It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
mysterioustranger
reply to post by Fylgje
This guy can play anything. And there is a backyard video of him just sitting with friends and playing something for them. He goes from blues, to jazz to country, to metal, fingerpicking, tricks and scales, classical to traditional songs I can even comprehend all in a medley with a little amp outside and its absolutely amazing....and Ive been playing and teaching 40+ yrs.
If I find it again, Ill post the link. Shut your eyes and listen. I dare ya...
CardiffGiant
reply to post by eggman90
i freaked when i first saw it because i spent a lot of time digging into him. i found some early deli creeps vids and even those had the blurr over his face. of course i cant prove this is him but i think it is. there is a picture floating around from about the same time of him in the newspaper as a winner of a guitar competition. he has the same puffy/curly hair. put that with the playing style and lanky robert johnson type fingers and i just think its him.
when he plays with claypool is magical. they are two of the great improvisers on their instrument and when they get in the groove its like nothing i have ever heard
im thinking buckethead can play anything by page or hendrix but not the other way around.
im sure of that.
Astyanax
reply to post by CardiffGiant
im thinking buckethead can play anything by page or hendrix but not the other way around.
im sure of that.
Musicianship is not the ability to play a series of notes.
Buckethead is certainly able to play with great fluency, facility and speed, but his music — to my ears at least — is bland and devoid of expression. A bit like that mask he wears, really.
he does more than just play a series of notes.
there is a lot of technique and theory there in his music
Astyanax
reply to post by CardiffGiant
The only comments I made about Buckethead are the ones you quoted.
he does more than just play a series of notes.
there is a lot of technique and theory there in his music
Theory and technique are not musicianship either. That's precisely the problem with people like Buckethead.
Sort of the opposite of the Kenny G problem, I guess.
edit on 27/11/13 by Astyanax because: of an unqouted
mysterioustranger
reply to post by CardiffGiant
It doesnt matter to me if Im into Rock, Standards, Metal, Alternative, Sinatra, or Django Reinhart....because I can appreciate talent. Wherever its found....
(and I like everything...due to being a multi-string-instrumentalist....AND keyboardist since 1963)
Gotta give credit to Buckethead...whether you like his image or not.
whats your definition? ...i am seriously interested. not to debate. just to know how others think about it
an ability to recognize such complex scales in chord form with voicings up and down the neck, with each note being a member of a "family".
someone like hendrix or page may have more 'sensitivity when it comes to their expression but what about their skills? technique? talent? theory? see what i mean?
i am not trying to turn you into a fan. not by any means.
i just think his skill should be recognized.
if you think friggin billy joe from green day is the best, then he is. thats how it works.
if theory and technique are not musicianship then how do you define it?
does the guitarist from the ramones have the best musicianship even though he knows a total of 3 chords, 2 power chords and a small chunk of a pentatonic scale.
mysterioustranger
reply to post by CardiffGiant
I think the way I was raised...an aunt was a professional jazz singer in the 40's-50's for NBC radio...I had a love for anything musical.
I think in all my years, successes and travels...Ive just come to accept ANYTHING musical....good , great or terrible...as what it is...music.
And, I dont have to like it to accept it. And Ive said before in referrence to "shredders"...Clapton or Robert Johnson...even B.B. King...can say more with 3 notes than with 30.
Astyanax
reply to post by CardiffGiant
whats your definition? ...i am seriously interested. not to debate. just to know how others think about it
So am I. And I have been some kind of musician for a very long time.
I see you are a musician too. So first... a word about theory.
Both standard minor scales contain a major seventh interval, so to say 'minor major seventh' is redundant. I would think of the scale you're talking about (if I thought of it at all) as a C major scale with one note moved a half-tone to fit it into the key of F minor. The notes are F, G, G#, B, C, D, E — the notes of the C major scale with a dropped sixth played over an F minor chord. How hard can that be to play? You just move one finger. It sounds complicated when you talk about it, I'll grant you that.
If you make your music out of scales you're probably barking up the wrong tree. That doesn't mean you shouldn't know the scales, and theory certainly helps you play in tune. But unless you're a composer, that's about the only use it is, seriously. Theory helps you play fewer bum notes.
an ability to recognize such complex scales in chord form with voicings up and down the neck, with each note being a member of a "family".
Nah, you don't have to know the names of any notes or scales or chords to do that. You just need an ear, and a fairly well-developed sense of melody.
You taste the music. Jimmy Page used to drool on stage. Though maybe there were other reasons for that, too.
someone like hendrix or page may have more 'sensitivity when it comes to their expression but what about their skills? technique? talent? theory? see what i mean?
No, actually. Sensitivity, and the ability to express it, are what musicianship is all about. The rest is just the stuff that surrounds it. It expands your vocabulary, but it doesn't give you anything more to say. That part you've got to supply yourself.
i am not trying to turn you into a fan. not by any means.
No chance. I can't go for that, as Hall (or was it Oates?) might have said.
i just think his skill should be recognized.
Well, he has his admirers. Though the live performances I just watched on YouTube to educate myself in the mysteries of Mr Buckethead did seem to be somewhat sparsely — though enthusiastically — attended.
What is music? I don't know. I know it when I hear it. I'm sure you can, too. I'm grateful to those who created the system — many systems, actually — of analysing and defining it. You can break it down all sorts of ways. Musical notation. Psychoacoustic components: melody, harmony, rhythm and tempo, timbre or tone colour. Being a guitar player with a weakness for wah and modulation effects in general (and an ex-physics student) I would definitely add 'phase' to this, since it's now such an important variable and we have become so conscious of it. I notice Buckethead uses a lot of modulation effects, including a touch wah that he switches on and off from the toggle just next to the tailpiece on that very heavily wired and preamp-ed axe of his.
I don't use them like he does. As I told someone once, the trick with wah is to learn to disconnect your pedal foot from your right hand — and from the drummer. Though connecting them can also give you a great buzz, like it gave Hendrix on the solo in 'All Along the Watchtower'. They didn't have sequencers and click tracks then to make it all seem a bit too easy.
if you think friggin billy joe from green day is the best, then he is. thats how it works.
Man, I don't think anyone is the best, or the worst (except me — and it can go either way, depending on the notes I just played). There are a lot of great guitar players I admire.
if theory and technique are not musicianship then how do you define it?
Brian Eno, producing the Talking Heads, once got so excited listening to a track they were making he unzipped his fly, stuck a banana into into it and went on conducting the band, crying 'This is giving me the horn. This is giving me the horn!' For my present purpose, I can't think of a better definition than that.
does the guitarist from the ramones have the best musicianship even though he knows a total of 3 chords, 2 power chords and a small chunk of a pentatonic scale.
Full barres, not power chords. And all downstrokes, man. Johnny only picked south.
Back in the day some idiot asked me for Joey Ramone's autograph.
Though I think I look more like Paul Reed Smith...