It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
You can't win an argument with a wack-job wanna be terrorist guys and gals.
Originally posted by dbates
We interrupt this downward spiral of this thread in to a slug-fest to remind everyone to be nice and courteous towards all the other fine members here. Even if we differ on opinion we can all still get along and discuss things rationally. Along with the opposable thumb, this is what separates us from the animals out there.
Originally posted by XyZeR
Why cause he sais things you'dd rather not hae know about you country ?
Originally posted by Souljah
FIRST STEP,
would be to STOP LYING. That's a Nice start. But it wont Happen anyway, so I guess we will have to Wait for the TRUTH to come out. Because it will; one way or the Other.
Originally posted by devilwasp
Souljah,
I notice you keep bringing up the geneva conventions, the laws of war and varios other articles defining how war and human rights should be conducted...
Now my question is this...Do you believe in these laws?
Originally posted by Souljah
What does it Matter what I belive in?
These Laws were Written for a Certain Purpose - so that EVERYBODY can Enjoy the same Rights and Priviledges, so that nobody is "Left Behind".
They were written in order to bring some Sanity and Humanity to this World, torn apart by MANY Wars.
What would happen, if the Cops would not follow the Criminal Law in the Wolrd we have today?
So, how can the US (along with UK) tell the Entire World what to do, while they are breaking the Same Law, which they are suppoesd to Uphold?
Isn't that a little bit Hypocritical?
Originally posted by devilwasp
Stop lieing? About what? Everything?
What do define as the "truth" ? My perception of the truth or the facts?
"There are no whole truths: all truths are half-truths. It is trying to treat them as whole truths that plays the devil."
Alfred North Whitehead,
Tell me what "truth" do you believe?
No matter how it is spread, propaganda comes in four basic varieties, said Arthur Siegel, social science professor at York University in Toronto, whose 1996 book Radio Canada International examines World War II and Cold War propaganda.
“The first level is the Big Lie, adapted by Hitler and Stalin. The state-controlled Egyptian press has been spreading a Big Lie, saying the World Trade Center was attacked by Israel to embarrass Arabs,” said Siegel.
“The second layer says, ‘It doesn't have to be the truth, so long as it's plausible.’
“The third strategy is to tell the truth but withhold the other side's point of view.
“The fourth and most productive is to tell the truth, the good and the bad, the losses and the gains.
“Governments in Western society take the last three steps. They avoid the Big Lie, which nobody here will swallow,” Siegel said.
Beth Gillin, U.S. intensifies the war of words
Originally posted by ludaChris
greenleft and world socialist website's names speak for themselves. Cmon folks, am I the only one looking for things like this. Checking sources is something that is important to make sure we are getting accurate information and not someones agenda.
Originally posted by XyZeR
Why cause he sais things you'dd rather not hae know about you country ?
Originally posted by me
You can't win an argument with a wack-job wanna be terrorist guys and gals.
Smart reaction
Originally posted by Souljah
obviously you know Nothing about the War, Propaganda and the Media's Role here.
Propaganda serves to JUSTIFY the War at all costs - every conflict is fought on at least two grounds: the Battlefield and the Minds of the people via propaganda.
The Good guys and the Bad guys can often both be guilty of misleading their people with Distortions, Exaggerations, Subjectivity, Inaccuracy and even Fabrications, in order to receive Support and a sense of legitimacy.
Military control of Information during war time is also a major contributing factor to propaganda, especially when the media go along with it without question. The military recognizes the values of media and information control very well.
What makes you THINK that the Goverments of US and UK are Telling the TRUTH this time?
Originally posted by devilwasp
How about all the good thigns happeneing in iraq? Are they ever shown by the media? No is the answer.
Well done you've explained what ONE use of propaganda is about, how about the other propaganda against war?
Good guys? Bad guys?
In war there are netheir!
Onlyv you and the men next to you are the good guys, the bad guys are who YOU percieve and there are no even drawn lines to define them.
Give a rest with the qoutes, we can play a qoutes war all day and night.
Yes and not just the military, the terrorists, freedom fighter, rebels, conspiricy theorists and political parties use the media and information to control the war. See majics podcast.
What makes me think they are telling the truth about the war?
I think they are telling the truth about the war because I trust them a hell of a lot more than I trust the insurgents.
Tell me, does the iraqi insurgency conduct propaganda?
Yes it does is the answer, yet.....there are no threads about that on ATS at all...
Does the iraqi "resisitance" conduct warcrimes?
Yes it does is the answer yet....the threads that are posted about it recieve little or no coverage OR are debunked as pro coalition propaganda...
Originally posted by Souljah
Good Things? Such as? You mean the GOOD News that our skippytjc is "reporting" all of the time, with the "Viva Iraq!" ending?
Seriously, the situation in Iraq is FAR from "Good" - it is a F.U.B.A.R. situation and it will just get worse.
The Independant Media is IMHO the only one who counts here - because frankly, they got nothing to loose if the War stops or goes on forever - they will still be around, reporting what they have actually SEEN, and not what they Want you to SEE.
If you haven't noticed, there are Good vs. Bad in this War also. Basicly it is a matter of Perspective, yet again. The Coalition is out there to Fight the Bad Terrorists - and the Insurgents are out there to Fight the Bad Invaders.
You wanna?
Are you saying that I "Control" the War?
The Question here is, WHO has MORE money to Conduct a BETTER and More Sofisticated Propaganda War here?
The US ARMY?
The Iraqi Insurgents?
The Independant Media?
The Corporate Media?
Independant Individuals?
See? You really do not have a Clue about War, Propaganda and Media.
The Army HAS to Lie in order to maintain the Peoples support of the War.
That is why they have Information Officers.
That is why they have PsyOps.
That is why they have Propaganda Officers.
Sure they do
Oh Please!
The Media are doing a Damn Fine Job Demonizing the Iraqi Insurgency.
It is the other way around - you do not hear News, such as is the first post of this thread from the Guardian - very often. The Coalition is the Bastion of Liberty, Democracy and TRUTH; everything else are LIES!
Originally posted by devilwasp
Why not look and find out, skippy is one man alone on this board the ENTIRE MEDIA is against the war almost.
So speaks the voice of reason and knowledge?
I'll listen to people I respect and trust before I take your word thank you VERY much.
Independant media?
Your trying to say that no one is reporting thier opinion and not the whole story? GEEE wow your right!
Depends what "war" you mean but no you simply add to the firepower.
The insurgents since they can play the wounded oppressd people position while the coalition is restricted to playing down the "truth and freedom" position, they cant use the media too much because the media doesnt trust them.
You and the bloody army, god sake man think out side your box.
There are 3 diffrent services!
I dont gee wow and what should make me trust you?
Or trust anyone?
Thats paranioa.
The army has 0 lies to maintain support, why? Because thats not the army's job. The governments job is that, oh and btw if your wondering there is a unit designed for "hearts and minds" , its a tri service made up of part timers.
They have no propaganda officers, thats nazi germany and the soviet forces.
Thank you for telling the truth!
Now the better question:
Why are you not reporting this if you hate lies and the truth being distorted?
Is this possibly because you have an agenda?
Oh so your now avoiding the question?
I thought you hated lies and wanted the truth?
Well I have a qoute for you!
"You want the truth? You cant handle the truth!"
I put it to you and ATS that YOU , soljah , cant accept the fact that the iraqi insurgency conducts and fights JUST AS BAD as the coalition, the coalition has done wrong I accept that but they do so by accident and not by choice, heres another question for you?
Can you say the same for the insurgency?
Originally posted by Souljah
Most People in Developing World cannot Afford to buy FOOD!
Hey - buts thats their Problem, right? If they DIE on daily basis because of Severe Malnutrition, thats all Fine. It's their Fault anyway - why don't they get a Decent Job?
Thats why we have a GLOBAL Warming Effect - see if you Effect a BIG Ocean such as Atlantic or Pacific, you put the Delicate Natural Balance out of balance, thus creating a Worldwide BUTTERFLY Effect.
As long as you have drive your BIG American Cars, to go and eat in your BIG American Drive-Ins, and you go in your BIG Americna Wal-Marts - SCREW THE REST!
America was founded on 3 Things: GUNS, MONEY and POWER. And those 3 are their Main Export since.