It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by xXxinfidelxXx
reply to post by HauntWok
Okay, how about the fact that some of the larger blocks that were used in the construction of the Pyramids and other monuments from the Khemet era of Egypt were so heavy that they could not be picked up even using the biggest conventional (non-gantry) heavy lift cranes that we have had at our disposal until very recently? Minor details... Some of the blocks weighed in excess of 800 tonnes. To my knowledge only recently have cranes been built that can handle in excess of 1000 MT and they are 30 million dollar behemoths that sport multiple diesel powerpacks rated in excess of 1000 horsepower each. If we are only figuring out a means of lifting that kind of weight now, than how do you explain the Khemetians' ability to lift 800+ MT limestone blocks if all they had at their disposal was man-power and ropes?
Originally posted by WhiteAlice
Yes for such things would definitely be from the Gods or Heavens. It's like the Black Stone at Mecca. That, too, came from the Heavens long ago according to Islamic tradition and it's likely to be a meteorite or a by-product of a meteorite impact. I have a necklace made from meteorite so I suppose the practice of wearing carved meteorite is still in existence.
Originally posted by zeeon
In closing, it certainly is within the realm of possibility that 100,000 men built the pyramid over a 20 year span.
Based on our program management approach and our informed guesses we concluded that the
total project required an average workforce of 13,200 persons and a peak workforce of 40,000
and that it required two to three years of site preparation, five years of pyramid construction,
and two years of ramp removal, decoration, and other ancillary tasks. Assembling a workforce
of this size—and feeding it—appear to have been well within the capabilities of the Egyptian
economy at that time if the population was in fact 1 million to 1.5 million.
Originally posted by jonnywhite
My opinion is the ancients knew how to use the old methods to do things better than we know how to use them. They were masters. Instead we use the modern methods. I believe if we were placed into their time without our technology we would be incapable of the simplest things. We'd be laughed at and made fun of. That's why they deserve credit and some respect.edit on 23-8-2013 by jonnywhite because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by HauntWok
I so loathe the "ancient aliens" BS.
These people seem to think that ancient humans were completely retarded (in the literal sense of the word) and couldn't wipe their own behinds without help from some outer space cthulhu.
1) it's not that hard to cut limestone. It's a pretty soft stone after all.
2) it's not that hard to stack blocks one on top of another.
3) Yep, I completely buy that they would find an iron meteorite, heat it up crack it up, then make jewelry out of it. Wouldn't take a huge leap of thought to do that.
Humans are pretty smart, we have come up with some ingenious things throughout our time on this planet. There's no need for outer space people to come down and show us everything step by step.
Based on our program management approach and our informed guesses we concluded
The stones in the GP you refer to were most likely slid into place using what today we refer to as the Grand Gallery for a ramp, with counterweights on the opposite side of the pyramid.
Originally posted by VeritasAequitas
reply to post by Harte
Based on our program management approach and our informed guesses we concluded
Based on informed guesses? Well #, that's no more than what anybody else has...Again, just a theory, not ever proven fact.
Originally posted by VeritasAequitas
Seems like we've hit a raw nerve with this thread. Someone is sending out the big guns to debunk and discredit any meaningful conversation herein...edit on 24-8-2013 by VeritasAequitas because: (no reason given)
Definitive proof doesn't exist in the real world - only in mathematics and only because math is based on agreed-upon definitions and postulates that are themselves unproveable.
Now, if someone with "advanced" tech built the pyramids, why, exactly, are these ramp remains there?
Originally posted by MarioOnTheFly
reply to post by HauntWok
But it's absolutely doable.
But it's not....doable.
Go ask a master stone cutter...with all the today's tech...to reproduce one of the more complex blocks from Puma Punku...
Pure Granite, that can only be cut with diamond tips...and such outstanding precision...
Originally posted by VeritasAequitas
reply to post by Harte
I pointed out this argument so that for the record; you have indeed said that definitive proof doesn't exist in the real world...Try applying that to something completely subjective like remote viewing or astral projection when people like you want to nark on parapsychology.
Originally posted by VeritasAequitas
reply to post by Harte
Now, if someone with "advanced" tech built the pyramids, why, exactly, are these ramp remains there?
Mind showing me a picture of these remains?
Originally posted by bigfatfurrytexan
Originally posted by SKUNK2
Originally posted by HauntWok
I so loathe the "ancient aliens" BS.
These people seem to think that ancient humans were completely retarded (in the literal sense of the word) and couldn't wipe their own behinds without help from some outer space cthulhu.
1) it's not that hard to cut limestone. It's a pretty soft stone after all.
2) it's not that hard to stack blocks one on top of another.
3) Yep, I completely buy that they would find an iron meteorite, heat it up crack it up, then make jewelry out of it. Wouldn't take a huge leap of thought to do that.
Humans are pretty smart, we have come up with some ingenious things throughout our time on this planet. There's no need for outer space people to come down and show us everything step by step.
How did ancient people cut granite rock with hand tools???
The simple fact is people back then had technology around our level or even greater.edit on 23-8-2013 by SKUNK2 because: (no reason given)
I know, right?
We are all familiar with that hieroglyph showing how they used a diamond mining saw that was 100ft long.
Oh. Wait.....
Originally posted by Grimpachi
What you don't think red sandstone can be cut?
Originally posted by Harte
Originally posted by MarioOnTheFly
Than I guess at puma punku had some superior tools back than...even though the age of puma punku is speculated to be older than the Egypt era.
It is unquestionably true that the Tiahuanaco site - including Pumapunku - dates to the common era.
Originally posted by MarioOnTheFlySo what did they use...to cut granite ? Some older, but somehow superior tool to the later copper chisel.
There is no granite at Pumapunku. Assuming you mean the Egyptians, then, they used copper/bronze saws with sand as an abrasive. link
The technique has been duplicated in modern times by Stocks, Protzen et al.
Stocks' book: link
Quarrying link: link
Harte
Originally posted by Harte
The most recent technical estimation I'm aware of (1999) comes from the Architectural/Civil Engineering firm Daniel, Mann, Johnson, & Mendenhall (DMJM) - today known as AECOM:
Based on our program management approach and our informed guesses we concluded that the
total project required an average workforce of 13,200 persons and a peak workforce of 40,000
and that it required two to three years of site preparation, five years of pyramid construction,
and two years of ramp removal, decoration, and other ancillary tasks. Assembling a workforce
of this size—and feeding it—appear to have been well within the capabilities of the Egyptian
economy at that time if the population was in fact 1 million to 1.5 million.
Source: link