Guess the Writers... ATS Challenge

a reply to: Encia22

I just checked. Only 63 members are logged on to ATS right now.

a reply to: FaceTheCrazyTruth

a reply to: pthena

6 + 3 = 9 Such a magical number.

Friends, Writers, Contestants... I'm pooped!

Shutting down for maintenance ...

Carry on and, for the love of God, someone guess the right answers... Pleeeaaasssee

a reply to: Encia22

I read that whole thing and didn't see a question.

originally posted by: Encia22
Friends, Writers, Contestants... I'm pooped!

Shutting down for maintenance ...

Carry on and, for the love of God, someone guess the right answers... Pleeeaaasssee

Encia, Blend, JJ Productions and DBCowboy. Final answer.

Logic works better than emotions

My next best guess is people, pthena, Encia... Damn...
i should wait if nugget has 3 out of 4 too, but I'll just go wit DTOM as the 4th writer?

if this is true:

Blend, Enica, Pthena, and Peeple. 3/4
JJ productions, Enica, Pthena, and Peeple 3/4

it has to be Encia, Pthena, blend and JJ

a reply to: Peeple

Always with the deflections

a reply to: Terpene

always with the paranoia...

a reply to: Peeple

No, you've been logically determined to be one of the writers.

Both combinations of

Blend, Pthena, Encia, and yourself
JJproductions, Pthena, Encia, and yourself

We're confirmed to be 3/4 correct

Logically the three like writers must be correct given other information known.

In the Blend, Pthena, Encia, and Peeple response if you were the odd one out then my response of JJproductions, Pthena, Encia, and peeple would be 2/4, unless JJ Productions was correct, but that writer was elimated by combining other answers like participation. 3/4 have responded in this thread + at least 1 didn't enter WFS2023. Unless I falsely eliminated Blend and JJproductions. Which I may have done.

I gaslit myself here.

Blend, Enica, Pthena, and JJproductions.

Is either 2/4... (or 4/4, and you were first, if I screwed up my logic). It's either game over or a mystery writer left.

All I know is several of you are in The Monty Hall position right now.

a reply to: Degradation33

What are you doing? using logical deduction to tease People.

This is ATS it's all emotion based reasoning

a reply to: Degradation33

That has to be it. now we only got to assign the paragraphs to the right writer.

a reply to: Peeple

I couldn't replicate eliminating either Blend or JJproductions, so I made a logic error. I think I falsely eliminated one of them taking an answer out of context.

So I'm inclined to believe you, your responses have not necessarily been deceptive. It is just a matter of order.

This is where I screwed up:

Where we are:

Blend, Enica, Pthena, and Peeple. 3/4
JJ productions, Enica, Pthena, and Peeple 3/4

Only one way to both be 3/4

The missing writer hasn't posted In this thread.
And may not have submitted a story either.

Can I ask about the missing writer specifically?

Two ways to be 3/4. Should have asked if I got the same 3/4 and eliminated one.

That's funny.

* Note - I have only your responses to eliminate you. But I'm trying not to be paranoid.

Brain tired, sleep now.

a reply to: nugget1

My dear nugget1, lovely to see you partake of this nobel challenge.

Let's see, rolling the dice...



3/4, so close, and yet not quite there.

a reply to: Terpene

Good, but not there yet. Perhaps, you should have waited...



2 out of 4 are correct.

a reply to: Peeple

Your savvy and intuition has accompanied you well in this arduous journey; shall we see just how far...



C O N G R A T U L A T I O N S ! !

Someone will DM later with your prizes!



To everyone else, immense thanks for participating, you each deserve a prize, but as there can only be one winner, I'll just leave you with a token of our appreciation...



Stay tuned for more exciting challenges and adventures...

a reply to: Peeple

Very good, Peeple... if you can guess that, then the Challenge is well and truly won.

We'll let that brew for a while... a little later all will be REAVELED...

a reply to: Encia22

No I can't accept it, because it was really Degradation33 who figured it out, I just put it together when she got stuck.
That would seem incredible unfair.

a reply to: Peeple

Most humblest of sentiments, Peeple!



Computing.... Please wait...