It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by PieceOfThePuzzle
Originally posted by 4ajodster
They still haven't found a cause.
So far no problems found with gas lines.
usnews.nbcnews.com...
My opinion is its something other than from gas. I don't think its from a Meth lab. I think its something external looking at pictures because of the crater. Just my opinion.
Show me a good picture of the crater so I can try and see how you folks do. As I have said before, natural gas leak is currently the only plausible reason why as of right now.edit on 12-11-2012 by PieceOfThePuzzle because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by telemetry
...I dunno, this is odd indeed... and I'm not implying that he's the culprit, but it's certainly not out of the question if it does turn out to be a gas explosion.
Too many questions
Originally posted by Staroth
Happened 11/11 at 11PM
Originally posted by 4ajodster
Originally posted by PieceOfThePuzzle
Originally posted by 4ajodster
They still haven't found a cause.
So far no problems found with gas lines.
usnews.nbcnews.com...
My opinion is its something other than from gas. I don't think its from a Meth lab. I think its something external looking at pictures because of the crater. Just my opinion.
Show me a good picture of the crater so I can try and see how you folks do. As I have said before, natural gas leak is currently the only plausible reason why as of right now.edit on 12-11-2012 by PieceOfThePuzzle because: (no reason given)
You mean you haven't seen the pics yet? I find that hard to believe.
But here you go anyways.....
willyloman.files.wordpress.com...
www.indy.gov...
t0.gstatic.com...:ANd9GcRfXIPQ6SleMnzqRDPCWcDAYMw6GKjaHmfkqiaLysZ8qm4e41FP
r.m.yahoo.com...://media.zenfs.com/en_us/News/ap_webfeeds/30673edce2a8a01f200f6 a706700969a.jpg
Originally posted by 4ajodster
Originally posted by PieceOfThePuzzle
Originally posted by 4ajodster
They still haven't found a cause.
So far no problems found with gas lines.
usnews.nbcnews.com...
My opinion is its something other than from gas. I don't think its from a Meth lab. I think its something external looking at pictures because of the crater. Just my opinion.
Show me a good picture of the crater so I can try and see how you folks do. As I have said before, natural gas leak is currently the only plausible reason why as of right now.edit on 12-11-2012 by PieceOfThePuzzle because: (no reason given)
You mean you haven't seen the pics yet? I find that hard to believe.
But here you go anyways.....
willyloman.files.wordpress.com...
www.indy.gov...
edit on 12-11-2012 by 4ajodster because: removed last 2 links b/c broken and my phone sucks
Originally posted by telemetry
reply to post by djgray
Thanks for digging that up, it could be someone else with a similar name. That's odd, but plausible.
-
Folks, on that thought:
With some further research, it appears there are possibly two Monserrates.
1. The NASA one being Monserrate Roman who has three sons, and no daughters mentioned.
2. The other one that comes up as Monserrate Shirley (ex-husband's name is John) which is the one referenced to the house in question.
Until we get 100% confirmation on that, I just don't know... meaning I could be wrong on her being the NASA one I posted back around the 50th page. If so, my apologies to all for the mixup.
=========================
Moving on -
The articles I've read from today point to them having a daughter, who was the one that texted her father regarding the furnace problem. (ties into above point #1) here is the relevant quote:
"About a week and a half ago I got a text from my daughter that the furnace was out and they were going to spend the night at a hotel. If I were to suspect anything, that's where the problem was," said John Shirley, who is divorced and now lives in Noblesville, Ind.
Now here is where it gets suspect, from the same article... he goes on to say that he thinks that is what caused the problem... specifically:
bolded emphasis added.
I think that's what caused the problem. It either wasn't fixed correctly or, knowing my ex-wife, she probably compromised on the fix.
Then, goes on to say that she has a protective order against him. Hrrm.
Then this little gem:
Asked if he believed his ex-wife started the explosion intentionally, Shirley said, "I don't think so because there was no real reason to. I pay a thousand dollars a month for one kid because she had a lawyer and I did not, so she has more than enough money," he said.
emphasis added
From ABC News
After reading that, I found his comments kind of odd... and slightly contradictory. Mainly the one of him implying that she somehow skimped on the repair of the furnace, then goes on to say (paraphrased) that she has more than enough money.. so there is no real reason why she would blow up a house.
Uhh...
And add to the fact that the daughter was texting him about the furnace problem, instead of just saying something like... hey mom, furnace is messed up.. can you get someone over here to fix it? That makes no sense in my mind, was he supposed to pay to get it fixed instead? Why the need to contact him?
I dunno, this is odd indeed... and I'm not implying that he's the culprit, but it's certainly not out of the question if it does turn out to be a gas explosion.
Too many questions
The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) is an independent U.S. government investigative agency responsible for civil transportation accident investigation. In this role, the NTSB investigates and reports on aviation accidents and incidents, certain types of highway crashes, ship and marine accidents, pipeline incidents and railroad accidents.[1] When requested, the NTSB will assist the military and foreign governments with accident investigation.[1] The NTSB is also in charge of investigating cases of hazardous materials releases that occur during transportation. Deborah Hersman was appointed as NTSB Chairman in July 2009.[2] Christopher A. Hart was designated Vice Chairman on August 18, 2009 for a two-year term. The agency is based in Washington, D.C. It has nine regional offices around the country and runs a training center in Ashburn, Virginia.
Originally posted by badnickname
reply to post by PieceOfThePuzzle
So far the meteor theory has not been ruled out, quite contrary, we have several witnesses suposedly seeing something burning in the sky prior to the explosion.
Also, it was already established that the way the 2 houses were equaly demolished with the next 2 havin partial damage makes it hard to accept gas as the cause. Gas explosions are not directed explosions, are they...
Originally posted by WanDash
Originally posted by telemetry
...I dunno, this is odd indeed... and I'm not implying that he's the culprit, but it's certainly not out of the question if it does turn out to be a gas explosion.
Too many questions
Thanks for putting some effort into this...
The primary problem I have with this scenario would be - "Is he the kind of person that would risk killing his daughter in such a deliberate act?"
I know - there are plenty (too many to be comfortable with) of examples of such personalities...but - it takes a "special" circumstance or person to actually do it.
Originally posted by badnickname
reply to post by 4ajodster
First one is a picture of the place, not of a crater. A crater is a big effing hole, clearly visible to all who look at it, or it is no crater at all. There is no crater at this site.