It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: TrueMessiah
Do you mind disclosing any information regarding this?
originally posted by: EnPassant
a reply to: Alfred2012
Deliberate contact with beings who abduct and terrorize people? Do you think it is safe to go near these beings or trust what they say?
originally posted by: tanka418
a reply to: AlienView
Interesting, Associate Professor of History at Temple University and a PH.D. Makes me wonder what kind of credentials these repetitive, robot like debunkers have
That is the only easy question; None...for the most part these "debunkers" and "arm chair" skeptics have no real education; no degree in anything, with the possible exception of "Master's" degrees in "knee jerking".
I see it in almost all debunker types; they set up their own artificial standard, without any care for convention (scientific or social)and attempt to "rule" from this...non-existent place of authority.
Then they actually have the temerity to demand truth.
The real misfortune is that any serious research we can do is reduced to a mockery of science by the application of the debunkers "courtroom" tactics...i.e. reduce the whole to an argument. a war of words...just like two lawyers arguing, neither knowing want they are talking about, neither accepting the other's witnesses.
This of course leads to absolutely NO progress, no learning.
originally posted by: draknoir2
Hey Tanka/Alienview... how exactly have you determined the educational background of all us "arm chair skeptics"?
No offense, guys, but you have yet to dazzle this "debunker" with your "logic and reason". In fact, I find you to be woefully deficient in both. Anyone can get a Ph.D in just about anything... including complete BS. It's no certification of intelligence, competence, rationality, or even sanity.
So when you armchair believers get frustrated that your sources and evidence suck, don't take it out on the folks who have the "temerity" to point it out. It's not their fault, it's yours.
This is "how" we can tell...your statements...like the above. "Anyone can get a Ph.D..." That was spoken like a person who has absolutely no concept of what is involved in getting a Ph.D. To become a Doctor of Philosophy actually involves a great deal of work. Something over 20 years of formal education, and two rather serious projects of increasing difficulty.
originally posted by: tanka418
This is "how" we can tell...your statements...like the above. "Anyone can get a Ph.D..." That was spoken like a person who has absolutely no concept of what is involved in getting a Ph.D. To become a Doctor of Philosophy actually involves a great deal of work. Something over 20 years of formal education, and two rather serious projects of increasing difficulty.
originally posted by: tanka418
This is "how" we can tell...your statements...like the above. "Anyone can get a Ph.D..." That was spoken like a person who has absolutely no concept of what is involved in getting a Ph.D. To become a Doctor of Philosophy actually involves a great deal of work. Something over 20 years of formal education, and two rather serious projects of increasing difficulty.
originally posted by: Soylent Green Is People
On one hand, I do agree that getting a PhD is an accomplishment, and in general most people who do have them do have a certain higher level of intellect.
HOWEVER, and having said that, having a PhD does not necessarily make everything that person says automatically right. Believing in what someone says just because they have a PhD or some other advanced degree is the classic definition of the fallacy "appealing to authority".
On one hand, I do agree that getting a PhD is an accomplishment, and in general most people who do have them do have a certain higher level of intellect.
HOWEVER, and having said that, having a PhD does not necessarily make everything that person says automatically right. Believing in what someone says just because they have a PhD or some other advanced degree is the classic definition of the fallacy "appealing to authority".
originally posted by: ZetaRediculian
What qualifies him to request unwashed panties from women while they are under hypnosis....so he can check for alien dna? A phd in history?
Dr David Jacobs, PhD - Alien DNA Information gathering
originally posted by: ZetaRediculian
This Dr Jacobs guy? What qualifies him to do regressive hypnotherapy on people over the phone or on a "chat" program? yes, that is what he did. What qualifies him to request unwashed panties from women while they are under hypnosis....so he can check for alien dna? A phd in history?
Said degree does make that source's opinion more valuable however, as it's "confidence level" is higher. I will always give the opinion of a Ph.D. more weight, going in, than that of a layman.
I'm not sure my comments on other discipline's "information gathering" skills would be appropriate here. It is a rather low opinion at times. Let me just say that at times information gathering should be left to professionals. And by "professionals" I tend to mean Data and Computer science types.
"This is not consciousness-raising; this is like consciousness denying. This is consciousness-lowering in a sense. So I don’t have any stake in this. It would be wonderful if it is. I think that John Mack was just dead wrong in his analysis of this. In fact, he tried and tried and tried to ram the abduction phenomenon into his preconceived ideas about consciousness and never could. Most people don’t realize that he gave up. He said, “That’s it. I don’t want to do it anymore,” because it could never conform to his ideas. Two years before he died he stopped doing abduction research altogether, closed up his peer group at Harvard, and told Budd Hopkins that maybe he’d been a little too gullible in this situation of abductions. He could never fit it into what he wanted it to be."
Same thing that qualifies a Ph.D in theoretical nuclear physics to be an expert on conspiracies, Thanatology, Ufology, Parapsychology, and Cryptozoology.
Why do all of the men try to run
A big legged woman down?
Well, it must be the same old thing
That makes a bulldog love a hound
Well, it's the same thing
Well, it's the same old thing
Better tell me who is to blame
Well, the whole world is a-fighting all about that same thing
Read more: Muddy Waters - Same Thing Lyrics | MetroLyrics
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: tanka418
Let me just say that at times information gathering should be left to professionals. And by "professionals" I tend to mean Data and Computer science types.
You mean... like you?
:-))