It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
[Editor’s Note: W is an experienced soldier with combat experience in several corners of the world. They are now working as a PMC and cannot reveal their identity due to the possibility of backlash. As they put it, “The military is a very, very tight-knit community.” This article has been edited for style and clarity; no additions or deletions have been made.]
Disclaimer: I am not an academic. I have no education past the age of 16, so my writing may be rough. What I do have is an entire adulthood of military service, which I terminated recently when I decided I wanted more money for doing the same job.
I am a private military contractor, and I have an issue with the depiction of war in videogames — or more specifically, the soldiers in those games.
When I say soldier, let me be clear that I am talking about the Infantryman and the Special Forces operator, as I have next to no knowledge about anything outside of this relatively small percentile of service personnel.
Unfortunately, the vast majority of games featuring the military focus on these frontline combat troops in “realistic” action. And that’s where we get problems.
Next time you watch a military documentary, ask yourself why only 3 or 4 men are ever interviewed from a unit. The answer?
The rest of them are like me.
There’s a reason the new guy always gets put on point and nobody really cares when he gets blown up, that so many incidents of collateral damage go unreported, that failed missions are spun into something positive like gathering “valuable intel,” and why only roughly 20% of combat troops ever get PTSD – when if you think about it, it should affect everyone that ever sees combat.
It’s because the vast majority of us are straight up sociopaths.
Heroes are a myth. Every incident I can recall in war that created a hero was either an accident or ended up with said hero in a body bag.
Which makes the “hero” myth a fight of luck versus stupidity, a roll of the dice.
We all make calculated risks in war. Not one of us would make that risk if we genuinely thought it would get us killed.
I’ll say it again. Heroes in a frontline combat context do not exist.
It is an all volunteer system so it is by choice that these kids join.They choose to take a career of obedience to authority and the main job of killing other people. Only two kinds of people take a job like this. The brainwashed or the psychopath.
I find it very interesting this society has taken the psychopath and given them such power.
Hey you are welcome happy to bolster your ego. Glad you found a group that could make you feel good about yourself. And you are sooo right not everyone can be a marine some of us were too good and became seals.
But this is something that needs to be addressed and talked about. This culture of war mongers that probably exists within the military that are just oh so happy to use their trained skills to murder and kill people, without a second thought to the consequences.
In any case, regardless of how much weight you put into this man's theory and story, it certainly should make you think as this is a VERY different perspective than the cookie cutter one we are given by the media.
Thoughts?
There’s a reason the new guy always gets put on point and nobody really cares when he gets blown up, It’s because the vast majority of us are straight up sociopaths.
We all make calculated risks in war. Not one of us would make that risk if we genuinely thought it would get us killed.
Originally posted by tothetenthpower
An article I found just this week regarding the depiction of soldiers in video games, versus the actual truth of the matter.
Originally posted by tothetenthpower
This culture of war mongers that probably exists within the military that are just oh so happy to use their trained skills to murder and kill people, without a second thought to the consequences.
Originally posted by tothetenthpower
In any case, regardless of how much weight you put into this man's theory and story, it certainly should make you think as this is a VERY different perspective than the cookie cutter one we are given by the media.
Originally posted by seabag
reply to post by AmericanPitBull
It is an all volunteer system so it is by choice that these kids join.They choose to take a career of obedience to authority and the main job of killing other people. Only two kinds of people take a job like this. The brainwashed or the psychopath.
I find it very interesting this society has taken the psychopath and given them such power.
Excuse me…wasn’t it you just a few weeks ago telling me that you are a former Navy SEAL? (If I'm wrong then I apologize but I don't think I am)
So I must ask the obvious question, which category do you fit in to? Brainwashed or psychopath?
Originally posted by AmericanPitBull
Only two kinds of people take a job like this. The brainwashed or the psychopath.
Originally posted by AmericanPitBull
Only two kinds of people take a job like this. The brainwashed or the psychopath.
I was the first but became the second. Do not presume I do not recognize the reality of this. How about you? are you unscathed by what doing your duty requires? If so you must be the same.
See my realizations came while dealing with a wrecked body that was cast aside by those I served. So I admit I am damaged goods and I recognize it. What are we now? The "global force for good" is it? Any hoo not an attack on you just wondered if you have given it any thought? As I have had many sleepless nights over it myself.
BTW I am not in the habit of playing into an obvious trolling post but am giving you the benefit of doubt you are not just a troll.
Do you have anything to add to the Op or are you gonna make me wrong?
Originally posted by seabag
Sometimes in society we have to kill people and break things for the greater good. Evil must be killed and killing evil does not make a person evil IMO. I’ve NEVER met a person who cherished or enjoyed time in war…that would be a true psychopath or sociopath.
Selfish, callous and remorseless use of others:
Glibness/superficial charm (smooth-talking, engaging and slick)
Grandiose sense of self-worth (greatly inflated idea of one's abilities and self-esteem, arrogance and a sense of superiority)
Pathological lying
Conning/manipulative (uses deceit to cheat others for personal gain)
Lack of remorse or guilt (no feelings or concern for losses, pain and suffering of others)
Emotional poverty (limited range or depth of feelings)
Callous/lack of empathy (a lack of feelings toward others; cold, contemptuous and inconsiderate)
Failure to accept responsibility for own actions (continued)
Originally posted by AmericanPitBullBTW the term psychopath is hardly a real slam.
About 80-85% of incarcerated criminals have Antisocial Personality Disorder. However, only about 20% of these criminals would qualify for a diagnosis of being a psychopath. Most psychopaths meet the criteria for Antisocial Personality Disorder, but most individuals with Antisocial Personality Disorder are not psychopaths. Psychopaths account for 50 percent of all the most serious crimes committed, including half of all serial killers and repeat rapists.
Originally posted by AmericanPitBullLook into the how many folks fall into the category and lead normal lives. Until you really understand what is being said when saying psychopath, that it does not mean raving lunatic, we can't discuss this more in depth.
Originally posted by AmericanPitBull
My entire families history is war for America since WWII. We have sent and lost at least one member in each major action since (note I did not say war as we have not actually declared war since WWII, right) I am not the last body we are throwing at the war machine either as my nephew is in Afghanistan right now.
See I am not freaking threatened by the fact that we all have a strong protective spirit of America mixed with an unhealthy dose of " will to violence"
So if I don't get pissing on dead enemies, flying nazi symbols and naming bases after the " Aryan" nation is today's military.