posted on Sep, 17 2011 @ 07:56 PM
Originally posted by Elzon
Originally posted by RanDeLv2
reply to post by SplitInfinity
This will sound stupid ... what if they just make the projectiles reflect the laser ? It's a high tech material called a mirror that would make the
laser waste 99% of it's energy.
Indeed, if they have the capability to bend light (they do) then defeating this type of weapon is near effortless. The only ways to defeat such craft
is to somehow overcome their effective deflection limits (how much energy it takes to deflect something). So if you overcome the amount of energy the
craft can use over a certain surface area then you will cause penetration
The 'holy grail' is an x-ray or gamma-ray laser, which is extremely hard to achieve and extremely hard to 'deflect'.
Yes if these supposed ET's have gravitational warp drive, it would also affect EM radiation---note that this works two ways. If x-rays were deflected
around the ship, then the occupants couldn't see out. Presumably an x-ray laser attack would have a very short-lived pulse and may be successful if
the target were not able to adjust sufficiently fast. More to the point, it is possible that the warp-drive effects necessary to deflect an x-ray
laser attack would be incompatible with the craft's usual freedom of navigation using such warp drive. So it could be a (temporarily) successful
denial-of-operations weapon even against an advanced ET with warp drive.
During the mid-80's the large-scale x-ray laser was a pet project of Edward Teller for SDI. The only feasible design at that time required exploding
a substantial thermonuclear warhead in space (and potentially causing a damaging EMP on Earth) with some (obviously) one-time use only x-ray lasing
cavities/assemblies.
In the context of the Cold War, this would be a desperately offensive "defensive" weapon, virtually impossible to use rationally. In its explicit
deployment, it would have to be detonated over the USSR only a few minutes after ICBM's were launched.
And what if the detection was a false alarm? From the USSR's point of view, the USA just detonated a space-based H-bomb to cause a EMP, which is the
classic opening shot of WOPR's game of Global Thermonuclear War. So, it's exceptionally dangerous to ever deploy; it is an offensive weapon of
desperation with apparently little sensible use in usual strategic scenarios.
I don't know if this technology is remotely feasible or deployed; I generally doubt it.
edit on 17-9-2011 by mbkennel because: (no reason
given)
edit on 17-9-2011 by mbkennel because: (no reason given)
edit on 17-9-2011 by mbkennel because: (no reason
given)