Woman Finds Missing Dog in Oklahoma Tornado Rubble

Originally posted by OutonaLimb

Originally posted by g146541
Sorry folks but Ima have to call fake on this one.
Dog is inches away from master and not so much as a bark??
I smell planned feel good news.

agree. only argument is is it staged on site/green screened/complete cgi???

i tend toward complete cgi! it all looks weird and the womans hand movements
give cause for reality concern.

I don't suspect any special editing, I call the very quiet dog into question.
Any trapped animal, especially one that knows he/she is loved, will call for help.
I'm thinking the news did this for ratings, fake just like everything else on tv..

Originally posted by g146541
Sorry folks but Ima have to call fake on this one.
Dog is inches away from master and not so much as a bark??
I smell planned feel good news.

Best feel good story of the day.

I enjoyed it after all the doom and gloom.

Sorry you didn't feel the same and want to "try" to ruin it for the rest of us.

Didn't work.

Originally posted by riverwild

Originally posted by g146541
Sorry folks but Ima have to call fake on this one.
Dog is inches away from master and not so much as a bark??
I smell planned feel good news.

Best feel good story of the day.

I enjoyed it after all the doom and gloom.

Sorry you didn't feel the same and want to "try" to ruin it for the rest of us.

Didn't work.

I did not try to ruin anything, I only pointed out a fact, and a big one too.
You see, I am a dog fan so I understand them somewhat.
But go ahead and believe what you need to, it is a nice story.

Originally posted by g146541
Sorry folks but Ima have to call fake on this one.
Dog is inches away from master and not so much as a bark??
I smell planned feel good news.

She said she was laying under some rubble right where she was standing, and when it hit, she was holding her dog. The dog was laying under ruble beside where she was lying in rubble. In all the chaos she probably was concerned of over things or was looking in the wrong spot, because the dog wasn't barking. The dog was probably knocked out, in shock, weak, scared, it was pinned, and thankfully not crushed. This is such a great interview, I have a beagle and black lab, and I would be crying if I found my dogs in the rubble after I thought they were lost, and I don't cry.

Could it have been they set it up for a feel good story of hope, yea, easily, but I don't think this is the case. As she told the news crew that her dog was under all that debris somewhere, one of them probably started scanning the debris, and saw the little guy moving it's head around in that dark opening.

i call BS as well. how does the dog only wind up under such small amount of rubble during the collapse and she never saw it until a news reporter just happens to show up at her place instead of the school where everyone else is filming?

my guess is she did lose her dog and couldn't find it then found it, the story got out and she reenacted finding her dog for the film crew. usually a kernel of truth to every story.

Its the same dog as Toto from the wizard of oz! Coincidence? I think not.

Women's house has just been ripped down but she's more concerned about her dogs well being, proof that love has more value than wealth. Loved this video.

Originally posted by g146541
Sorry folks but Ima have to call fake on this one.
Dog is inches away from master and not so much as a bark??
I smell planned feel good news.

My thoughts exactly.

Originally posted by Alpha Grey
yea..."God" answered her prayers and saved her dog......too bad the loving and just "god" let 20+ kids die.

let me guess...this is all part of his plan right ?? let kids die in fear ??


god is nowhere to be seen......he does not exist.

i take more offense (as a non believer) that she prayed for her dog at all...
according to the bible, animals do not have souls, or are even equal to people.
there are 100 more valid prayers she could have made that day, but her #2 was her concern for her personal property and her personal need for her pet.
how very disgusting and wasteful a thing to ask a god for. and yet thats the prayer god apparently granted.
just sad on all levels.

Originally posted by Bisman

i take more offense (as a non believer) that she prayed for her dog at all...
according to the bible, animals do not have souls, or are even equal to people.
there are 100 more valid prayers she could have made that day, but her #2 was her concern for her personal property and her personal need for her pet.
how very disgusting and wasteful a thing to ask a god for. and yet thats the prayer god apparently granted.
just sad on all levels.

oh oh...you had better watch talk like that or someone might wanna punch you in the face.

isn't that right 3xil3 ? ...

Originally posted by 3xil3
Id like to punch you in the face Alpha Grey

and and you too Kituwa ?.....

Originally posted by Kituwa

Originally posted by 3xil3
Id like to punch you in the face Alpha Grey

Get in line.

Typical reply of an imbecile........you don't like what is being said so you threaten violence.

I laugh at both of you.

............................................................................................

I bet your both not so tough in person......typical keyboard warriors.

maybe you can pray to 'god" to strike me down........I will wait for the lightning......and wait....and wait....

still waiting.......did you pray yet ???.........no lightning yet ???.......are you praying hard enough ????

This is my very first post reply on ATS. I would certainly hope that other more interesting and pressing topics will generate my interest and response.

But this post caught my attention because I love animals and have four dogs/I saw this interview yesterday/the cries of fake and staging prompted me to want to respond.

1: There is a much longer original segment of this news interview, which I think might ease some quick to judge as fake.
www.youtube.com...

2: I've been waiting for someone to claim that the tornado event was a "false flag", so I guess this post re: the dog being found while being interviewed comes close but quite a distance removed from a conspiracy about the whole tragedy.

reply to post by ICONvsICON


Ok, done watching.
Still as fake as the first time.
It sure is a nice story but, that is all it is.
A story, just like everything else on the dumb down box.
But it sure does give the "believers" something to grab onto.

reply to post by roughycannon


This was absolutely incredible!!!

reply to post by roughycannon


Not to be a wet blanket, but that dog looks like he was planted there. He's far too alert when taken out from under the metal sheeting, and there doesn't appear to be a scratch on him. Also, he is not exhibiting any separation anxiety. Heck, my dog lives outside, and HE has separation anxiety if I'm gone for a while. This pooch appears to be a lap dog.

Great news story... get them ratings up!

reply to post by Alpha Grey


Looks like you got your panties in a ruffle.

smile, be happy and clap your hands.

:

Alpha grey has personal issues and takes his frustration out on people over the internet to make himself feel better inside.

Pretty sad if you ask me.

Originally posted by 3xil3
Alpha grey has personal issues and takes his frustration out on people over the internet to make himself feel better inside.

Your the one who threatened me. I feel perfectly fine inside, what's your excuse troll ??

Pretty sad if you ask me.

yes you are pretty sad.


now go do your homework little boy.....or momma will send you to bed with no dinner.

Originally posted by Kituwa
reply to post by Alpha Grey

 

Looks like you got your panties in a ruffle.

those are NOT my panties....they belong to your mom.

smile, be happy and clap your hands.

:

already there.

reply to post by 3xil3


Yes, I noticed that.

Originally posted by 3xil3
Id like to punch you in the face Alpha Grey

edit on 21-5-2013 by 3xil3 because: (no reason given)

that doesnt sound very christian. Im assuming your christian since your so offended