Originally posted by Itisnowagain
Then what is your purpose? Why do you post here?
Excellent question. My motivations are manifold. As best as I can discern them and put English words to them, I will lay them out. I will keep it
fairly shallow for brevity's sake (but the rabbit hole of motivation is a rather deep one).
Firstly, my reasons for being here at all. I surf ATS more or less as a pastime now when more important things are on hold, poking my head into
topics that capture my interest and commenting if I desire to add something. I value truth highly, I would say religiously, which not only means
pointing things out to people when they seem to be missing something, but also not shying away from being challenged. This latter is very important
not only because having one's mind changed is a bonus for a truth-seeker, but also because it allows close observation of the emotional factors that
crop up seeking to prevent "exposure", to prevent being shown to be wrong. In this way I learn more about myself and how my unconscious works.
In the case of this thread, I first commented because the OP resonated with me, especially the importance of mindfulness and a sense of personal
responsibility (in the sense of "owning" one's own words and actions). I wanted to throw in my take on it, which involves my personal experiences,
religious views, and psychology, and wanted to recommend a couple of excellent books that have led to a lot of self-understanding on my part. I have
an enormous amount of respect for the late Karen Horney, especially her later works, those being the two books I recommended in my first post in this
thread.
Then, I wanted to respond to you in particular, because while having an attitude of mindfulness, of being in the present, is definitely a very
skillful trait, I got the impression that when you spoke about it, you were speaking only from your own experience and ignoring the fact that other
people come from different backgrounds and/or are at different phases in their lives and will not see things the same way you do. I was trying to
help you see some perspective in this area.
I continued doing this for the next couple of posts, but we never seemed to establish any kind of rapport. I started to get the feeling we would
never understand each other, and started to speculate in my own head whether you are truly a totally anxiety-free spirit as you claim, or whether you
really, really wish you were but in fact have simply chosen to withdraw from active living in order to avoid anxiety-provoking situations.
(Incidentally, if the latter is true, you might learn a lot from Horney's
Neurosis and Human Growth, in particular the chapter on neurotic
resignation.)
In my latest posts my motivation is almost strictly an attempt to get under your skin. This is both due to a prankish, playful mood, and for what you
might call scientific reasons in light of not knowing where to place you. Actually I think the two reasons largely mesh together.
That is, except for this post, which is once again in a more expository spirit.
So, how about you?
edit on 26-7-2011 by NewlyAwakened because: (no reason given)