It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Benevolent Heretic
Originally posted by mr-lizard
The sad thing is. If you started making threads about how you love women and bragging about your sexual ideals, your thread would probably be deleted.
Are you serious?
www.abovetopsecret.com...
There are many heterosexual threads on ATS/BTS. You don't think anything about hearing someone mention their husband or their wife, but that's advertising their sexuality. If heterosexuals don't have to "keep it to themselves", why should gay people?
Originally posted by LordBucket
Experiencing pride for a state of being is probably preferable to experiencing shame for it, but if homosexuals could do what they do, simply because they choose to...without any pride or shame at all...that would probably be both healthier and more comfortable for them.
For example, I like to ski. It's not something I'm "proud" of.
If heterosexuals don't have to "keep it to
themselves", why should gay people?
Originally posted by mr-lizard
And if Gay people are allowed to be dismissive of religious folk or get annoyed at straight people, then why not the other way round?
Oh and those links you posted are in the 'off-topic' section.
Originally posted by LordBucket
Simply as a matter of courtesy. If one smoker is in a room with a dozen other people who dislike the smell of smoke, is it more reasonable for them to ask that he smoke outside, or for him to insist that they accept him smoking in the room with them?
A lot of people are uncomfortable with homosexuality. I assert that it is reasonable for heterosexuals to request homosexuals to keep their private lives private, just like it's reasonable for non-smokers to ask smokers to smoke outside.
What if you hadn't been able to ski for the first 25 years of your life, but
you persevered and worked hard and fought and struggled until one day, you were
able to ski! Might you be a little bit proud?
What I am IS NOT a choice!!! I WAS BORN THIS WAY!!!
I assure you, they didn't feel shame because of their own judgments of homosexuality.
That came from the outside world.
Originally posted by LordBucket
But if I was, that pride would be the result of overcoming the unhealthy condition that was preventing me from being able to ski. It would not be pride for having been unable to ski. If a homsosexual claims to be proud for having overcome their fear of self expression, that seems reasonable to me. But that's not quite the same as expressing pride for being gay.
These are not the words of someone acting on a simple preference and having a healthy result from it. These are not the words of someone motivated by desire to "love who they choose." These are the words of someone motivated by shame, guilt, self-pity, self-loathing, and a whole host of nasty, unhealthy emotions.
But that pride is coming from the rubber-band effect of desperately trying to escape from a huge pile of emotional nastiness.
But I don't think the cry of "it's not my fault I was born this way" or "it's not my fault, the angst came from the outside world" ...I don't think either of these are likely to improve conditions for anyone.
I think gays on the whole will benefit far more from self acceptance, than they will from getting anyone else to accept them.
Someone talking about their sexuality, whether straight or gay,
doesn't emit poisonous toxins into the air for others to breathe!
Some people are uncomfortable with talk of aliens. Should
we request that people don't talk about that anymore?
It is reasonable to request it. Request away.
But you can't always get what you want.
Originally posted by LordBucket
Talking about diarrhea also doesn't emit poisonous toxins, but if you do that at a dinner party sooner or later someone is going to tell you shut up because they don't want to hear about it.
And if two guys decide to make out in a public park, knowingly causing discomfort to other park-goers, they should not be surprised if someone shouts deragatory expletives at them that might make them uncomfortable.
If you knowingly do things that annoy people...don't be surprised if they don't put up with it.
... it seems like a lot of people want to put homosexuality on some kind of pedestal and pretend that it's magically exempt from the same simple courtesies we would extend on any other topic.
Originally posted by jjkenobi
Not condoning or approving homosexual behavior does not make one a homophobe.