It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Yes, religion is just some label of identity whether in which fantasy movie script u put ur belief in. And it is worst when the reason to embrace a particular religion is simply to seek safety in numbers, than u are a truly soulless and tasteless sheeple.
Originally posted by JoshF
reply to post by coyote66
Yes, religion is just some label of identity whether in which fantasy movie script u put ur belief in. And it is worst when the reason to embrace a particular religion is simply to seek safety in numbers, than u are a truly soulless and tasteless sheeple.
The irony is that atheists repeat this like a christian repeats a bible passage, who are the "sheeple"?
Originally posted by nusnus
reply to post by coyote66
Okay I'll try to explain this is the best way possible.
What do we mean by organized religion? just a bunch of organized rules to follow off a book? if that was the case then any kind of manual could be characterized as 'organized'. What I mean by organized religion is humans coming to form an organization, a pyramid structure of people, beginning from a base of believers, then upwards where fewer and fewer people get more and more power. And they are all connected by the sheer fact that those on the bottom level, HAVE TO obey those on top. Sort of like a company.
Now historically speaking Christianity did not start off as organized religion. It was simply one man, against corruption of Jews and their friends, treating people like they were items of business etc. Jesus never formed a church, or a structure where people were tied to obey. So where did churches come from? Where did the concept of a Pope come from? Its all in history, so I shall not repeat this here.
Basically over time, Christianity has become a religion where people had to be a part of an organized group i.e. their church. (this is still the case in many places around the world isn't it) They go to their church, and pay tithe, and listen and feel compelled to do as their ministers tell them. And if they were to lets say, want to advance in their religious studies, they would have to study and study and pass exams to become someone higher up.
Allow me to ask you something here, since when did spirituality become something you can earn on a piece of paper? Who has the right to tell you that you are now 'closer to God' because you've passed exams, set by human beings? Isn't there something about only God judging a humans worth in the Bible somewhere?
This is what I mean by organized religion. It puts the power of control of masses, in the hand of one man (or a couple), i.e. an organization. And this is very dangerous, its not something God intended for anyone. Because only God can judge the worth of people. And humans, no matter how amazingly devout they are, cannot be trusted when it comes to their EGO. No body is infallible, and no one is above Gods law. So even creating 'levels' of spirituality through some sort of human interaction is sin, a very grave one at that.
There are people who understand this concept within Christianity but their numbers are few, they come in many different names, gnostics, etc.
But I hope this explains the difference I was referring to. Even though there are Muslims who have tried, and continue trying to create similar organizations to control the masses, they will fail. Because there is not a single verse in the Quran that points at the need for other men, or intercession or taking anyone as a leader in order to reach God. Whereas with the advent of the Trinity in Christianity, the basis for creating organizations led by men, to control men, have been put forward in the past and very few Christians recognize the problem for what it is.
Originally posted by nusnus
Am I a liberal Muslim? No, I'm simply a Muslim who tries to see what the current world needs, and projects that in there to create balance. A lot of Muslims would not be able to pull so much information out and place them in great sentences. But a lot of people are very average minded, who do not wish to go deeper and deeper and study their religion. They just want to perform the tenets and live the way thats easier to live.edit on 10-2-2012 by nusnus because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by andersensrm
reply to post by Starchild23
Nope religion is about control. Its a Us vs. Them mechanism, and its been at work for a long time. Hypothetically, ancient humans would have used these tactics to band together against neanderthals and taking them out, now we group together by race, by religion, by sexual orientation, but we forget how we have more similarities than differences. As long as we hace an Us vs. Them mentality there will never be peace, end of story.
Originally posted by andersensrm
reply to post by coyote66
The hierarchy system of high class, middle class, low class, or those at the top of the pyrimid the middle or the bottom, this is a very primitive system.