Is this Elenin or not?

The coma of elenin is supposed to be 200,000 km or 124,000 miles as the recent news are saying.
The planet Jupiter is 143,000 km or 88,700 miles.
Jupiter is 9 times farther away than elenin...so how come the elenin is not 9 times bigger on this soho video?

Because of the low density gas surroundig it or maybe if we look through an infrared we will see the real elenin?

Your opinion?

reply to post by borutp



elenin is psyop bull

reply to post by borutp


I mus say, i don't believe any of this Elenin stuff. it seems like yet another distraction. so much time and energy is being spent on this instead of the things we should be focusing on. I, personally, can't wait for it to pass and for everyone to wake up and stop falling for this sort of nonsense.
Now, about that major earthquake coming our way. I sure as hell hope it doesn't decide to strike when that hurrican hits. Talk about a one/two punch.

The minimum distance from earth to jupiter is 365 million miles.

Or did I miss your meaning?

reply to post by borutp

The coma of elenin is supposed to be 200,000 km or 124,000 miles as the recent news are saying.
The planet Jupiter is 143,000 km or 88,700 miles.
Jupiter is 9 times farther away than elenin...so how come the elenin is not 9 times bigger on this soho video?

Because of the low density gas surroundig it or maybe if we look through an infrared we will see the real elenin?

Your opinion?

You are correct; the coma, though large, is not very dense.

Can a 120mm refractor or 25x100 binoculars see Elenin ?

I cannot try as the northern hemisphere doesn't see it until next year.

It is currently day time only in the north atm.

reply to post by borutp


er. Ignore me.
Misread the original post.

reply to post by geraldcole


Yes and this divided by 9 is approx. the current distance of elenin

reply to post by borutp


Maybe Elenin is not traveling alone. I have seen some video footage that seems to show two other objects with her. Two sisters. So the Stereo B images may be altered.

One of the sisters may come closer to earth than expected. That's what I think.

Originally posted by borutp
reply to post by geraldcole

 

Yes and this divided by 9 is approx. the current distance of elenin

Okay I see what you mean, I'm with you now!

I'm pretty sure it's based on the strength of the lens and the distance from that lens, it has to do with being a point source of light.

I think, but I could be wrong.

reply to post by borutp


The image of Elenin in that clip could be superimposed from a video taken at an earlier time. This reminds me of the pictures of the lunar rovers that NASA released. After a big build up, we see just pixelated squibs that show nothing.

Stereo B could of and should have shown some really spectacular pictures of Elenin. It is my opinion that we are being "jobbed". Also consider if Elenin is part of the Nibiru solar system then it too could be mostly visible in infrared. I would guess it to be about 14K not 4K and composed of some very dense matter. This is my opinion.

Any astronomers here have their own images of Elenin?

reply to post by yourmamaknows

Stereo B could of and should have shown some really spectacular pictures of Elenin. It is my opinion that we are being "jobbed". Also consider if Elenin is part of the Nibiru solar system then it too could be mostly visible in infrared. I would guess it to be about 14K not 4K and composed of some very dense matter. This is my opinion.

Why do you hold this opinion? Given that the nucleus is less than 4 kilometers across, and that its tail is not very extensive, it is surprising that the comet is visible at all in these images! Why do you think the pictures should have been spectacular? Why do you think that because something does not confirm your own beliefs, we are being "jobbed?" Please explain how something can be part of the "Nibiru solar system" yet clearly be orbiting the Sun? Why would something from this mythical solar system mostly be visible in the infrared? Why do you believe comet C2010X-1 is very dense? It was observed passing through the asteroid belt and it had no effect on the asteroids it passed near, hence, has very little mass. Please explain your reasons for your opinions, I'm genuinely curious.

Originally posted by DJW001
reply to post by borutp

 

The coma of elenin is supposed to be 200,000 km or 124,000 miles as the recent news are saying.
The planet Jupiter is 143,000 km or 88,700 miles.
Jupiter is 9 times farther away than elenin...so how come the elenin is not 9 times bigger on this soho video?

Because of the low density gas surroundig it or maybe if we look through an infrared we will see the real elenin?

Your opinion?

You are correct; the coma, though large, is not very dense.

!Hombre, tu por aqui! (translation) You again! Shoveling out the soft serve.

How do you know the coma is not very dense? Did you take a sample? We can read the same reports and look at the same visuals as you, one way or the other.

reply to post by yourmamaknows

How do you know the coma is not very dense? Did you take a sample? We can read the same reports and look at the same visuals as you, one way or the other.

First of all, the fact that it has been expanding pretty much proves that it is not a solid, but a gas. The laws governing the behavior of a gas have been fully understood for nearly two centuries now. Unless constrained, they expand. Since matter is not created spontaneously, all of the material in the coma must have originated in the nucleus. Since the nucleus, however massive and, hence, dense, it really is is only a few kilometers across we can instantly see that the material has expanded to fill a volume 100,000,000 times larger than it did originally. In other words, however dense and massive you imagine the nucleus to be, the coma is at least one hundred million times less dense! Why is it we can see the same pictures and read the same measurements and yet you seem unable to believe their logical consequences?

reply to post by yourmamaknows


Sighting ignorance is not proposing a strong case for proof. Now show us these fantastic images from STEREO B you seem to think its supposed to take.

astrobob.areavoices.com...

october seems to be the Northern hemisphere date of visbility.

reply to post by yourmamaknows


Nibiru is (supposedly) coming from the other direction
Maybe they will collide in a huge galactic-level firework show, and we will have front-row seats.
How's that for luck

Will us vikings up north north be able to see it all..??

It would be nice to show the kids...