It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by dude69
reply to post by SuperiorEd
I'll have to agree with Iknowstuff...the Egyptians were the first to prosper in mathematics and science.edit on 24-4-2011 by dude69 because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by IkNOwSTuff
reply to post by SuperiorEd
Yes we have already established you have lots of modern examples but my question was what did they offer prior to that? I can name thousands of modern discoveries not made but Jews. can you name more than a handfull of Jewish contributors to science, philosophy, art etc prior to the 19th century
How is mentioning something attributed to god got anything to do with Jewish discoveries?????
And if you look at earlier ancient texts they are alot more intriguing and scientific than the Talmud or Torah which were both based on Sumerian writings anyway.
Ive heard of light being wave and particle but the bible saying "This is the wave that carries the light" I dont see any correlation as he was talking about Jesus not physics.
I checked out the link RE hexagrams and gotta be honest dude it seemed like nonsense to me, thats not to say that it is just that I didnt understand it. It would be great if you could perhaps summarize for me what it all means.
So anyway.. we got the last hundred years, yeah they done some good stuff and for the sake of argument Ill give ya the beggining of time nonsense but what about the intervening 3500 years or however long its been since the bible says the world was created? can you give me a few examples of Jewish Scientific superiority in that time period?
edit on 24-4-2011 by IkNOwSTuff because: (no reason given)
Yes we have already established you have lots of modern examples but my question was what did they offer prior to that? I can name thousands of modern discoveries not made but Jews. can you name more than a handfull of Jewish contributors to science, philosophy, art etc prior to the 19th century
Yes we have already established you have lots of modern examples but my question was what did they offer prior to that? I can name thousands of modern discoveries not made but Jews. can you name more than a handfull of Jewish contributors to science, philosophy, art etc prior to the 19th century
Originally posted by IkNOwSTuff
reply to post by SuperiorEd
OK then
I give up!!!
Ur either a complete nutjob or so far ahead of me intellectually Im not even the same species (Im leaning towards the nutjob side)
You didnt answer my question so in my book it means you dont have an answer or more likely the answer doesnt promote whatever religious drivel it is your pushing.
It was fun dude but trying to get a straight answer or anything coherent out of you or even just to get you to stay on topic is doing my head in.
Ill look through your posts later as you seem to have some info that I would find very interesting but for now.....
Im outty
Originally posted by IkNOwSTuff
reply to post by SuperiorEd
I checked out the link RE hexagrams and gotta be honest dude it seemed like nonsense to me, thats not to say that it is just that I didnt understand it. It would be great if you could perhaps summarize for me what it all means.
edit on 24-4-2011 by IkNOwSTuff because: (no reason given)
Even Wikipedia makes the connection
Just do the research and we won't be so far apart intellectually. Just do a Google search for 'scientists Jewish.
Originally posted by SuperiorEd
Of course there are others who are not Jewish. But an abnormal amount of major discoveries have come from the Jewish people. The statistics back me up. Look at these lists. Take their discoveries away and we would not be where we are. This is true for anyone who has made a discovery, but the Jewish people are above the average. Way above. LINK LINK
Here is a list for the area of Chemistry alone LINK.
Adolph von Baeyer #,1 (1905)
Henri Moissan #,2 (1906)
Otto Wallach # (1910)
Richard Willstätter # (1915)
Fritz Haber # (1918)
George de Hevesy # (1943)
Melvin Calvin # (1961)
Max Perutz # (1962)
Christian Anfinsen 3 (1972)
William Stein # (1972)
Ilya Prigogine 4 (1977)
Herbert Brown # (1979)
Paul Berg # (1980)
Walter Gilbert # (1980)
Roald Hoffmann # (1981)
Sir Aaron Klug # (1982)
Herbert Hauptman 5 (1985)
Jerome Karle 6 (1985)
John Polanyi 7 (1986)
Sidney Altman # (1989)
Rudolph Marcus # (1992)
George Olah 8 (1994)
Sir Harold Kroto 9 (1996)
Walter Kohn 10 (1998)
Alan Heeger 11 (2000)
Aaron Ciechanover 12 (2004)
Avram Hershko 13 (2004)
Irwin Rose 14 (2004)
Roger Kornberg 15 (2006)
Martin Chalfie 16 (2008)
Ada Yonath 17 (2009)
Others 18
And then there is THIS.
reply to post by Bspiracy
edit on 24-4-2011 by SuperiorEd because: (no reason given)edit on 24-4-2011 by SuperiorEd because: (no reason given)edit on 24-4-2011 by SuperiorEd because: (no reason given)
"P.s This is why I joined ATS, for the mental stimulation, to be challenged and to learn new things. I really appreciate your time dude."
Originally posted by IkNOwSTuff
reply to post by SuperiorEd
A couple things first
Even Wikipedia makes the connection
Considering wikipedia is updated by the public and no real scientific or peer review process is used I dont know that I would be using it to champion my cause or even refering to it as a reliable source. Even on Wiki it doesnt say he was Jewish it actually says moses MAY have gotten knowledge from him. It actually clearly states he was thought to be Egyptian and there is even doubt he was a real person. (Im getting that from the article you directed me to)
Just do the research and we won't be so far apart intellectually. Just do a Google search for 'scientists Jewish.
I did the search and I actually came to the opposite conclusion that you did. In a history that spans 6000+ yrs they according to the list I found have only managed to produce 433 names of note and this list included philosophers!!! 433 over 6000 yrs, not that impressive or at least not in anyway remarkable.
African Americans in only 200 yrs have 37 SCIENTISTS worthy of note, no padding out the numbers with philosophers necessary to make em look good. That figure according to your logic makes them twice as loved by god or twice as superior or whatever it is you were saying jews were.
Theres alot of info to digest in your posts and videos so Ill save it till tomorrow, I apologise for the name calling but I got frustrated when I couldnt get a simple answer to a simple question. Now you have explained that its difficult to give a simple answer Ill try and sort through it and Ill get back to you.
Thanks for all the research and links I really appreciate it
P.s This is why I joined ATS, for the mental stimulation, to be challenged and to learn new things. I really appreciate your time dude
Originally posted by IkNOwSTuff
reply to post by SuperiorEd
Just an idea
Before I found this thread I asked if anyone out there wanted to have a go in the debate forum.
Since this is a topic were both interested in would you be keen to battle it out there?
I dont think either of us is gonna change the other persons mind but it could be fun and we can see what other people think of the ideas we put forward.
whacha say?
Originally posted by RicoMarston
Originally posted by SuperiorEd
Roger Kornberg 15 (2006)
Martin Chalfie 16 (2008)
Ada Yonath 17 (2009)
Others 18
And then there is THIS.
reply to post by Bspiracy
edit on 24-4-2011 by SuperiorEd because: (no reason given)edit on 24-4-2011 by SuperiorEd because: (no reason given)edit on 24-4-2011 by SuperiorEd because: (no reason given)
which means nothing without the list of christian chemists, muslim chemists, etc etc.
it's called compare and contrast.
So...what Descartes was saying was that we can only define reality within our human limitations of reality, thus not really describing reality?...makes sense.
Originally posted by ABNARTY
reply to post by SuperiorEd
Interesting source from the bible on a thread talking about Zion and Zionism: Luke. The New Testament and one of the Gospels to boot. I will assume you were talking about something else other than the tenants of the Old Testament.