It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by crazydaisy
I can see this spreading to other states
in a jiffy. Once you are considered a
dealer you have to pay taxes on what
you sell. I think that is the reason for
the law - they want more money for
items that have already been taxed.
So many people supplement their
income during these difficult economic
times by selling an item they have
had around for a while. They are taking
food from children and worse passing
laws such as this. Children love helping
their parents have yard sales, they learn
about money and sales. They have fun
with the lemonade stands - this country
is just chopping down on every one and
everything except for the things they should
be concentrating on.
By not using cash the seller will have
to report everything sold second hand.
Oh where are the good old days when
you could sell your old sewing machine
to put food on the table or pay a bill
until you got paid. The days of trade
are gone!edit on 12-10-2011 by crazydaisy because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by usernameconspiracy
Why is everyone completely ignoring the many rational posts explaining the law, and spouting off with completely unfounded and rather stupid overractions? READ! Many on this thread have explained the law perfectly. It's not new. It's not directed at yard sales. It never will be.
Louisiana is simply catching up to the scrap and pawn laws of other states. Unless you are one of those nutjobs that fears producing identification when making a transaction (a common practice used in every day life) this law will never, ever hurt you...unless you knowingly bought stolen property. Then you get yours.
Originally posted by DragonTattooz
Originally posted by usernameconspiracy
Why is everyone completely ignoring the many rational posts explaining the law, and spouting off with completely unfounded and rather stupid overractions? READ! Many on this thread have explained the law perfectly. It's not new. It's not directed at yard sales. It never will be.
Louisiana is simply catching up to the scrap and pawn laws of other states. Unless you are one of those nutjobs that fears producing identification when making a transaction (a common practice used in every day life) this law will never, ever hurt you...unless you knowingly bought stolen property. Then you get yours.
Here's rational for you- How about the lawmakers write the law in such a way that it makes the intent clear? This law can cover everything that has been discussed in this thread. Just because you are one of those nutjobs who trusts the government doesn't make you right, it actually makes you a person who is incapable of critical thinking. Just follow the leader, he will show you exactly where you need to go.
To call a person a nutjob because he doesn't think he should need to show ID in order to take part in a transaction makes you sound like a government shill. Just re-read your statement and if you don't see the problem with it, then I will write you off as a lost cause.
Originally posted by seachange
Cash Transactions Banned on Used Goods in Louisiana!
www.sott.net
(visit the link for the full news article)
"A secondhand dealer shall not enter into any cash transactions in payment for the purchase of junk or used or secondhand property. Payment shall be made in the form of check, electronic transfers, or money order issued to the seller of the junk or used or secondhand property..."
...
"They must also make a detailed description of the item(s) purchased and submit this with the personal identification information of every transaction to the local policing authorities"
edit on 12-10-2011 by getreadyalready because: fixed spelling in titleedit on 12-10-2011 by getreadyalready because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by usernameconspiracy
Originally posted by DragonTattooz
Originally posted by usernameconspiracy
Why is everyone completely ignoring the many rational posts explaining the law, and spouting off with completely unfounded and rather stupid overractions? READ! Many on this thread have explained the law perfectly. It's not new. It's not directed at yard sales. It never will be.
Louisiana is simply catching up to the scrap and pawn laws of other states. Unless you are one of those nutjobs that fears producing identification when making a transaction (a common practice used in every day life) this law will never, ever hurt you...unless you knowingly bought stolen property. Then you get yours.
Here's rational for you- How about the lawmakers write the law in such a way that it makes the intent clear? This law can cover everything that has been discussed in this thread. Just because you are one of those nutjobs who trusts the government doesn't make you right, it actually makes you a person who is incapable of critical thinking. Just follow the leader, he will show you exactly where you need to go.
To call a person a nutjob because he doesn't think he should need to show ID in order to take part in a transaction makes you sound like a government shill. Just re-read your statement and if you don't see the problem with it, then I will write you off as a lost cause.
So, you personally refuse to show ID when you make a purchase using your credit card when asked by the cashier? You personally refuse to show ID when purchasing alcohol when asked to do so by the cashier? I'm just asking.
So you would prefer that one law be specific about pawn shops. Then another law be specific about scrap yards where thieves sell stolen copper. It makes sense that the law be vague in its intent to cover whatever situations occur.
In the example of a yard sale, we are referencing a one or two day event that a special permit has been given to (if they followed the city code), which would not constitute a business. Now if that yard sale is every weekend, we have a different story as they are entering "business" territory and may very well have to comply.
By the way, reading this law and applying it to a yard sale is not critical thinking. If you are a minor and you try to sell a blue ray player at a pawn shop, you will be denied because it is illegal. Nothing nefarious; just illegal to conduct a transaction with a minor. If you want to go to a pawn shop and sell a Rolex, you will have to fill out forms and provide ID. I don't know of a state that does not require this. It isn't really about you, as hard as it is to believe. It's about the fact that criminals frequent pawn shops to sell stolen Rolex watches because, in the past, they got cash and were out the door. Now they have to provide ID and are forced to take a check.
Critically thinking, how is this a bad thing?