It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
This theory is also inherently flawed as Even if Roosevelt had wanted to go to war, he would not have wanted to enter it with his fleet badly weakened. 11 Above all, Kahns argument is much more water tight than that of Wohlstetter and very well argued allying the relevant facts with his argument. The conspiracy theories do not counter his argument, but offer various reasons for his conclusion; that there w as no intelligence available to indicate that a Japanese attack was coming, let alone where, but on close analysis they can be seen as The facts as we can see them certainly seem to advocate Kahn’s thesis as little intelligence was available to Washington, which was because intelligence service was under rated and therefore under funded.
Originally posted by DenyObfuscation
reply to post by blocula
Have you come up with any evidence that anything actually happened as you propose or are you simply clinging to the thin thread of "it's possible"?
Originally posted by oxbow
Originally posted by DenyObfuscation
reply to post by blocula
Have you come up with any evidence that anything actually happened as you propose or are you simply clinging to the thin thread of "it's possible"?
Has blocula ever been able to supply one shred of credible evidence for any of his crazy theories? No, and he never will be able to because nonesuch exists. It's futile asking for any, or even entering into a debate about it.
Originally posted by blocula
reply to post by Koffee
This threads headline and its entire premise hit me like the proverbial ton of bricks one day while i was watching a documentary about the attack on pearl harbor....
The footage i watched and the words i listened to spoken by the narrator again and again,showed and explained about japanese airplanes upon japanese aircraft carriers that were positioned near pearl harbor, loading up their bombs and flying into the air,headed for their american targets...
Then i was shown footage of japanese pilots within japanese airplanes flying through the air and dropping their bombs...
Then i was shown footage of ships and docks exploding and burning at pearl harbor...
Then i was shown footage of a shocked and enraged president roosevelt declaring open war against japan very soon after the attack...
Well in reality,that footage of japanese aircraft carriers with japanese airplanes upon them could have been filmed just about anywhere,because those ships and airplanes were surrounded by nothing but sea and sky...
We dont really know where they really were,we only know where we are told to think they were...
The footage of japanese pilots in japanese airplanes and pearl harbor,were never showed at the same time within the same frames of film,not even once...
We dont really know where they really were flying and what they were really dropping their bombs upon,we only know where we are told to think they were...
All i saw was footage of japanese pilots in airplanes and then an edit and a cut to bombs falling upon ships and docks at pearl harbor...
Whos to say for sure,who really knows without any doubt those japanese pilots were really members of the japanese military from japan?
They easily could have been some of the forcibly interned without a choice japanese americans and or hawaiians and or americans hidden behind flying suits,head gear and goggles who were threatened with the torture and death of themselves and their families if they didnt do it,who were then coerced, forced,bribed and brainwashed into doing it...
Whos to say for sure,who really knows without any doubt those airplanes originated from japan,who knows for sure they were really built by japanese in japan?
Not one person within any branch of the american military ever laid their eyes upon the supposedly massive japanese naval armada,that we are told to think was positioned relatively near pearl harbor...
Trying to think and believe what i'm told to think and believe about those extremely vital and very hard to replace american aircraft carriers,that it was just a lucky coincidence they just happened to be mysteriously and way too conveniently missing from pearl harbor during the attack,is more than a little hard for me to swallow...
We dont really know where they really were,we just know where we are told to think they were...
Imo,i know where they really were and i know what they were really doing...
Originally posted by Vitruvian
reply to post by blocula
Originally posted by blocula
As off the wall as this may seem to a lot of people,i think far outside the box and this is not beyond the realm of reality and it is not without strong possibility...
December 7th 1941,a day that will live in infamy,is that actually the greatest false flag conspiracy of all time?
BLOCULA - Thanks for your courage in presenting these ideas. This whole topic is EXTREMELY TABOO in the USA. I know of no person who will discuss it with me........."you're crazy" blah blah
I wrote a letter to Henry Makow recently asking him why the "waters" of Pearl harbor are so "sacred." Same as the fraudulent 9/11 Memorial site - hallowed ground! No one is allowed near the place to do anything whatsoever. Why were the bodies of the "slain soldiers" not brought up for proper burial. Where were the families? The bodies of the men and women were supposedly just beneath the surface - as in NOT DEEP. The entire matter is shrouded in utmost secrecy in the same manner as the alleged VICTIMS of 9/11.
I was suggesting to him that 3,000 or so Americans DID NOT DIE at Pearl Harbor and that is was all a scam to get us into the war - this in a similar manner as the fact that NEITHER DID 3,000 or so Americans DIE on 9/11.................9/11 was the exact same kind of terror scam as was Pearl Harbor.......
Makow never answered my letter.............
The fraud of Pearl harbor is exactly the same as the 9/11 fraud and 9'11 is actually an extension of what was begun in WWII.
Keep up the good work BLOCULA even though they will villify you for doing so.............
The # 3,000 "dead" was just too coincidental for me and that's what got me to thinking along these lines.
The very same mystery surrounds both events - as in "government controlled conspiracies" - both events are intimately connected to one another.
edit on 6-7-2012 by Vitruvian because: edit
One question still haunts visitors to the Arizona Memorial even to this day. Why were the dead not removed? Initially, about 105 bodies were removed but because the ship was never raised, the remainder could not. The priority at that time was salvage of ships that could be repaired -- the ARIZONA was not in that category. As a result, the bodies deteriorated to the point of not being identifiable. Even as late as 1947, requests were made in regard to removal of the dead, but rejected. They are considered buried at sea by the US Navy.
Originally posted by blocula
reply to post by Koffee
Who was able to get their above the law eyes and hands upon those japanese records and japanese materials long before they were released to the public? and who most likely edited and altered them long before they were allowed to be seen and read? It doesnt take sherlock holmes or a rocket scientist to figure out the answer...
edit on 6-7-2012 by blocula because: (no reason given)
I dont want to see another one of my favorite threads getting axed
Originally posted by Koffee
But hey I know its more fun to live in fantasy land where your the only guy with the Truth because you dare question something but the problem is you don't actually question anything you go "it could be so and I want it to be so despite evidence to the contrary it shall be so" and you end up saying dumb things like that US blew up its central force in its war plans to fight Japan so it could fight Japan.
Originally posted by vkey08
I hate to jump in at this late a stage, but being originally from Japan, I can say with pretty much certainty, while Pearl was not their original target and there is some contention as to how it actually became a target (there are several conspiracy theories about this) Japan certainly did as a nation attack the United States in order to drag them into a Pacific War and attempt to keep the US out of Europe. It did not work, as planned, the United States ended up sending it's huge war machine to both Europe and the Pacific, fighting a two front war and winning it, nuking two Japanese cities and leaving most of the home islands in ruin.
There's really nothing to this theory of yours seriously Blocula....
I've been explaining how the commonly embraced and currently accepted versions of important,world altering historical events,may not have always happened in the ways we are told to think and taught to believe they did and i've showed various alternative scenarios that might have and have since been suppressed...
Originally posted by Koffee
Originally posted by blocula
reply to post by Koffee
Who was able to get their above the law eyes and hands upon those japanese records and japanese materials long before they were released to the public? and who most likely edited and altered them long before they were allowed to be seen and read? It doesnt take sherlock holmes or a rocket scientist to figure out the answer...
edit on 6-7-2012 by blocula because: (no reason given)
Again its the giant magical conspiracy, who are these people, how they did change the records, these are pretty big claims, why hasn't any Japanese person said this is BS, how do you know they did this? The answer is you don't and your just grasping for straws. Why are you the only one who believes this is the case?
Proof please provide some. Other then saying a wizard did it over and over again.