frank,
for helping a fallen brother,
for being honest in business,
for thinking before speaking,
for praying and seeking God,
for standing by your principles,
for stopping your ears to gossip,
for bridling a slanderous tounge,
for trying to harbor good thoughts,
for sympathising with the afflicted,
for being courteous and kind to all.
- Anonomous
Why believe in atheism? What benefits are there to believing in atheism ?
Look ya'll, I am not some Bible toting religous zealot, and I am not into organised religon. I have gone to church- but it's been a while.
Yes, there are bad and corrupt religous leaders. But, we are human, and there will always be some who preach whatever it is (atheism being one) and religon being another ( yeah, it's big money).
But, I try to live by the above mentioned paragraph and for me- I'll take Heaven any day over Hell-
What is the benefit to being an atheist? That is what you should ask yourself....
Atheism is not a religon, I agree. Who benefits from disbelief in God? Only one, and I will not even post the name-
If there wasn't truth to God's existense, and his fallen angel, the stories and bibles and preachings would not be where they are today. There are many secrets- and this is the reason why we are all here reading this thread. For without secrets, all the stories would not be told and retold again and again, generation after generation, age after age.
If there wasn't truth- many of you would not be wondering and seeking the reality of God's existence.
Miracles happen every day- look at yourself- for you are a miracle.
Yes, we live in a cruel world- but we made it that way. We have free will, to believe or not- todays current situations are created by us- and the disbelief of many.
Take a set of scales and imagine evil on one side, and good on the other. It all depends on which side you rest upon- and the scale will surely take you in that direction you rested on-
You do not have to go to church , to believe in God. You do not have to become involved in organised religon to secure your entry through the pearly gates-
Just belief and a little prayer does me good- and you can look at my words and laugh at me, I don't care-
For I am- A Believer in God.
Another fact I wish to disclose- this observation came from the tounge of a real sick man, as we were driving down I-10 in Mississippi. I found it very intriguing-
You know (my name), I want you to see this- and I asked "what?" And he replied...if you look deep into every object we see- there is a cross in it! And as I thought of his words, I began to see- for there is a cross- in every thing you look at! Call me crazy , I don't care- if you look at whatever it is- the cross is there.
Peace to all- and may God bless everyone-especially all the atheists. For they are lacking- and their beliefs will try, but never be- religous doctrine.
Originally posted by Hyperspace
Fear is a one way to control (like your example about souls in the afterlife). Another way of control is rewards. It is rewarding for some to feel that they can "sin" and not be accountable (by God). An atheist is being controlled by the belief that he/she is not being controlled (held accountable by God). A false freedom if you will. There is MANY ways to control someone and some are very paradoxical in nature.
Originally posted by Gazrok
Fear is a one way to control (like your example about souls in the afterlife). Another way of control is rewards. It is rewarding for some to feel that they can "sin" and not be accountable (by God). An atheist is being controlled by the belief that he/she is not being controlled (held accountable by God). A false freedom if you will. There is MANY ways to control someone and some are very paradoxical in nature.
So, atheists are automatically immoral people???