It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by thelibra
Now I just want to be clear on this, because I want to make sure I read it right... Are you saying that if a loaded gun were in your hand, and you found a man who had broken into your house, and was brutally raping your daughter or wife, that you wouldn't shoot him? Instead, you would turn the other cheek?
Originally posted by thelibra
I could never do that. The man who would violate my family so would be lucky to only find himself dead, and I consider myself to be a limited pacifist of rational mind.
Originally posted by thelibra
I just got a pile of extra work at the office, so the rest of my answers will have to br brief, but I'll try my best.
Originally posted by thelibra
Any law enforcement or lawyer will tell you this is the most effective method of avoiding lawsuit later on, and to prevent retribution by the person who was shot. Disabling them, on the other hand, allows them to sue you (usually successfully), and to enact revenge later on. The #1 rule of thumb is that if you have an invader in your house, shoot to kill, and only shoot once if you hit. Anything else will result in jail time.
Originally posted by thelibra
On the contrary, I keep a baseball bat by my bed, swords on the wall, and a several knives around the house. Anyone who breaks into my domain thinking to find a victim will find themselves instead victim to any number of lethal attacks.
Originally posted by thelibra
What I was saying though, is that a gun is the most effective method of stopping an intruder dead in his tracks.
Originally posted by thelibra
Well, according to the Bible, even using a gun is fine. Christians never played nice in times of war. When violence was called for, they fought with all the fury and vengeance that their God could summon.
Originally posted by thelibra
I'd quote any number of passages, but as I mentioned, I need to go soon, and get to working on my assignments.
Originally posted by thelibra
Once you let the firearm do the thinking for you, you've become no better than the intruder.
Originally posted by thelibra
Always keep the mentality that your ammo is precious, and that you only have one shot, and to make that shot count, and perhaps it will stay your finger enough seconds to get a better view of the situation.
Originally posted by thelibra
Back when I was a Christian, a minister gave a sermon on following God's plan. He opened it with the following joke:
Originally posted by thelibra
Admittedly, I do gain quite a bit of inner peace by trusting in providence. However, I am also of the belief that God helps those who help themselves. If I cannot make rent one month, due to lack of enough money, I do not say "God will pay my rent". I get up, find a second job, or odd jobs, work with the landlord, or pawn something until I can make rent. God gave us free will for a reason.
Originally posted by thelibra
It is my belief that "the hand of God" is almost never used, but rather God acts in subtle motions, such as a rowboat during a flood, or a loaded gun within easy reach when one is being robbed. Does allowing the robber to violate my home further God's plan any more than shooting him dead? Perhaps God put him in my home, knowing I would shoot the intruder, because later that intruder would decide to slaughter a busload of children.
Originally posted by thelibra
Possessions are much more than just an X-Box, or a set of collectable plates. Possessions include your home, which shelters your family. Various heirlooms, which tie the past to the present in a physical way. Wedding rings, engagement rings, memories of places or events we may never see again. Appliances with which we can prepare food to feed our families, books, tapes, DVDs with which to teach them. The computer, which may contain years worth of stories one has written, or all the family accounts with the funds with which we use to provide for them.
Originally posted by thelibra
There is nothing in the Bible that says one should not defend their home.
Originally posted by thelibra
The exact context of turn the other cheek is in reference to threats or attacks which do not violate our intrinsic right to life, or to provide for our family. For instance, you shouldn't shoot someone for calling you a name, and it's best not to stoop to their level. It does not mean, IMO, that one should sit idly by and allow some lawless bastage to violate you.
Originally posted by thelibra
I believe that there was once a man named Jesus, who was so convinced that he was the Son of God that he got others to believe it as well. Beyond that, I pretend to know nothing. Perhaps he was the Son of God, and perhaps he was just a very confused young man in the wrong place at the wrong time, thus I cannot debate if he was the Son. However, I can debate as to whether or not Jesus is the only way to achieve the "happy ending" after our life ends.
Originally posted by saint4God
I would try to protect my family by getting in the way. I would try to get him conscious and talking. Who knows, if I completely lose it I may try to knock him out. I hope to God however, I would not shoot him.
Originally posted by saint4God
There have been cases of abuse in a few instances in my family. Without going into specifics, my first reaction was anger...hatred...the want to kill them. I took a moment to think about this each time it happened.
Originally posted by saint4God
For as long as a person lives, they have the ability to change. It's rare, but supposing you did kill someone before they had that opportunity. Now what good have you done?
Originally posted by saint4God
As those on here shout "don't judge people!", what then gives any individual the right to be judge, jury and executioner?
Originally posted by saint4God
I agree that our legal is broken in some places. When it comes to law of 80 years and law of eternity, guess which I choose.
Originally posted by saint4God
Dead Jim....dead dead. Sounds like the pioneers back in the day who shot Native Americans for not understanding property lines. "Those savages!".
Originally posted by saint4God
The people who burglarize your house, do they want you? Not unless you personally did something to piss them off and that's a whole other issue. Give them the junk, the money and let them go along their merry way. If you have nothing left of value, why would they come back?
Originally posted by saint4God
So ah, God summoned you to have a fire-arm? I seem to remember something about "those who live by the sword will die by the sword."
Originally posted by saint4God
Originally posted by thelibra
I'd quote any number of passages, but as I mentioned, I need to go soon, and get to working on my assignments.
It's cool. Whenever you have time.
Originally posted by saint4God
Originally posted by thelibra
Does allowing the robber to violate my home further God's plan any more than shooting him dead? Perhaps God put him in my home, knowing I would shoot the intruder, because later that intruder would decide to slaughter a busload of children.
Sounds like rationalizing to get your way frankly.
Originally posted by saint4God
If I were unarmed and an intruder were to come into my home God would know it long before I would and would stop it if he chose to do so.
Originally posted by saint4God
Even still, you think he'd 'teach me a lesson' that's against his commandment in both the Old and New Testament? *Booming voice* "saint4, it's your fault those school children died. You're responsible for their deaths because you didn't have your sidearm cocked and ready. Shame on you."
Originally posted by saint4God
Stuff stuff stuff. It's all garbage. I know, I have all that garbage too. If we invested a quarter of what we have (time, money, etc.) into people, we'd be a hundred times richer for it!
Originally posted by saint4God
Originally posted by thelibra
There is nothing in the Bible that says one should not defend their home.
There's nothing saying you should. How often did Jesus defend his house?
Originally posted by saint4God
Originally posted by thelibra
The exact context of turn the other cheek is in reference to threats or attacks which do not violate our intrinsic right to life, or to provide for our family. For instance, you shouldn't shoot someone for calling you a name, and it's best not to stoop to their level. It does not mean, IMO, that one should sit idly by and allow some lawless bastage to violate you.
I know where you're coming from in that I have the same feelings. It's a tough battle and unfortunately I've brought you into the war I'm having with myself on the issue.
Originally posted by saint4God
Originally posted by thelibra
I believe that there was once a man named Jesus, who was so convinced that he was the Son of God that he got others to believe it as well. Beyond that, I pretend to know nothing.
Alright, how about what he had to say on all other things?
Originally posted by saint4God
You've got great reasoning which is why I'm totally into this discussion and ask all the questions. Who knows, maybe you'll be changing my mind on a few things.
Originally posted by SkipShipman
First of all "God is Love."
God is a loving Father and we are his children.
Any religion that tells you anything else as a priority is moving you away from knowing this.
Originally posted by Bondi
*clap* Exactly, everyone who posts here is making a judgement based on their own analasys of information provided, or their belief in someone elses (maybe a little wrongly phrased there).
Originally posted by drbryankkruta
Question everyone, is this a fair way to state the one real belief?
Originally posted by drbryankkruta
1 Does your service and faith honor God despite the name you use to describe this faith or God himself.
Originally posted by drbryankkruta
2 Is your belief beneficial to following the course God and not man has laid out for you.
Originally posted by drbryankkruta
3 Can you belive and do you believe in God sight unseen with no proof other than the promise to us God exists as our father and is watching over us trying to help us along.
Originally posted by drbryankkruta
4 Does you faith in God transend the harm of fellow man because they dont agree with you.
Originally posted by drbryankkruta
5 Finally do you believe that you are serving God the way he wishes you to in your heart.
Originally posted by drbryankkruta
Based on your answers to these simple questions in your own heart you now have your answer as to what the true ONE FAITH is its the simple feelings and love for God you have in you its a personal issue that we are incuraged to discuss but not force on others.
ITS ALL UP TO YOU TO HAVE THE ONE TRUE FAITH not anyone else.
Its inside you and shows through your actions.
Originally posted by LadyV
Originally posted by Bondi
*clap* Exactly, everyone who posts here is making a judgement based on their own analasys of information provided, or their belief in someone elses (maybe a little wrongly phrased there).
Bull! There is a difference between being "judgmental" and stating your belief...a "huge" difference.....funny you don't see that. One is stating something as if it is fact and the other is voicing an opinion.
Originally posted by Bondi
So you don't use your faith to judge what is right and wrong, you do not use your faith to judge what ir moral and immoral.
No. About the only things I really judge are murders, rapist, abusers...I fully well understand that because I may believe in something with all my heart, doesn't make it true...I could be wrong, though I don't think so or I wouldn't follow what I do. This seems to be huge problem...people thinking if someone doesn't believe just as they do, they are wrong, evil, blaa, blaa, blaa...
Originally posted by LadyV
There is no one "true" religion...
there is only one creating force and people fight over which way to worship/find/believe in it.
The sad thing is what people "do" in the name of what they believe is the one true faith....
My personal belief is that none of the faiths/religions that worshiped today, actually nails it down
I think everyone is just cluster messing it all up
...most people don't have a clue as to the "truth"
Originally posted by drbryankkruta
1 Does your service and faith honor God despite the name you use to describe this faith or God himself.
Originally posted by drbryankkruta
2 Is your belief beneficial to following the course God and not man has laid out for you.
Originally posted by drbryankkruta
3 Can you belive and do you believe in God sight unseen with no proof other than the promise to us God exists as our father and is watching over us trying to help us along.
Originally posted by drbryankkruta
4 Does you faith in God transend the harm of fellow man because they dont agree with you.
Originally posted by drbryankkruta
5 Finally do you believe that you are serving God the way he wishes you to in your heart.
Originally posted by LadyV
Originally posted by Bondi
*clap* Exactly, everyone who posts here is making a judgement based on their own analasys of information provided, or their belief in someone elses (maybe a little wrongly phrased there).
Bull! There is a difference between being "judgmental" and stating your belief...a "huge" difference.....funny you don't see that. One is stating something as if it is fact and the other is voicing an opinion.
Originally posted by thelibra
Okay, so it's not so much that you wouldn't intervene, but rather you would opt to use nonlethal force to intercept the intruder.
Originally posted by thelibra
In a situation this severe, I personally would opt to use lethal force as a first resort, even were I a Christian, for two reasons:
God would forgive me, IMO.
Originally posted by thelibra
Even as a Christian, there are a myriad of ways of obtaining forgiveness. Everything from simply praying and asking for it,
Originally posted by thelibra
to getting baptized again, to going to confession and doing penance.
Originally posted by thelibra
My spiritual beliefs are not quite as simple as simply asking for it. I would then have to find a way to balance it out. Perhaps by saving a life. But that would be for my own edification. God, as a being, understands on a far deeper level than I can ever imagine. If God could forgive a man who lived his entire life as a murderous villanous scumbag that did horrible things, he could forgive a man who lived most of his life as a good person, and once slipped into wrath, and genuinely sought forgiveness.
Originally posted by thelibra
I got to receive the physical sort quite a bit, but my sister got worse than I did, and my brother received the absolute worst. I actually got to watch, one Christmas, as my mother pushed my brother down the stairs, after beating him, and when he lay at the bottom, his ankle twisted horribly from a breakage, she flew down the stairs, grabbed him by the hair, and proceded to slam his face repeatedly into a brick wall seperating the kitchen from the den. I was probably six or seven at the time.
One may ask, how could I ever love people like that? The long and short of it is, I didn't... for nearly two decades. Then, in my mid-20's my father realized he had no children left, only offspring. He began to try and be my father, a father I'd never had before. At first I refused, and it was only with time, earned trust, and proving he'd changed, that I slowly came around. Eventually my mom reached the same state of mind. I can forgive them now, because I know they've changed, that they genuinely regret the past, and want to be good people. Now, almost 30, I share a healthy relationship with my parents, and have learned from the past on what not to do, and to a degree, what to do right, when I have children.
Originally posted by thelibra
I have spent over 90% of my life in Texas. I was born here, as was most of my family. (and for the record, most of us can't stand Bush, but that's another discussion altogether). Anyway, Texas is a harsh land. In times past, it made todays harshness look like a day at the park.
Originally posted by thelibra
Having descended from the Sac & Fox Tribe, I have my own beef with what happened to the Native Americans back in the day.
Originally posted by thelibra
One might quite reasonably assume that from my series of posts, that I am a gun-toting redneck just itchin' to find someone to shoot.
Originally posted by thelibra
Thus, if America were invaded, I'd volunteer to join the armed forces immediately.
Originally posted by thelibra
If, however, it was a war overseas, in a country that had never launched an attack against us, I would support our troops from afar, and curse our leaders from up close.
Originally posted by thelibra
Exodus 21:12-25 - God laws down the law
"12 "Whoever strikes a man so that he dies shall be put to death.
Originally posted by thelibra
1 Samuel 17:45-49 - David slays Goliath.
"45 Then David said to the Philistine, "You come to me with a sword and with a spear and with a javelin; but I come to you in the name of the LORD of hosts, the God of the armies of Israel, whom you have defied. 46 This day the LORD will deliver you into my hand, and I will strike you down, and cut off your head; and I will give the dead bodies of the host of the Philistines this day to the birds of the air and to the wild beasts of the earth; that all the earth may know that there is a God in Israel,
Originally posted by thelibra
Romans 13 - Legally Exacting Death
"1 Let every person be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God. 2 Therefore he who resists the authorities resists what God has appointed, and those who resist will incur judgment. 3 For rulers are not a terror to good conduct, but to bad. Would you have no fear of him who is in authority? Then do what is good, and you will receive his approval, 4 for he is God's servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain; he is the servant of God to execute his wrath on the wrongdoer."
Originally posted by thelibra
There are numerous other passages I could quote from, but it would require reading the Bible in it's entirety again to find ones that are not taken out of context, and I don't quite have that much time before my fiance returns home.
Originally posted by thelibra
I can see how it would, but my meaning was that one cannot pick and choose what is and is not within God's Plan. If I act merciful towards a man, I can no more claim it was part of God's Plan than I can if I were to commit a heinous act of villainy.
Originally posted by thelibra
Take for instance the story of Job. He allows this man to be utterly broken by having his wealth, health, and loved ones torn away from him in the worst ways possible, just to satisfy a bet with Satan. For what?
Originally posted by thelibra
To be able to have bragging rights on how devout a follower was?
Originally posted by thelibra
He instructs a Abraham to take his son to the top of a mountain and sacrifice him. For what? A test of faith?
Originally posted by thelibra
Yet Christians trust in God's Plan every single day, and feel that there must be some sort of justification, beyond knowing that God has it all worked out in the end, and that everything that happens, happens for a reason.
Originally posted by thelibra
Well, it can't happen both ways. You cannot say that God's Plan only involves mercy, love, and harmony, because there's an entire book, and history of a world that shows this is not the case.
Originally posted by thelibra
There is even the possibility, as shown by St. Anselm, that not even God knows exactly every little detail that will happen within the Plan, but rather, what the end result will be.
Originally posted by thelibra
Thus, killing violating intruder may possibly have just as much place within God's Plan as being merciful towards him. Or, it is possible that the entire incident is of no consequence to the plan whatsoever, that it is merely a detail that came about in the culmination of The Plan.
Originally posted by thelibra
The slaughtered children on your conscience are not punishment enough?
Originally posted by thelibra
You would require God to personally make an appearance (if only in voice) to point out that you had let a very bad man commit even more acts of greater and greater evil?
Originally posted by thelibra
Not even Jesus would test God
Originally posted by thelibra
It is all garbage? The means with which to live, that God has so graciously allowed you to obtain, you call garbage?
Originally posted by thelibra
(shaking head sadly). How can one take the assumption that God would save them from any number of heinous acts, but so quickly assume that any material possessions bestowed upon them were not also a result of God's Blessing?
Originally posted by thelibra
Did not the Israelites defend their land, numerous times?
Originally posted by thelibra
As for investing a quarter of what we have into people... I already do that. Every day I spend at least a quarter of my day trying to get at least one person to sit down and seriously think, something that most people willingly admit they try to avoid.
Originally posted by thelibra
Why? Because I am not rich. I'm not even middle-class. I barely scrape above the poverty line. All that I have to share with others is my mind, and what scant charity I can afford to scrounge up.
Originally posted by thelibra
But additionally one must take a longer-term approach to provisions, if they truly wish to make a difference. As the saying goes, if you give a man a fish, you feed him for a day, if you teach a man to fish, you feed him for life. The same goes, in many ways, towards possessions, to an extent. While a Brittany Spears CD may teach a child nothing useful, a computer may allow them to learn, grow, and become a better person for it.
Originally posted by thelibra
How well can one provide for their family if they have nothing?
Originally posted by thelibra
Have you truly made the world a better place if you have given away all your possessions, only to see your own child turn to a life of crime to obtain that which you cannot provide?
Originally posted by thelibra
Have you made the world a better place if you give all your books away, only to have your own child grow up ignorant and borderline illiterate?
Originally posted by thelibra
In the end, one's life and family and fellow man is more precious than money, but some material possessions are still the basic tenants by which we grow and nurture each other in society.
Originally posted by thelibra
But the rapture and suchlike aside, God doesn't expect us to always be like Jesus.
Originally posted by thelibra
On the contrary, I am rather secure in my beliefs.