It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: jofafot
originally posted by: CarlLaFong
originally posted by: jofafot
a reply to: DBCowboy
You really think the ME was at peace?
Wow.
History cannot be found on the pages of wiki.
Wikipedia does its job as a quick information source with all references included.
You realize Wikipedia can be easily manipulated as propaganda. Yes?
Not only that but I also realize this point is only made up when someone needs an emergency exit from arguing.
originally posted by: CarlLaFong
originally posted by: jofafot
originally posted by: CarlLaFong
originally posted by: jofafot
a reply to: DBCowboy
You really think the ME was at peace?
Wow.
History cannot be found on the pages of wiki.
Wikipedia does its job as a quick information source with all references included.
You realize Wikipedia can be easily manipulated as propaganda. Yes?
Not only that but I also realize this point is only made up when someone needs an emergency exit from arguing.
So you DO know Wikipedia is not a reliable source...yet you sing it's praises, all the same.
Why?
You realize Wikipedia can be easily manipulated as propaganda.
originally posted by: jofafot
Which is proven wrong and you'd know that if you actually bothered reading quotes and source of those quotes in my previous messages. Don't worry, wikipedia have been putting references to make sure they are not fake for a long time. You can follow it and see who said what. So go on, don't be scared of finding the truth.
originally posted by: jofafot
Your point falls apart if I say yes, you realize this, right?
Can you get to your main point in all this?
Current israel, west bank, gaza were referred as "palestine" when ottomans ruled those lands and they were infact mostly peaceful. However, sh!t seems hit the fan whenever ottomans lost control of these lands then got peaceful again when they got control back
I find you reality of peace has many grey areas in it
then we can actually talk about what has been going on there is a very down-to-earth level of communication. So where did you live, and we can talk about it.
Whatever
originally posted by: jofafot
Your reading comprehension must be very bad but sure, let me copy-paste the samething I've been saying for several posts
Current israel, west bank, gaza were referred as "palestine" when ottomans ruled those lands and they were infact mostly peaceful. However, sh!t seems hit the fan whenever ottomans lost control of these lands then got peaceful again when they got control back
Eh, not really. I have been making the same point(peace under ottoman rule) while you have been busy with not understanding me and changing your points(ottoman wars, saddam, africa...).
originally posted by: cherokeetroy
What are we, 12?
The ME can be as religious as it wants to be but the bottom line is Money Talks. That's the way it's always been.
I didn't give myself 8 stars, obviously.
Well, the fact that I don't read every post you make doesn't mean I have a reading comprehension issue. Why do you feel the need to attack my me personally now?
Muslims hate each other and have zero concerns about killing each other.
When I say Whatever, I mean there really isn't much more to say unless you want to rehash the same lines over and over again.
originally posted by: Xtrozero
Well, no they are not. Both Jordan and Saudi supported Israel when Iran launched missiles. There is no such thing as Palestine, it was recently invented in the last 100 years to describe these groups of people. The people in The Wast Bank and Gaza are Jordanians and Egyptians by DNA, culture, and religion. The word Palestine was invented by a foreign conquer to describe uncharted areas of Egypt
They are nothing more than groups of refugees no one wanted. Jordan and Egypt dumped their troubles on to Israel as they did not let them go one foot into their own countries. If the ME really wanted to fix it, they could, but some countries like to use them as cannon fodder against Israel.
originally posted by: cherokeetroy
In other words, you have no rebuttal.
Well, no they are not. Both Jordan and Saudi supported Israel when Iran launched missiles. There is no such thing as Palestine, it was recently invented in the last 100 years to describe these groups of people. The people in The Wast Bank and Gaza are Jordanians and Egyptians by DNA, culture, and religion. The word Palestine was invented by a foreign conquer to describe uncharted areas of Egypt
originally posted by: jofafot
I am still against generalization not only because I find it always wrong but also due to my personal experience with them but as you've previously said in one of your messages: "Whatever"
originally posted by: Danvero
The term Palestine first appeared in the 5th century when the ancient Greek historian Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistine" between Phoenicia and Egypt in The Histories. We commonly hear that the Romans eventually imposed the alien name "Palestine" on Israel or Judaea.
Following the Ottoman conquest in 1517, the Land was divided into four districts and attached administratively to the province of Damascus and ruled from Istanbul. At the outset of the Ottoman era, an estimated 1,000 Jewish families lived in the country, mainly in Jerusalem, Nablus (Shechem), Hebron, Gaza, Safed (Tzfat) and the villages of Galilee. The community was comprised of descendants of Jews who had never left the Land as well as immigrants from North Africa and Europe.
As I have said, it was a word used by conquering nations to label a large area, there were no nations called Palestine. Judaea has been around long before anyone else in the area.
You say the Ottoman Empire had peace for 400 years and I'm saying the only way they did that was with extreme control over the population. They were a warlord conquering nation, not nice guys in any way you look at it.
The Muslim, Christian, and Jewish communities of Palestine were allowed to exercise jurisdiction over their own members according to charters granted to them. For centuries the Jews and Christians had enjoyed a large degree of communal autonomy in matters of worship, jurisdiction over personal status, taxes, and in managing their schools and charitable institutions. In the 19th century those rights were formally recognized as part of the Tanzimat reforms and when the communities were placed under the protection of European public law.
originally posted by: Xtrozero
originally posted by: AliceTheSmall
But they aren't. They're uniting together to stand up for Palestine.
Well, no they are not. Both Jordan and Saudi supported Israel when Iran launched missiles. There is no such thing as Palestine, it was recently invented in the last 100 years to describe these groups of people. The people in The Wast Bank and Gaza are Jordanians and Egyptians by DNA, culture, and religion. The word Palestine was invented by a foreign conquer to describe uncharted areas of Egypt
They are nothing more than groups of refugees no one wanted. Jordan and Egypt dumped their troubles on to Israel as they did not let them go one foot into their own countries. If the ME really wanted to fix it, they could, but some countries like to use them as cannon fodder against Israel.