It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by TinkererJim
reply to post by KoraX
The video is most likely fabricated, but HoaxKiller1's arguments are just cursive and unconvincing.
Try shooting a foreground/background comparable to OP's video with foreground object ~20ft and background ~few miles. I think when foreground object is far enough, the optical shift will be reduced to near zero.
Not your ordinary hoax is it...
Originally posted by Paradigm2012
reply to post by mtnshredder
So far nobody has been able to find any errors in the video.
Are we now calling this one real?
Originally posted by Unknown Soldier
A Cruel Hoaxedit on 1-2-2011 by Unknown Soldier because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by triklops
Has this third angle already been posted ?? ( No, not the one with the still image)
www.youtube.com...
Sorry, if already been posted..went through the last couple of pages and did not find it.
Originally posted by Unknown Soldier
Ummm you are incorrect, several people have pointed out that this is a hoax. You may not have had the time to go back through the pages but it has been posted several times. Come on people stop being lazy and do the footwork yourself and you will find this is more then fishy.
Originally posted by WhizPhiz
Originally posted by triklops
Has this third angle already been posted ?? ( No, not the one with the still image)
www.youtube.com...
Sorry, if already been posted..went through the last couple of pages and did not find it.
Son of a gun! Has anyone seen this yet?
It's a 4th freaking video! A bit like the third, but this time it isn't a still background, there are cars moving and stuff...and it has the flash...let me embed this for you also:
edit on 1-2-2011 by WhizPhiz because: small correction
Originally posted by wingsfan
ok, this is strange now. that video looks good, but it seems like a new one shows up as soon as the last gets debunked.
Originally posted by KoraX
Originally posted by Unknown Soldier
A Cruel Hoaxedit on 1-2-2011 by Unknown Soldier because: (no reason given)
Due to the religious connotation, I would agree with you whole heartedly, its not just trying to fool the ufologists, its trying to trick the faithful as well.
Truly sad
Originally posted by Crayfish
Originally posted by mtnshredder
Is it possible for one of you guys or gals that feel the footage is real, to answer and explain these questions that no one seems to want to address and keeps going unanswered?
This is where you are getting us wrong. Just because we're not satisfied with the evidence of hoaxing provided so far, it doesn't mean we think it is real. There are one or two people who have stated they believe it is real and if your post is only addressing those people then I apologise.
There are a greater number on the side sceptical of the debunkers who simply do not like to see something absolutely discarded as a hoax when there has been no conclusive proof. The questions raised in your post are all very valid but they are not what we are looking for. We've been looking for the inevitable error that a hoaxer will have made. So far the most compelling candidate for such an error is the mismatch between the screen of the cellphone and the image it was supposedly recording. That's still not quite proof as we don't know for sure that there isn't some mode on that phone that captures video using a non standard user interface.
What has got some people irritated is the keenness of certain people to discard this as a hoax based upon circumstantial evidence. They say "case closed", we say "probably fake but case still open at the moment".
Originally posted by triklops
Has this third angle already been posted ?? ( No, not the one with the still image)
www.youtube.com...
Sorry, if already been posted..went through the last couple of pages and did not find it.
edit on 1-2-2011 by triklops because: attached still image of the "flash"
Originally posted by Unknown Soldier
The person filming anticipates that is about to shoot up just like the original. something that shoots up that fast would leave you to react a bit slower. Thus he anticipated that it was about to "shoot up" yes looks can be deceiving.
Originally posted by Unknown Soldier
Originally posted by Paradigm2012
reply to post by mtnshredder
So far nobody has been able to find any errors in the video.
Are we now calling this one real?
Ummm you are incorrect, several people have pointed out that this is a hoax. You may not have had the time to go back through the pages but it has been posted several times. Come on people stop being lazy and do the footwork yourself and you will find this is more then fishy. You will find the original video has ties with ANW/--/allhoaxweb Micheal Cohen. The people screaming "this is real" are ignoring all the key factors here. All the evidence points to hoax as provided in this thread.
Listen, debunkers skeptics call em what you want they have won thus far. Even believers debunked and are yelling bs like myself, im a tin foil hat believer myself yes. And NO nobody knows if aliens are here and what "it" is. We think they are but we do not know in any certainty. Something has been interacting with our civilization, something much more advanced but nobody knows what it is. But something like this comes along it bridges your believer types with your religious types together and they tend to ignore the facts in favor of their extreme beliefs. That is why this hoax has been so effective. Yeah it looks really "cool" and it may even be real to you. But what we have been seeing so far is overwhelming, overwhelming instances of a HOAX.
Now more hoaxers are being inspired to follow suit. These people want you to believe in ET, they want to impose their new age GFOL type of beliefs on the rest of us. They think hoaxing is for the greater good and that a lie wont hurt anything. So what makes them different then religious radicals? They have become one and the same and are the opposite of what UFOLOGY is about. They are not concerned with the truth they are only interested in you joining the gospel they speak. The people behind this are genius in a sense that they know how people will react to this given the holy site. If this happened in Idaho in some potato field it would have faded in to obscurity by now.
It is ANW viral spam people , just go there and realize all the CGI footage they have has the same back story.
A Cruel Hoaxedit on 1-2-2011 by Unknown Soldier because: (no reason given)