Gaps in Melania Trump's immigration story raise questions

originally posted by: Indigo5

originally posted by: xuenchen
So is there any actual proof of all these claims?

Melania has said repeatedly and even now in response to this, that she came here in 1996..

Her roommate in NYC in 1995, paychecks, Magazine staff and the Photo-Shoot all put her here in 1995.

There is a lot of evidence. But apparently you haven't read the OP?

Even in 1996...she would have been here on a tourist visa that would have forbid her to work.

Her entire story about immigrating here does not comport with the known facts.

My wife and I are going through green card paperwork and I know for a fact that you can apply for a work permit on a student visa. Did Melania definitely come here as a tourist ? You can work on a work visa, fiancee visa, student visa ...

originally posted by: Nikola014
a reply to: Annee

Hillary is a corrupted criminal

Hearsay, unless you can prove it.

a reply to: Indigo5

Many models come into countries using tourist visas. For example when they do sports illustrated t hey use tourist visas when they do shoots on places like Belize. It's standard practice and not a big deal.

originally posted by: chris_stibrany

originally posted by: Indigo5

originally posted by: xuenchen
So is there any actual proof of all these claims?

Melania has said repeatedly and even now in response to this, that she came here in 1996..

Her roommate in NYC in 1995, paychecks, Magazine staff and the Photo-Shoot all put her here in 1995.

There is a lot of evidence. But apparently you haven't read the OP?

Even in 1996...she would have been here on a tourist visa that would have forbid her to work.

Her entire story about immigrating here does not comport with the known facts.

My wife and I are going through green card paperwork and I know for a fact that you can apply for a work permit on a student visa. Did Melania definitely come here as a tourist ? You can work on a work visa, fiancee visa, student visa ...

Wouldn't it be simple enough to prove?

All they have to do is show the paperwork.

I will never vote for Trump or Hillary for POTUS. If Trump supporters see no problem with "Mr. Make America Great Again" having an agenda to deport millions of people here illegally when his 3rd foreign trophy wife may herself have come here illegally is just being willfully hypocritical.

I think ole Donald and Bill are cut from the same cloth, both are big buddies with Epstein and both have been connected with his underage sex parties, both have been accused of rape. Yeah, Yeah......ALL powerful men are accused of rape..NOT ! Does the morality and integrity , or lack of, from both the Clinton's and Trump's mean nothing to people !?

originally posted by: ugmold
a reply to: Indigo5
I think I may need to do a little more investigation before I can form an opinion, do you have a link to the nude photo shoot? Good place to start.

You are going to have to investigate that on your own, but they are out there.

Now Redsate:

So why is any of this even important?

It becomes very important when Donald Trump has made illegal immigration the cornerstone of his campaign.

It’s bad form to have one set of standards for those from countries that don’t appeal to you and another set for those where you’re fishing for your next wife.

www.redstate.com...

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Nikola014
a reply to: Annee

Hillary is a corrupted criminal

Hearsay, unless you can prove it.

Hillary was born in America... hearsay unless you can prove it...

We will require Introverts standard of proof here... you must have a legal notarized copy of a film showing Hillary's birth... otherwise...who knows,,, birth certificates are worthless as evidence, as noted in the Obama fiasco.

Yes sir we require proof,,, notarized eyewitness testimony from no less than 5 people who witnessed Hillarys birth with their own eyeballs and are willing to take a lie detector test.

Otherwise... I say she was born in outer Mongolia.

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: LSU0408
a reply to: Indigo5

Oh noes! Not Melania coming here on a short term visa, anything but that! This is turrable!

It matters because of Donald's stance on illegal immigration.

Are illegal Slovenians running around breaking American laws and taking over cities? Do we have a Slovenian flag flying over the US flag at posts offices in towns overrun by illegal Slovenians? Are they smuggling drugs into America? Forcing us to put Slovenian writing just below the Spanish that was forced just below the English on everything because they come here not knowing the native language?

originally posted by: dragonridr
a reply to: Indigo5

Many models come into countries using tourist visas. For example when they do sports illustrated t hey use tourist visas when they do shoots on places like Belize. It's standard practice and not a big deal.

I expect some have work permits from their company.

My former son-in-law was Canadian, working for a Canadian company in the USA. He had a work permit through the company.

originally posted by: LSU0408

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: LSU0408
a reply to: Indigo5

Oh noes! Not Melania coming here on a short term visa, anything but that! This is turrable!

It matters because of Donald's stance on illegal immigration.

Are illegal Slovenians running around breaking American laws and taking over cities? Do we have a Slovenian flag flying over the US flag at posts offices in towns overrun by illegal Slovenians? Are they smuggling drugs into America? Forcing us to put Slovenian writing just below the Spanish that was forced just below the English on everything because they come here not knowing the native language?

Your attempt at excuses are just that, excuses.

Trump's made it clear where he stands on illegal immigrants. Which it currently appears his wife was.

originally posted by: dragonridr
a reply to: Indigo5

Many models come into countries using tourist visas. For example when they do sports illustrated t hey use tourist visas when they do shoots on places like Belize. It's standard practice and not a big deal.

Still illegal to work on a tourist visa...and I would think that matters to the "Build that wall" and "Law and Order" candidate.

But more importantly...
she lied and claimed she was on H1B work visa, not a tourist visa...
she lied about having a university degree (likely when she filled out the federal application for Green-Card)...
and she is lying about not being here in 1995 at all (the time of the photo-shoot and when her roommate says she was here and living with her)...so there is a chance she had no visa at all when she was here in 1995...otherwise, why keep pretending she wasn't.

originally posted by: Indigo5

originally posted by: LSU0408
a reply to: Indigo5

Oh noes! Not Melania coming here on a short term visa, anything but that! This is turrable!

Seeing as she is pretending she did not come here until 1996...and clearly she was here (as her roommate attests) as well as the Nude Photo shoot and subsequent magazine publication shows..in 1995...there is a question about whether she was here on a Visa at all.

Maybe we should vote for Hillary Clinton in 3 months then. That'll teach Melania to ever come here 21 years ago again! Anyways, all garbage jokes aside, she's not hurting anyone. The only way to deport illegals is to catch them breaking a law other than being here illegally. If they don't break any other law, they have nothing to worry about.

a reply to: Nikola014

Your are soooooooo RIGHT!!! I am wasting my time here on this ASININE NONSENSE!!! Thank you for the reality snap!!!

pax

originally posted by: paxnatus
a reply to: Nikola014

Your are soooooooo RIGHT!!! I am wasting my time here on this ASININE NONSENSE!!! Thank you for the reality snap!!!

pax

You can't face facts, can you?

Khan didn't work.

Time to go to back up plan A... attack the wife to keep everyone from wondering why I haven't had a press conference in almost a year now.


Do not look at the man behind the curtain... look over at Trumps wife!!!!


Working as intended

originally posted by: LSU0408

originally posted by: Indigo5

originally posted by: LSU0408
a reply to: Indigo5

Oh noes! Not Melania coming here on a short term visa, anything but that! This is turrable!

Seeing as she is pretending she did not come here until 1996...and clearly she was here (as her roommate attests) as well as the Nude Photo shoot and subsequent magazine publication shows..in 1995...there is a question about whether she was here on a Visa at all.

Maybe we should vote for Hillary Clinton in 3 months then. That'll teach Melania to ever come here 21 years ago again! Anyways, all garbage jokes aside, she's not hurting anyone. The only way to deport illegals is to catch them breaking a law other than being here illegally. If they don't break any other law, they have nothing to worry about.

Again with the Hillary excuse.

originally posted by: LSU0408

originally posted by: Indigo5

originally posted by: LSU0408
a reply to: Indigo5

Oh noes! Not Melania coming here on a short term visa, anything but that! This is turrable!

Seeing as she is pretending she did not come here until 1996...and clearly she was here (as her roommate attests) as well as the Nude Photo shoot and subsequent magazine publication shows..in 1995...there is a question about whether she was here on a Visa at all.

Maybe we should vote for Hillary Clinton in 3 months then.

What does Hillary Clinton have to do with Melania Trump potentially having come here illegally.

Have you spent so much time obsessing about Hillary Clinton that you are unable to discuss other topics?

originally posted by: introvert

originally posted by: LSU0408
a reply to: Indigo5

Oh noes! Not Melania coming here on a short term visa, anything but that! This is turrable!

That is how most illegal immigrants get in to the country. They come with a visa and then stay once it has expired.

Despite common belief, they are not all crossing the border illegally.

And won't be deported under Trump unless caught breaking a law other than being here illegally. And the millions here that came illegally and are now legal aren't the ones in the spotlight, so the left needs to get off Melania's back unless she's still here illegally. Man, you guys really have nothing better to do, do you...

originally posted by: RickinVa

Do not look at the man behind the curtain... look over at Trumps wife!!!!

No, just shove the facts behind the curtain.