It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
That question is rhetorical btw. I'm looking for an intelligent debate based on logic.
originally posted by: OptimusSubprime
a reply to: Subaeruginosa
Saying that the Bible has been altered and mistranslated by man is purely conjecture on your part. There is overwhelming scientific evidence, through the science of textual criticism, that shows beyond any doubt that the Bible today says exactly what the earliest manuscripts said. It has not been altered or mistranslated. Your claims hold no water, so the question isn't is the Bible accurate, because that has been proven, regardless of your opinion on it. The real question is... do you choose to believe it? I do and many others do, and clearly you and many others don't.
originally posted by: Subaeruginosa
a reply to: Logarock
So if I express disappointment, because someone tells me they have evidence of the existence of god, then posts some senseless ramblings, it obviously must mean I have a dysfunction?
That question is rhetorical btw. I'm looking for an intelligent debate based on logic.
I mean, even going by the current biblical writings, it would seem to me that God stands for everything of which we consider evil within a modern world and Satan everything of that which is good.
Think about it. God is all about holding back knowledge and truth, he demands full control and to be obeyed at all times, is that not dictatorship? Yet Satan would seem to stand for the exact opposite. He promotes spreading knowledge and truth and is all for freedom of thought and speech, he even fights for equality.
Abandoning our ancient beliefs and turning all our energy on advancing the scientific method is the only chance man has of taking control of our own fate.
originally posted by: Subaeruginosa
You've actually bought up a very good point here. When I debate Christians in real life, one of the most common things I hear is, “if there was no religion, then what’s stopping people from just going around murdering, raping and robbing there fellow man?”.
Now what other conclusion can a person make from such an odd comment, except that the only thing stopping them from doing these things is there fear of being punished by god. It’s basically an admission that they don’t posses the intelligence to make rational decisions on their own.
All wars have been based on spiritual beliefs or irrational ideologies.
Before anyone starts ranting on about hitler, he was raised catholic and was deeply religious, he talked constantly about being chosen for a higher purpose by a higher power. He was just against traditional Christianity and wanted to create his own Nazism religion.
originally posted by: Deetermined
a reply to: Subaeruginosa
Abandoning our ancient beliefs and turning all our energy on advancing the scientific method is the only chance man has of taking control of our own fate.
When man takes control of it's own fate, it only leads to all of us dying sooner by killing each other off.
originally posted by: Xtrozero
originally posted by: Subaeruginosa
You've actually bought up a very good point here. When I debate Christians in real life, one of the most common things I hear is, “if there was no religion, then what’s stopping people from just going around murdering, raping and robbing there fellow man?”.
Now what other conclusion can a person make from such an odd comment, except that the only thing stopping them from doing these things is there fear of being punished by god. It’s basically an admission that they don’t posses the intelligence to make rational decisions on their own.
With no right or wrong then there is nothing one could do to go to jail, well unless someone else decided they would like to put people in jail. When we go back to the dark ages we see how humans handle situations where humans could be put in the position to have power over others.
originally posted by: Subaeruginosa
a reply to: Xtrozero
You've actually bought up a very good point here. When I debate Christians in real life, one of the most common things I hear is, “if there was no religion, then what’s stopping people from just going around murdering, raping and robbing there fellow man?”.
Now what other conclusion can a person make from such an odd comment, except that the only thing stopping them from doing these things is there fear of being punished by god. It’s basically an admission that they don’t posses the intelligence to make rational decisions on their own.
Well I’m more than capable, so yes total freedom suits me just fine. Anyone who is incapable belongs in jail, not church!
originally posted by: Deetermined
a reply to: Subaeruginosa
As humans we have a sinful nature, this is why you might think that Satan represents those things which are good in your eyes. Satan wants to spread knowledge because he knows that we have a tendency to misuse it for evil over that which is good, due to our sinful nature. God knows this too, that's why he wants to limit it. By the way, knowledge doesn't always lead to truth. As humans, we error in recognizing what's true and what's not. That's why we should leave it to God and have faith that he will decipher it for us. He's the only one filled with light and truth. God is the only one who can save us from ourselves. We can't save each other and we'll never be equal to God, which is what Satan wants us to believe. Thousands of years of human existence has already proven this to be true if people truly take the time to reflect on our mistakes and human history. That's what we were put on this earth to learn.
Rubbish. You can't cite an iota of testable evidence proving that your God or your Satan exist. This is what you, personally,have chosen to believe for your own reasons. Do not speak for other humans. It only embarrasses you.
originally posted by: Deetermined
Hitler only thought he was religious and chosen for a higher purpose by a higher power, just like you thought you were a passionate Christian clear up until your twenties.
The Australian Aboriginals lived isolated for 50 thousand years and knew nothing about god or any other structured religion, to them it was the land that sustained them, which was sacred. They were the least violent culture we know of and lived a very structured, moral and peaceful existence.
originally posted by: ladyinwaiting
Just so you'll know, Christians don't believe in hexes, nor do they put "hexes" on people. I believe you are thinking about voo-doo.
Also, Christians who are in mainstream Christianity do not speak in "tongues". I think there is a small faction of churches who do this.
...
originally posted by: Utnapisjtim
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: Utnapisjtim
a reply to: trollz
Indeed, and there's more, since you mentioned the word church. The word used by Jesus, ..."
Jesus didn't write the Bible. The words in the Bible attributed to Jesus were written multiple generations after Jesus allegedly lived by people who never heard Jesus say a word. In fact, there's not an iota of contemporaneous documentation (ie. historical evidence) proving that Jesus ever lived.
Fair enough, but that's a whole different discussion.
originally posted by: Subaeruginosa
originally posted by: Xtrozero
originally posted by: Subaeruginosa
You've actually bought up a very good point here. When I debate Christians in real life, one of the most common things I hear is, “if there was no religion, then what’s stopping people from just going around murdering, raping and robbing there fellow man?”.
Now what other conclusion can a person make from such an odd comment, except that the only thing stopping them from doing these things is there fear of being punished by god. It’s basically an admission that they don’t posses the intelligence to make rational decisions on their own.
With no right or wrong then there is nothing one could do to go to jail, well unless someone else decided they would like to put people in jail. When we go back to the dark ages we see how humans handle situations where humans could be put in the position to have power over others.
The idea of god has nothing to do with right or wrong. Nor does freewill eliminate humans basic instinct of what is right or wrong. If anything God is used as an excuse to justify carrying out evil acts. btw, you do realise that satan doesn't even exist in any of the ancient scriptures don't you? A single entity that represents evil is purely an invention of modern day Christianity.
That's the saddest thing I have taken from this thread. I despise religion, yet in truth I know far more about the concept than most of the people who have posted here. If you took the time to actually research the issue, rather than just excepting what your pastor says, you would discover for yourselves how flawed the whole thing actually is.