Matt Walsh's documentary: What is a woman?

a reply to: DBCowboy

Indeed. In the vast majority of cases men and women have XY and XX chromosomal make up.

Let's say you have XXY then you are still a male with Klinefelter syndrome. This is a syndrome and not a new gender as some activists are suggesting showing how irrelevant they are with basic human biology and genetics.

It becomes even more absurd when they try to argue in terms of intersex.

a reply to: Asmodeus3

I'm so glad you posted this -- thank you.

Matt Walsh has been doing some great work in this area. I've had a couple of the same links, and a couple additional links, open for days, just taunting me to start a thread, but I never did.

So I hope it's okay if I drop them here. Here is a little bit more on where Vanderbilt University's program is now, after Walsh's investigation and others raised concerns --

“This page could not be found.”

Internet users are now met with that message — small black font at the center of a white screen — after Vanderbilt University Medical Center (VUMC) seemingly erased the website that once housed information about its “Pediatric Transgender Clinic,” according to an Aug. 31 archive of the site.

VUMC apparently removed the landing page for its “Pediatric Transgender Clinic” following a now-viral Twitter thread posted by The Daily Wire’s Matt Walsh, who unearthed videos purportedly showing Vanderbilt employees celebrating its overarching “transgender clinic,” which opened in 2018, as a “big money maker” for the Nashville-based medical center.

Vanderbilt Faces Intense Backlash Over 'Pediatric Transgender Clinic,' Faith Leaders Speak Out

And this --

Tennessee Republican Governor Bill Lee has called for an investigation of the Pediatric Transgender Clinic at Vanderbilt University Medical Center (VUMC) after shocking videos posted by Matt Walsh detailed a doctor’s promotion of “big money maker” transgender surgeries.

The videos obtained by Walsh also show apparent threats made against medical professionals at VUMC if they objected to the procedures, even for religious reasons.

“The ‘pediatric transgender clinic’ at Vanderbilt University Medical Center raises serious moral, ethical and legal concerns...” Lee said in a statement to The Daily Wire.

Go v. Bill Lee Calls For Investigation Of Vanderbilt’s Pediatric Transgender Clinic Following Matt Walsh Revelation

And another video --

There have always been transgender people among us. Most just tried to fly under the radar and live their life as their prefered gender, at great peril if found out.

The Native Americans believed transgenders were honored gy the gods with two spirits and gave them a higher status.

I don't care what an adult chooses to identify as, but I do care that it's being ce;ebrated with special treatment, in our face 24/7 and being used against us to destroy our children. THAT isn't LGBTQ+ism; that's perversion and qualifies as extreme child abuse, IMO.

a reply to: Asmodeus3

Take the conflict in Ukraine as an example, no one knows what to believe and neither do they want to believe either sides news reporting about it.

That is the uncertainty principle of subjectivity weaponized, the masses are so dumbed down and confused they don't even know a man from a woman anymore.

Meanwhile in the background the elite do as they will, they're the elite class, we're just the animals.

Yes that was a pun at Richard Dawkins... ever wonder how he was elevated to be a voice in academia?

There you have it...

a reply to: Boadicea

Hi there! Feel free to post whatever you think is relevant.

Matt has been very outspoken and well done to him! Others have also criticised this absurd ideology that tries to indoctrinate children and silence criticism and censor everyone and everything.

This must be stopped. Best way to deal with this ideology is science and facts. It can't deal with them.

a reply to: nugget1

I don't have an issue either with the way one identifies.

If they ask me whether their identification is correct I will still reply that it is not correct as a woman or a man isn't one who identifies as a woman or a man respectively but someone who has the biological markers XX and XY.

Other than that I don't have a problem with the individual transgender people but with the ideology, the activists, and the financial interests who are trying to use these activists and even some scientists to indoctrinate and brainwash young kids as well as adults.

a reply to: Asmodeus3

I just noticed you're a newbie -- welcome!

I agree wholeheartedly with you. It's gone too far and for too long and needs to stop.

I would also add that we are not only dealing with delusions and mental disorders, but male sexual fetishes (called "autogynephilia") being passed off as something else. These autogynephiles are distinguished as heterosexual men who are sexually aroused by pretending/portraying themselves as women, and having others treat them like women. As opposed to homosexual men, usually more effeminate, who feel more like women than men, who do think they have "lady brain" in a male body.

Autogynephiles have a much higher rate of sexual offenses and violent crimes against women than other men. Hence pose a greater risk to women and girls/boys in single-sex spaces like bathrooms and changing rooms and even women's prisons.

It must be stopped.

a reply to: Boadicea

It is indeed a case of delusions, beliefs, and ideologies.

Also you have to factor genuine gender dysphoria which was classified as a mental disorder sometime ago but no longer is considered as
such. However it does exist.

I am not quite sure if transgender individuals have one way or the other some sort of mental disorder. Trans-people are not considered as people suffering from mental disorders but this is debatable. At least from what I have seen online.

Yes I am aware of the case you have described.

But in any case how can a woman feel comfortable having a biological man in their changing rooms? With or without disorders, straight or gay, trans or not trans.

www.mayoclinic.org...

originally posted by: Grenade
a reply to: Asmodeus3

If you want to mutilate your own genitals then you need to see a psychiatrist, not a surgeon.

I have to agree with you.

See however how cynical one of the surgeons is in the documentary. And it happens to be...A transwoman! One of the very few cases where the person who is propagating this nonsensical ideology isn't an uneducated activist. In this case is someone with good academic credentials who is cynical about operations and who gains a lot financially from these operations.

Of course he will promote them as harmless routine operations...

Another great article!

www.science.org...#:~:text=The%20sex%20chromosomes%20of%20mammals,genes%20key%20to%20tes tes%20formation

From the article:

"The sex chromosomes of mammals have evolved over millions of years, originating from two identical chromosomes. Now, males possess one X and one Y chromosome and females have two Xs. The presence or absence of the Y chromosome is what determines sex"Text presence or absence of the Y chromosome is what determines sex"


Just as I have explained it earlier.
Biological sex is entirely determined by the Y chromosome and not by politics.

Does anyone else see how absurd is to say:

'A woman is whoever identifies as a woman'

And then to threaten you and everyone else that if you don't accept someone's : 'gender identity' then you are a bigot and a transphobe...

a reply to: Boadicea

There is indeed a great motivation behind this orchestrated campaign to 'educate' as many kids as possible in terms of what is gender and how gender can be changed. It's profit

The more potential clients there are, and there could many as the audience is huge and can easily be manipulated, indoctrinated, and brainwashed, then the greater the profit. This is a lucrative business!

1) Drugs and councelling before the gender affirming surgery.

2) Gender affirming surgery or surgeries.

3) Drugs and councelling after the surgery or surgeries.

It creates the need for never-ending intervention and dependence on potentially harmful drugs. Not to mention the effects of the surgery or surgeries themselves that could be detrimental or even catastrophic to someone's health.

a reply to: Asmodeus3

And don't forget the clinics, where there's money to be made they always seem to pop up.

Rep. Harshbarger: Pediatric Transgender Clinic an 'Abomination

www.newsmax.com...

a reply to: iamthevirus

Rep. Diana Harshbarger

'Vanderbilt is a fine institution but the words pediatric [and] transgender should never be used in the same sentence'

I cannot agree more!

I never understood how on Earth a little child is aware of his/her sexuality and 'gender identity'.
There must be some adults doing the work and indoctrinate these children.

lgbt.uni.edu...#:~:text=Woman%20(noun)-,A%20person%2C%20who%20regardless%20of%20their%20sex%20assigned%20at%20birth,and%20ident ifies%20as%20a%20woman.


If you want to have a flavour how the gender ideology tries to twist definitions and make claims that are at odds with reality and science here is the gender identity terminology on the LGBT site of the University of Northern Iowa

Definition of a woman:

'A person, who regardless of their sex assigned at birth, identifies as a woman. The term cisgender woman (or ciswoman) describes someone who was assigned female at birth and identifies as a woman. The term transgender woman (or transwoman) describes someone who was assigned male at birth and identifies as a woman.'


First of all, sex is not assigned by anyone. Biological sex is an immutable characteristic of humans.

A woman is one that identifies as a woman as they claim. Which is a circular and medmingless definition. You can't use what you want to define in the definition itself and moreover you still haven't defined what is it that you try to identify with.

I wonder whether all those activists and proponents of the gender ideology have had any basic science or math lessons in their lives.

This is where I feel we are going with this. The activists are the Cardassians, and we, well we're Picard.

"THERE ARE TWO SEXES!"

"I AM A WOMAN, A MOTHER, I BREAST FEED!"

And some poor lady wrote an Op-Ed for the NYT arguing that tomboys are not trans and she's getting blasted for that. Well, I am a tomboy. I have a personality type that leads me to have some more masculine thought patters, but never once have I thought I was maybe a boy trapped in a girl's body. Why? I looked at my body and it was self-evident to me what I was, no matter who strangely I might seem to express that.

a reply to: Asmodeus3

I hate, hate, hate cisgender!

It's like Latinx. A bunch of academic eggheads decided it needed a label because it offended to call people normal, so they made it up and saddled us with it.

I deny it every opportunity I get and tell people it's offensive.

a reply to: Asmodeus3

Yes, I'm well aware of the profit motive. As always -- follow the money! The medical community is literally creating lifelong medical dependence and dependents. Which explains why these drugs and surgeries are being provided, despite the many many risks and warning signs. It's simple supply and demand economics.

But we also need to understand why folks want these drugs and surgeries to begin with -- the "demand" side -- what motivates them to "identify" as something other than their biological/anatomical sex, and put our efforts into working to reduce the desire and demand. Not fulfill the desire/demand.

All transgenders are not the same -- despite TRAs wanting to believe they are. Genuine gender dysphoria is just one reason, and perhaps the minority reason at this point. Males can generally be divided into heterosexual (autogynephile) and homosexual, with the vast majority falling in the autogynephile category. These are more likely to be the loud and proud TRAs, as opposed to the homosexuals who do simply want to live their life as a woman in peace and quiet, and the same for lesbians who simply want to live their life as a man in peace and quiet. There are also disturbing trends in children, especially girls, and especially autistic girls, who have "identified" as transgender for less understood reasons.

I have no problem with folks breaking or embracing whatever gender norms they want. I think society in general can use a little gender bending, and stop much of the sexism that pervades our world in both blatant and in insidious ways.

a reply to: Boadicea

I'm not autistic, but I do have the personality type described as INTJ through Meyers-Briggs. It would have put me "at-risk" I feel had I been growing up in today's society.

Simply put, my thought patterns are more logical, more masculine than most women's. Females with my personality type tend to identify more with men than we do with women because we tend to have thought patterns that are more like a man's than a woman's. That doesn't make us men, but it can make us feel alien - like we don't ever quite fit in, especially as we are growing up and maturing. Take someone like that and put them in a situation where they have low self-esteem or struggle with not being able to fit in, and they are at risk for being targeted with trans ideology and needing that acceptance.

While I am not autistic, what I have read is that autistic girls, particularly Aspy's also struggle with fitting in with regular female society.

As someone with a more INTJ personality, I don't see the need for the most of the inane social dance women and girls tend to engage in. Aspy's just don't tend to be able to read it because they are impaired that way. We don't fit in. For me, it's because I mainly don't care to and find it annoying and dull. Who cares about makeup, hair, clothes, and who's dating whom? For Aspy's it's because they just plain miss it and will struggle with it all their lives.

Women are more socially complex, and if you aren't into that, it makes life, particularly adolescent life, sucky for you.

a reply to: ketsuko

Well, you're preaching to the choir here. I was never a "typical" girly girl, never wanted to be, and still don't. But neither was "tomboy" a bad word, so I never felt any need to be concerned about it. And with three brothers, it doesn't hurt to be a little rough and tumble! It's not like I couldn't change my jeans for a pretty dress... or curl my hair instead of a ponytail... or anything else. It was my choice. I chose. I was happy with my choice.

But there are plenty of reasons for people to feel like they don't belong or don't fit in. I'm not sure why people want to "fit" where they don't, or "belong" where they don't. And perhaps we should be looking harder at that?

Isn't that exactly what transgender persons are trying to do? Force themselves into spaces where they don't "fit" and don't "belong"?