It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Illumin
a reply to: bucsarg
If mankind created religion, and God created mankind, then who created God?
It's the same problem I have with the Big Bang, and that is nothing comes from nothing!
originally posted by: bucsarg
I write this at the risk of getting myself shewed up by you folks..
In my early years I was very religious and involved in the church. Over these years I became disgusted with the supposed Christians in my church due to their destructiveness towards one another. And I became very turned off by the headquarters who constantly wanted money with little to know support in return.
So I quit. Then started my own journey in trying to figure out what is God, religion, and so forth. To date is what I have come to believe. And it's radical. Below are my current beliefs:
God exists.
God is all knowing.
God is some sort of spirit.
God is not religious.
God created or set in motion all that is.
Creationism and evolution coexist.
God is not benevolent.
God views humans no different than any animal.
God wants our souls to learn.
God would like humans to treat each other well.
God does not live with time.
God's view point of humans is not what humans think God's view of humans is.
Religion is Mankind's invention not God's.
God is positive.
God is opposite of evil.
God is interested and cares about our souls.
God is not interested in our bodies. Our bodies are throw always.
I think God marvels at humans creativity, compation, love, stupidity, evilness, hatred etc.
I question whether God truly understands what mankind feels and the difficulties we endure.
If I make it to where God resides I plan on asking God how he/she can live with allowing children to suffer.
originally posted by: Illumin
a reply to: WarminIndy
No, but I can only assume based on common sense that God didn't just appear out of thin air. And then with all the power ever conceived start creating flawed, at times hateful and disgusting beings to occupy an extremely volatile rock in a universe that's just as volatile! And then sit back and give this being the false hope that their "God" actually cares and everything you'll ever do isn't in vain.
Let me guess, you're going to throw out how complex the human eye is next?
How about this, God exists inside your head just like Santa and the tooth fairy did when you were 5!
Now, the idea of beings that are thousands of years more advanced than we are having manipulated our psyche and/or DNA at one point in our evolution, is more plausible. Ever see Battlestar Galactica? Oh wait, that storyline is fairly new and wasn't written about in a book a couple thousand years ago so that would just be a ludicrous idea...
originally posted by: WarminIndy
originally posted by: Illumin
a reply to: bucsarg
If mankind created religion, and God created mankind, then who created God?
It's the same problem I have with the Big Bang, and that is nothing comes from nothing!
Do you assume that God must be created because you are?
How about this, God exists whether you do or not.
originally posted by: TzarChasm
originally posted by: WarminIndy
originally posted by: Illumin
a reply to: bucsarg
If mankind created religion, and God created mankind, then who created God?
It's the same problem I have with the Big Bang, and that is nothing comes from nothing!
Do you assume that God must be created because you are?
How about this, God exists whether you do or not.
"The universe couldn't come from nothing therefore god"
"Then where did god come from?"
"God doesn't have to be created silly"
"But...but you just said..."
That's how the conversation goes. When logic defies your hypothesis, introduce supernatural forces and suddenly you don't even need to test the hypothesis anymore. It becomes theology.
If mankind created religion, and God created mankind, then who created God? It's the same problem I have with the Big Bang, and that is nothing comes from nothing!
originally posted by: Illumin
a reply to: WarminIndy
I see the point you're trying to make. And although my wording indicates otherwise I don't believe since I was created that God must have been created. But it doesn't explain how anything created, invented or accidents can come from nothing. How did God (any God Christian, muslim etc.) come into existence? If indeed this Spiritual Creator exist on some plane of reality, how then did this being come to exist? That was the point of my original question and you're reply indicated that "welp, he just does"???