It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Phoenix267
This is nothing new in the media. I cannot believe people are starting to become outraged after years of the "music" industry marketed everything from sex, to drugs, to whatever. It's the most genius way to milk any individual for their money. I just wish it was different. But sadly I can see it won't change soon.
calstorm
reply to post by abeverage
Thank you for that! It was a very touching letter. I am a mom, not a dad, but I am going to show that to my boys.
daskakik
reply to post by abeverage
Lame.
Just as contrived as that VMA performance.
mblahnikluver
reply to post by abeverage
If you are so sick of hearing about Miley then WHY make a thread about her?
If you don't want to hear about it move along. I am sick of it too but it is what it is. Yes it's a distraction and yes I"m sure it was scripted and yes the music industry SUCKS but again it is what it is.
She has embarrassed herself and will regret it when she finally grows up.
abeverage
It actually had more to do with the blame not put squarely where it belongs as I pointed out on the Producers and Handlers of Miley and the show.
But MOSTLY I liked what the Dad said to his son and I wanted it to have some attention. And I was hoping some people might agree and next time shut their TV's off.
While I don't have a definite position on the situation, I'd like to ask you what responsibility does she have in all of this? We've pretty much rejected the "I was just following orders." defense, and she is an adult who was not facing physical coercion.
I have no outrage other then against the hypocrisy trying to pin this all on a CRAZY 20 year old girl!
daskakik
abeverage
It actually had more to do with the blame not put squarely where it belongs as I pointed out on the Producers and Handlers of Miley and the show.
Why the need to lay blame at all?
But MOSTLY I liked what the Dad said to his son and I wanted it to have some attention. And I was hoping some people might agree and next time shut their TV's off.
Why can't people be adults and keep the TV on and just take the performance for what it is?
abeverage
I was just pointing out the hypocrisy of blaming her for this which is pretty ludicrous.
People can (and obviously) do what they want. Over-sexualized scenes lack maturity and the VMA's are not designed for real Adults they are designed directly at Teens and pre-Adults.
Why do they need to take the performance (or lack of one) at all?
Unless you believe men should over sexualize and degrade women?
That it is ok for married men to simulate sex acts with girls 14 years younger?
Or that the music industry should take advantage of that as well?
daskakik
abeverage
I was just pointing out the hypocrisy of blaming her for this which is pretty ludicrous.
And I'm pointing out the hypocrisy in blaming anyone.
People can (and obviously) do what they want. Over-sexualized scenes lack maturity and the VMA's are not designed for real Adults they are designed directly at Teens and pre-Adults.
Teens and pre-adults that are already aware of sex. Why the hyperbole?
Why do they need to take the performance (or lack of one) at all?
They don't but that isn't any better or worse than watching it for what it is.
Unless you believe men should over sexualize and degrade women?
You would have to prove that it is actually the men degrading women.
That it is ok for married men to simulate sex acts with girls 14 years younger?
It was her choice and she's 20 so your point is moot.
Or that the music industry should take advantage of that as well?
Take advantage? Like the blogger?
abeverage
If we do not hold those accountable for their actions what do we do? Do we not blame anyone for anything? Do we loosen morals to what point and to what end?
I have to prove nothing, I asked a pointed and direct question Do you believe men should over sexualize and degrade women. and I will further it...do you believe that act was demoralizing and overly sexual?
You are correct it was her choice but again this is Directed question TO YOU...is it ok for a married man simulate sex acts with girls 14 years younger?
charles1952
reply to post by abeverage
I did not see her performance and, from what I've read about it here, do not care to. I am curious about an issue you've brought up with this:
While I don't have a definite position on the situation, I'd like to ask you what responsibility does she have in all of this? We've pretty much rejected the "I was just following orders." defense, and she is an adult who was not facing physical coercion.
I have no outrage other then against the hypocrisy trying to pin this all on a CRAZY 20 year old girl!
So, what is the justification? If she says, "I can do this offensive thing and make money from it," does that not reflect badly on her? And if she says, "There's nothing at all wrong with it," isn't that worse?
I'm sure there were pressures on her, but every time any of us have to make a decision there are pressures on us.
Originally posted by suz62
reply to post by abeverage
The blogger is right of course but the shock value always seems to rest with the woman who degrades herself. That is not how decent women behave in public.
He was standing there singing. She was acting like a pig.