Why Elenin broke up...A Skunkworks hypothesis

reply to post by chr0naut


thanks for proving exactly what i said

(did you even read my post, or just assume i was incorrect)

reply to post by BadBoYeed


Yes, i read your post. You suggested that comet Elenin broke up being torn between the gravity of The Sun and the gravity of Nibiru.

If you re-read my response, you will see that the gravity of Nibiru is not required and that the gravity and heat of the Sun is sufficient to cause the break-up.

There is no evidence of the gravity of Nibiru or any other celestial object similar, existing within the confines of the solar system.

... and no evidence that this somehow affected the path and the break-up of this comet.

Everything is conveniently explained by known science and existing forces.

reply to post by chr0naut


my point was, and because you quoted not my OP but one of my responses.

therein lies the confusion

If Elenin was a satellite of Nibiru.....

a) it would be moving on a very strange orbital path relative to the Sun.
b) Nibiru would be a large, bright object visible in the night sky.
c) Gravitational perturbations would have been detected in the orbits of the planets and asteroids.

Trust me, C/2010 X1 Elenin is in solar orbit.