It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: ScepticScot
originally posted by: Krazysh0t
originally posted by: crazyewok
originally posted by: Krazysh0t
a reply to: crazyewok
So you don't think that Germany wouldn't have been able to adapt to this?
Well they didn't.
Not sure what they could have done?
There air force was beaten and there their Navy in no way capable of taking on the Royal Navy anymore than the British navy today could take on the US Navy.
You know. If you guys were sitting so pretty, why were you guys turtling in your island up until America entered the war? You make it sound like the British had everything under control and I don't think that is the case.
I don't necessarily think that y'all were saved by any one country, but you cannot deny that the heat was on and America's entry certainly took a lot of that heat off of you guys. Though, even with America in the war, Germany was still winning on almost all fronts for a good while (up until D-Day).
They could have tried to out build the UK in ships but the UK was so vastly ahead. It would only have been possible if they could have secured the resources in Africa and Russia to fuel there industry.
Which they were working on doing (and were denied by the Americans).
Stalingrad 1942.
El Alamein 1942
Kursk 1943
Germany was already getting its arse handed to it by D-Day.
originally posted by: Krazysh0t
You know. If you guys were sitting so pretty, why were you guys turtling in your island up until America entered the war? You make it sound like the British had everything under control and I don't think that is the case.
?
originally posted by: Krazysh0t
I don't necessarily think that y'all were saved by any one country, but you cannot deny that the heat was on and America's entry certainly took a lot of that heat off of you guys. Though, even with America in the war, Germany was still winning on almost all fronts for a good while (up until D-Day).
.
originally posted by: Krazysh0t
[Which they were working on doing (and were denied by the Americans).
originally posted by: Krazysh0t
originally posted by: ScepticScot
originally posted by: Krazysh0t
originally posted by: crazyewok
originally posted by: Krazysh0t
a reply to: crazyewok
So you don't think that Germany wouldn't have been able to adapt to this?
Well they didn't.
Not sure what they could have done?
There air force was beaten and there their Navy in no way capable of taking on the Royal Navy anymore than the British navy today could take on the US Navy.
You know. If you guys were sitting so pretty, why were you guys turtling in your island up until America entered the war? You make it sound like the British had everything under control and I don't think that is the case.
I don't necessarily think that y'all were saved by any one country, but you cannot deny that the heat was on and America's entry certainly took a lot of that heat off of you guys. Though, even with America in the war, Germany was still winning on almost all fronts for a good while (up until D-Day).
They could have tried to out build the UK in ships but the UK was so vastly ahead. It would only have been possible if they could have secured the resources in Africa and Russia to fuel there industry.
Which they were working on doing (and were denied by the Americans).
Stalingrad 1942.
El Alamein 1942
Kursk 1943
Germany was already getting its arse handed to it by D-Day.
Eh... If you say so. Though I'm sure the necessity of D-Day said otherwise.
originally posted by: Wardaddy454
originally posted by: Ohanka
originally posted by: Wardaddy454
originally posted by: Peeple
a reply to: crazyewok
You have forgotten the one who really defeated Hitler: Stalin.
Without the US Lend Lease program, Stalin wouldn't have been able to get his forces out of Russia to help out.
Overly focusing on the lend lease program is typical in the West, despite the minor impact it had on the Eastern Front.
The Soviets did not help out in Europe. They won the war in that theatre. By the time of the Allied landing on D-Day, the Wehrmacht was for all intents and purposes defeated. It had been since Kursk and arguably Stalingrad. The Nazi leadership was merely delaying the inevitable.
The Western Allies main contributions against Germany were in the Africa campaign and the Mediterranean (Italy).
It was far more vital than you give it credit for. It would have been impossible for the Red Army to move the masses of troops and supplies on the primitive roads to the front lines without the Studebaker trucks, which also served as the launching pads for their rocket artillery. That's on top of the food and other supplies it provided the Soviets.
originally posted by: Rocker2013
a reply to: crazyewok
Settle this?
Unless you have the capability to go back in time and deliberately control events to create a new scenario, there is no why in hell this could ever be "settled".
There are a billion and one possible scenarios.
This is foolish.
originally posted by: Krazysh0t
Eh... If you say so. Though I'm sure the necessity of D-Day said otherwise.
originally posted by: Irishhaf
a reply to: crazyewok
I actually think the UK would have survived..
the german airforce was in dire straits..the german navy had no shot at beating the british in a head to head fight.
The only shot germany had was right after Dunkirk IMO, struck while the iron was hot, before the Limeys had a chance to regroup and train up those that were left.
They elected to try and establish air superiority and when that failed they were done.
originally posted by: eriktheawful
It was a joint effort.
The UK defiantly gave Nazi Germany the middle finger no mater how much they were bombed.
The US got involved and was able to churn out goods and men that Hitler knew would eventually overwhelm them.
The Russians did as they always do: let enemy forces come in further and further, and let mother nature bend them over.
In the end: the Allies put up a good fight and ended WW2.
Over 70's later, people who never fought in that war, nor had to suffer from it are on a internet forum fighting about who needed help or not.
Your grand parents and great grand parents would be slapping all of you upside your heads for disrespecting the mutual partnership we all had to stomp out a rather evil force.
All the allies did a wonderful job of fighting, surviving and fighting back. No one country was more important than another, not one country fought more than another. Each had their own roles to play, and each did very well in the end.
Anything else is just a mockery of what happened to all those souls lost in that war. Remember that.