It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: OpenMindedRealist
originally posted by: victor7
Because US pokes its nose in lots of nations affairs, near and far. Russia only minds its business in its neighborhood and mostly to the intrusive attempts by the US ex: Georgia and now Ukraine.
Riiiight...
Next are you going to tell me Russia only sends spies to ex-Soviet states, and never had any intention of expanding its influence into western Europe?
originally posted by: OpenMindedRealist
originally posted by: victor7
Btw, Obama has given the ULTIMATUM to Putin.
If there is war, it will be because Putin and his cronies engineered it.
I fnd it hard to believe, with all your pride in mother Russia, that you think Putin is frightened by an empty threat from our pushover President.
originally posted by: OpenMindedRealist
a reply to: jedi_hamster
Putin would surely commend your efforts...but he'd probably throw you in the gulag after listening to five minutes of such histrionics. You'd think someone from Poland would be more wary of foreign bombers skirting their airspace...
You can 'assert' your version of reality all you want. Those who learn their history from academia rather than RT will never fall for it.
originally posted by: OpenMindedRealist
Your vision is clouded by what you think you know.
Has it occurred to you that a person can support his own government only when it is deserving of support?
Do you think it's logical to assume any critic of Putin's Russia is a supporter of the current US government? You and other members are so caught up in your absolutist, black-vs-white worldview. I'm sure it makes things easier, but it gets you no closer to the truth.
When I mentioned Poland, I was referring to the Nazi invasion -- an act of aggression many around the world saw coming. Guess it's just one of those things; people rarely learn from history, be it ten years ago or a hundred. Don't you think it hypocritical that you expect NATO or some other military force to protect your country from foreign invasion, while you trash the US and its allies?
You claim I have no right to comment on Polish matters because I am not from Poland. That means you are resticted to commenting only on Polish issues, correct?
I don't expect you to conceed that point or retract your previous statement. Nor do I expect you to recognize that you are playing the same game which you accuse me of playing, just for the other side.
You repeatedly claim that I am somehow defending the US, when absolutely nothing I have said in this thread defends the United States in any way.
You don't seem to realize it's a two way street...
Except in the case of Ukraine, if the countries were people it would have gone something like this:
originally posted by: BornAgainAlien
a reply to: OpenMindedRealist
You repeatedly claim that I am somehow defending the US, when absolutely nothing I have said in this thread defends the United States in any way.
Yes you did, by trying to make it look like what Russia was doing comparable to what the US does...we are not that stupid to see it for what it is.
You don't seem to realize it's a two way street...
So you will always say if someone punched someone, it`s their own fault and they asked for it ?
originally posted by: OpenMindedRealist
a reply to: jedi_hamster
You've answered none of my pertinent questions. Why should I indulge your ramblings which contribute nothing to the thread?
You repeatedly claim that I am somehow defending the US, when absolutely nothing I have said in this thread defends the United States in any way. Sure, I've been critical of Russia...and apparently that leads you to make the illogical assumption that I could only be doing so in order to further some pro-American agenda.
This is what I mean when I say you are seeing things in black and white. To you, anyone who speaks negatively of Russia (or does not speak negatively of the US) has a sinister agenda. You've made up your mind to ignore anything that doesn't fit your narrative, and it would be a waste of my time to engage you further. I only write this post because an unfortunate number of ATS members share your fallacious mindset, and there may be hope for a few.
And of course you have a right to say anything you want about the US or any other country. You don't seem to realize it's a two way street, and I have a right to state my own observations. Instead of jumping up and down screaming that I am a shill or misinformed, you could have attempted to form a cogent rebuttal. Might have kept this thread from dying.
originally posted by: ScientificRailgun
Except in the case of Ukraine, if the countries were people it would have gone something like this:
originally posted by: BornAgainAlien
a reply to: OpenMindedRealist
You repeatedly claim that I am somehow defending the US, when absolutely nothing I have said in this thread defends the United States in any way.
Yes you did, by trying to make it look like what Russia was doing comparable to what the US does...we are not that stupid to see it for what it is.
You don't seem to realize it's a two way street...
So you will always say if someone punched someone, it`s their own fault and they asked for it ?
Ukraine: Hey Russia, I know we've friends for a long time now, but I think wanna go hang out with those guys in the EU house for a while.
Russia: You'll be sorrry.....
Ukraine: No I'll be alright, let me do my own thing for a while. We can still be cool, but the EU guys have nachos.
Russia: No. (Punch)
I have no doubts a small majority in Crimea would be in favor of rejoining Russia. The latest census puts native Russians as the most populous demographic in Crimea, followed closely by Crimean Tartars.
originally posted by: jedi_hamster
originally posted by: ScientificRailgun
Except in the case of Ukraine, if the countries were people it would have gone something like this:
originally posted by: BornAgainAlien
a reply to: OpenMindedRealist
You repeatedly claim that I am somehow defending the US, when absolutely nothing I have said in this thread defends the United States in any way.
Yes you did, by trying to make it look like what Russia was doing comparable to what the US does...we are not that stupid to see it for what it is.
You don't seem to realize it's a two way street...
So you will always say if someone punched someone, it`s their own fault and they asked for it ?
Ukraine: Hey Russia, I know we've friends for a long time now, but I think wanna go hang out with those guys in the EU house for a while.
Russia: You'll be sorrry.....
Ukraine: No I'll be alright, let me do my own thing for a while. We can still be cool, but the EU guys have nachos.
Russia: No. (Punch)
except that's not what happened. they wanted to take a step back from the pro-western course so they got punched by both US and EU - or rather, their government was replaced by those being paid by the west, and now everybody blames russia.
do some research, there was a poll in the crimea to ask people if they would like to join back russia if they would have a choice - most said yes. and that poll took place BEFORE the whole maidan thing.
heck, i even saw it mentioned somewhere today that according to the pentagon, ukrainian 'evidence' that russian army invaded the ukraine, is made of a photos dating back to around 2008 and in general is worth nothing.
it's not like russia needs ukraine - russia needs crimea, but crimea was always pro-russian and had a great deal of autonomy already.
ukraine, as a nation, and as a country, needs russia. but those in charge in ukraine don't give a damn about ukraine as a nation or as a country, they care about their own pockets. they're destroying ukraine and will continue to do so as long as they can - and they can do so as long as they have the support of the west. heck, they don't even have support of their own people.
originally posted by: ScientificRailgun
I have no doubts a small majority in Crimea would be in favor of rejoining Russia. The latest census puts native Russians as the most populous demographic in Crimea, followed closely by Crimean Tartars.
originally posted by: jedi_hamster
originally posted by: ScientificRailgun
Except in the case of Ukraine, if the countries were people it would have gone something like this:
originally posted by: BornAgainAlien
a reply to: OpenMindedRealist
You repeatedly claim that I am somehow defending the US, when absolutely nothing I have said in this thread defends the United States in any way.
Yes you did, by trying to make it look like what Russia was doing comparable to what the US does...we are not that stupid to see it for what it is.
You don't seem to realize it's a two way street...
So you will always say if someone punched someone, it`s their own fault and they asked for it ?
Ukraine: Hey Russia, I know we've friends for a long time now, but I think wanna go hang out with those guys in the EU house for a while.
Russia: You'll be sorrry.....
Ukraine: No I'll be alright, let me do my own thing for a while. We can still be cool, but the EU guys have nachos.
Russia: No. (Punch)
except that's not what happened. they wanted to take a step back from the pro-western course so they got punched by both US and EU - or rather, their government was replaced by those being paid by the west, and now everybody blames russia.
do some research, there was a poll in the crimea to ask people if they would like to join back russia if they would have a choice - most said yes. and that poll took place BEFORE the whole maidan thing.
heck, i even saw it mentioned somewhere today that according to the pentagon, ukrainian 'evidence' that russian army invaded the ukraine, is made of a photos dating back to around 2008 and in general is worth nothing.
it's not like russia needs ukraine - russia needs crimea, but crimea was always pro-russian and had a great deal of autonomy already.
ukraine, as a nation, and as a country, needs russia. but those in charge in ukraine don't give a damn about ukraine as a nation or as a country, they care about their own pockets. they're destroying ukraine and will continue to do so as long as they can - and they can do so as long as they have the support of the west. heck, they don't even have support of their own people.
The ACTUAL vote was a pure sham. Though I believe if the vote had been fair, it still would have been in favor of Russia.
There are no innocent parties in this Ukraine. Russia is just as at fault as the EU/West are. Both sides are in Ukraine for their own selfish reasons. I personally believe Russia wants an uninterrupted land bridge to Crimea. And of course, the EU/West wants Ukraine to join them to have another nation that borders Russia be sympathetic to NATO allegiances.
I just take issue with the fact that the Pro-Russia side of things continues to insist that Putin/Russia is the purely innocent party in all of this.
I don't know why you chose to lecture me on Crimea when I ceded that Crimea would have gone to Russia anyway in a fair vote. I agreed with you on that.
originally posted by: jedi_hamster
originally posted by: ScientificRailgun
I have no doubts a small majority in Crimea would be in favor of rejoining Russia. The latest census puts native Russians as the most populous demographic in Crimea, followed closely by Crimean Tartars.
originally posted by: jedi_hamster
originally posted by: ScientificRailgun
Except in the case of Ukraine, if the countries were people it would have gone something like this:
originally posted by: BornAgainAlien
a reply to: OpenMindedRealist
You repeatedly claim that I am somehow defending the US, when absolutely nothing I have said in this thread defends the United States in any way.
Yes you did, by trying to make it look like what Russia was doing comparable to what the US does...we are not that stupid to see it for what it is.
You don't seem to realize it's a two way street...
So you will always say if someone punched someone, it`s their own fault and they asked for it ?
Ukraine: Hey Russia, I know we've friends for a long time now, but I think wanna go hang out with those guys in the EU house for a while.
Russia: You'll be sorrry.....
Ukraine: No I'll be alright, let me do my own thing for a while. We can still be cool, but the EU guys have nachos.
Russia: No. (Punch)
except that's not what happened. they wanted to take a step back from the pro-western course so they got punched by both US and EU - or rather, their government was replaced by those being paid by the west, and now everybody blames russia.
do some research, there was a poll in the crimea to ask people if they would like to join back russia if they would have a choice - most said yes. and that poll took place BEFORE the whole maidan thing.
heck, i even saw it mentioned somewhere today that according to the pentagon, ukrainian 'evidence' that russian army invaded the ukraine, is made of a photos dating back to around 2008 and in general is worth nothing.
it's not like russia needs ukraine - russia needs crimea, but crimea was always pro-russian and had a great deal of autonomy already.
ukraine, as a nation, and as a country, needs russia. but those in charge in ukraine don't give a damn about ukraine as a nation or as a country, they care about their own pockets. they're destroying ukraine and will continue to do so as long as they can - and they can do so as long as they have the support of the west. heck, they don't even have support of their own people.
The ACTUAL vote was a pure sham. Though I believe if the vote had been fair, it still would have been in favor of Russia.
There are no innocent parties in this Ukraine. Russia is just as at fault as the EU/West are. Both sides are in Ukraine for their own selfish reasons. I personally believe Russia wants an uninterrupted land bridge to Crimea. And of course, the EU/West wants Ukraine to join them to have another nation that borders Russia be sympathetic to NATO allegiances.
I just take issue with the fact that the Pro-Russia side of things continues to insist that Putin/Russia is the purely innocent party in all of this.
small majority?
populous demographic?
more than 60% of crimea population are russians.
more than 79% of crimea population has declared russian to be their mother tongue.
also, back in 2008 63.8% of people declared their support for crimea leaving ukraine and joining russia. amongst those 63.8%: 75.9% of russians, 55.2% of ukrainians (more than a half!) and 13.8% of tatars.
and that was back in 2008, without fascist junta in charge in kiev. so no, i don't think there was any sham there.
ukraine wouldn't give a damn about crimea, especially considering how pro-russian it was already, but they had their gas price lowered because russia was allowed to have a military base there. then russia took crimea back, 'you're not in charge there anymore so no more price cuts for ya' - and kiev got pissed. rightfully? not at all, imho. it's their own fault they've lost crimea, and they didn't bother to pay for the gas despite the price cuts anyway.
lets get back on the boom-boom subject, shall we?
any news on the missile wreckage?