It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
You are welcome. Gurjieff is indeed a very interesting figure.
Originally posted by seaside sky
Thanks for that correction!
I don't think it is necessary to change the title, because Central Europe with Austro-Hungarian monarchy was one of the major players in this drama. Croatia and Slovenia were parts of it, with Croatia in the role of defending the borders with Otoman Empire.
By the way, I'm thinking about changing the title of the thread to Southeast Europe and Balkans, as I think I mis-spoke a little there- I was originally considering the connections throughout a very large area, but it's really looking like it's an enormously complicated thing, and perhaps ought to be limited in the scope?
Originally posted by Kretenoid
Originally posted by seaside sky
reply to post by Kretenoid
Thank you for replying so quickly! I look forward to hearing from you later when you have time. I don't understand what's going on in the videos- are you saying these are lies and propaganda, or that something else is?
I'll ask questions just as soon as I can figure out enough to know what questions to ask, and I'm very happy and excited that I've found some people who can give me some answers and educate me on what is no doubt a very complicated situation. But a couple of questions for starters: what's the history? Are these fairly modern issues or do they have deeper roots? What was your opinion of the US and NATO involvement over there? And, by the way- are you over there?
I'll get out my maps and start looking for some books so I can follow what you say.
Serbia war path:
1# Slovenia - small skirmish for 2 weeks, army moved to Croatia
2# Croatia – few years and dozen of genocides
3# Bosnia and Herzegovina – few years and many genocides ( city of Srebrenica named by Euro countries the largest genocide from WW2)
4# Kosovo – less than a year but also few genocides
Originally posted by odyseusz
In fact Serbia tried to keep integrity of the whole country but as the war progressed all sides made everything in more barbaric way. International law was broken by all sides but as the war ended they putt Serbia face of pure evil and isolate them and Croatia is now popular tourist destination and nice country almost as they never take part in this me$$.
Of course this was not war of two sides, it was much more complicated but I show you only extreme example. The same anti-Serbian propaganda was used to take their Kosovo which in fact is historic heart state of their nation. After that majority of Serbs were thrown away by Albanian people. To compare this situation to US reality is like cut off Boston and surrounding from US and told Americans that they have to move out.
This is only sample of history of few countries. What I wrote can't give overall view about central Europe and Balkans but it is a piece of information. In fact history of that region is much more complicated than history of western Europe with few large countries. Here we have such many nations which historically mixed with each other, they were changing borders so many times, fights with so many influence, accommodate so many cultures that you could not be sure fore anything except that the history is mostly written by liars.edit on 8-6-2011 by odyseusz because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by Kretenoid
reply to post by seaside sky
But the shear stupidity we can encounter when speaking with young people from USA is unbelievable.
For the end a killer question was posed to me by an American when I was working in the states. We where sitting outside taking a smoke he looked at the sky and asked me, do you have stars in Croatia. I almost ate my cigarette from LOL-ing.
edit on 8-6-2011 by Kretenoid because: (no reason given)
I would advice you to read the report called Milosevic vs. Yugoslavia released by the serbian branch of International Helsinky Federation for human rights. In this lenghty report you will find some interesting facts about Yugoslavia and its army. You will also find about constituional twist performed in the year before the war by the president of Presidency of Jugoslavia . B: Jović, along with Milosevic that was not at all legitimate, They have changed the part of the constitution related to the rulership of Army in the way that was unconstitutional itself. The army of Yugoslavia was by all means ment to be ruled regionaly, and was not centralized until Jovic has changed that particular paragraphs. The only thing which puzzles me the most is - why other members of the Presidency didn't object, or rightfuly press charges, if necessary, in order to prevent falsifying the Constitution.
Originally posted by Stefanbrzi
ARMY MOVED TO CROATIA....? You are saying that Serbs started this war? If so, you are talking bs then. Slovenians and you wanted your own country, so you started killing soldiers of YUGOSLAV army. It was not Serbia that declared independence from Yu.
Originally posted by Kretenoid
reply to post by odyseusz
Hi,
with all due respect but what you have posted is pure rubbish.
First of all, just to state, all countries have broken war rules when the war was in full motion. This is valid also for USA which used depleted uranium ammunition.
Originally posted by Stefanbrzi
Originally posted by Kretenoid
Originally posted by seaside sky
reply to post by Kretenoid
Hi Stefan,
I see this is going to be a nice discussion, hope other people jump in from this region and ad some thoughts especially facts since you have made arguments which are just funny!
ARMY MOVED TO CROATIA....? You are saying that Serbs started this war? If so, you are talking bs then. Slovenians and you wanted your own country, so you started killing soldiers of YUGOSLAV army. It was not Serbia that declared independence from Yu.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
@Stefan
What is wrong with wanting our independence from a regime which was a communist regime? Why is it your Serbian problem that we wanted to be independent from an aggressive communist regime with Serbian and Belgrade the dominating nation.
Yes, I say that Serbian started the war! As agreed by Serbian and Croatian historians, Croatia is inside its legal borders from past. Serbian people inside our territory blocked 1/3 of the country by organizing armed militias who took over some parts of Croatian territory 1 year before we even officially asked for independence.
Also, we where right away recognized as a independent country from most of the international auditorium. Therefore, I condone all aggressive militias who took over territories inside our country.
Serbian uprisings in Croatia began in August 1990 by blocking roads leading from the Dalmatian coast towards the inland almost a year before Croatian leadership made any move towards independence. These uprisings were more or less discretely backed up by the Serbian dominated federal army (JNA). The Serbs proclaimed the emergence of Serbian Autonomous Areas (known later as Republic of Serb Krajina) in Croatia
Yes it took three months for the army to move from Slovenia. Indeed they moved while Serbian militias in mostly Serbian populated parts of the Croatian territory took over our teritory, Croatian teritory. It doesn't give them the right. It's like if china town in USA would arm themselves and take over the control of the parts where they are the majority of population. You see, we already new when it started in Slovenia that we are going to be attacked by the Yugoslavian army. From the begging until the end of wars in this region Yugoslavian army fought for Serbia, that is a fact. A reasonable conclusion would be that Serbia controlled the only army in this region which was by the way among top three in Europe. Therefore, Croatia had only police at the time as an armed defense system. Naturally, we started arming our selves because obviously we did not had to contact "Baba Vanga" or look into a crystal bowl to know you are going to attack us.
There was a suspected incident of a war crime, as the Austrian ORF TV station showed footage of three Yugoslav Army soldiers surrendering to the Territorial defense, before gunfire was heard and the troops were seen falling down. However, none were killed in the incident. There were however numerous cases of destruction of civilian property and civilian life by the Yugoslav Peoples Army — houses, a church, civilian airport was bombarded and civilian hangar and airliners inside it, truck drivers on the road Ljubljana — Zagreb and Austrian journalists on Ljubljana Airport were killed. Ceasefire was agreed upon. According to the Brioni Agreement, recognized by representatives of all republics, the international community pressured Slovenia and Croatia to place a three-month moratorium on their independence.
During these three months, the Yugoslav Army completed its pull-out from Slovenia, but in Croatia,
en.wikipedia.org...
--------------------------------------------------------------
2# DOZEN OF GENOCIDES? Any proof? I would say that only genocide in Croatia was done by your people, against Serbs, in 1995, operation Oluja, remember that...??? No?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
@Stefan
Again, you seem to ignore facts. So let's check this video.
www.youtube.com...
Prologue: A Serbian president comes to Vukovar in Croatia for the first time after the massacre of 250 people (most of them from the town hospital) in 18 years during the annual grief ceremony and publicly apologizes in the name of Serbian people for the war atrocities. Also to add, I am not counting thousands of dead and injured during a attack of Serbian militias and Yugoslavian army (renamed into Serbian army, funny again, Serbian army) on a Croatian city named Vukovar till it was turned to dust.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3# "many genocides". Look who is talking about genocides. Not even your people is responsible for many genocides in WW2, just one, JASENOVAC (360,000 dead, mostly Serbs).I agree about Srebrenica, but there were no other genocides, and the numbers (if they are true at all...) are ridiculously small compared to Jasenovac.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
@Stefan
That is an entirely another issue but you should not use it to excuse Serbian genocides.
The majority of dead where Serbians and Jews since the Ustaša fascist (Croatian nationality) worked with Nazis. However, Partisans who where considered at the time the largest resistance to the Nazi WW2 in Europe have been assembled by both, Croatian and Serbians.
Serbians had also their fascist militia named Chetniks, you conveniently forgot to mention that.
The medal has two sides. We fought both sides. I hope that you have read my posts earlier and could recognize that I despise all wars especially genocides(children, women, men....)! I am not proud of it nor should anyone with a half brain. However, this was when probably both of us where not even an embryo.
Wov, you take the numbers of Srebrenica under suspicion when an excavation of bodies has been made from the mass grave. Today those numbers are accepted by the Hague court! Multiple foreign independent groups where present when documenting the excavation as official one.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4# "Kosovo – less than a year but also few genocides" NO PROOFS AT ALL. Just lies.
@Stefan
Kosovo territory which was an autonomy inside Yugoslavia with a 80% of their own population inside their recognized borders from former Yugoslavia had also right to self governance. All your arguments fall in the water because you cannot comprehend that territories of all Yugoslavia countries have been accepted since the inception of Yugoslavia in the parliament of Yugoslavia, also by Serbian side. Therefore, who gives you the Serbians the right to oppress wishes from other countries around you to self govern them. Countries with their own territories which are different from yours by religion, culture, language, ancestors!
And yes, genocide war purported, again multiple international sources. Either you are pretending dumb or you are listening only extremist propaganda. Obviously both due to your videos which can disputed with so many arguments that one would not know where to start.
-----------------------------------------------
"how come is Serbia being attacked according to your vids when not one foot of any army did not went into Serbia. Serbia was present in all those countries committing multiple genocides but not one foreign soldier has went to Serbia."
I didnt say that my country was attacked, I said OUR ex country (obviously you Croats never considered itas your country) was falling apart.
--------------------------------------------------------------
@Stefan
We did not want that country!
Of course we did not consider it our country when we wanted democracy not a communist regime centralized in Serbia. Again a logical fallacy. Who are you to force a regime on a another nation different by religion, culture and ancestors with our own territory.
How can you say your country, when it does not exist. Which country had a similar problem, let me enlighten you SSSR! What have they done, separated peacefully. We could have done the same thing, especially because the trends show that we will both be in the EU.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"not one foreign soldier has went to Serbia"
FOREIGN soldier. It was a FKING civil war, there were no FOREIGN soldiers!
---------------------------------
@Stefan
Serbian army former Yugoslavian army attacking, in my modest opinion I consider it a hostile foreign army which has lead 4 wars in less then 10 years!
How can it be a civil war whit a military involved! There are tons of videos which support that.
Ok, let's be rational now: How many Serbian refugees from Croatia? 230000. Thousands dead.
How many Croatian refugees from Serbia? Maybe 10. Dead? 0 (ZERO).
That tells a lot who was the agressor.
What have you expected when according to you "civil war" lead by Serbs has resulted with bombing of minimally 10 major Croatian cities with MIG's, Tanks and other artilieries on civilian targets.
Did you expect the Croatian people will say ok, let's bomb us but we will not fight against you.
Of course you where "escorted out of our territory.
And, again please explain how come do I have many Serbs friends who where born here in Croatia, never went to war stayed hear and continued to live and will in the future.
I am not sure where are you pulling up all of those numbers but until you support them with some sources, I am not going to address them due to Srebrenica numbers!
Please provide a link!
"Propaganda created the war, that is why I cannot comprehend that people are still divided by politics." I agree.
edit on 8-6-2011 by Kretenoid because: (no reason given)