It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Human_Alien
So very true OP.
Here's a 'quicky' free site to tell you your rising, moon etc signs. You have to know your hour of birth and of course, location.
Have fun.
alabe.com...
Originally posted by madnessinmysoul
reply to post by SeaWind
What you should know:
The celestial bodies are so far away from us that we cannot rationally conceive of the notion in one step. The only bodies that have any real effect on us are the sun (obvious for anyone who understand photosynthesis and sunburns), the moon (tides), and Jupiter (scoops up some asteroids here and there, it's how it has so many moons). The rest are just nice to look at.
I mean, seriously, what's the means by which a star, a constellation, or anything else in the night sky can change something about someone's life?
And how the hell is any of this philosophical?
Edit: One last thing, Ptolemy? Seriously? You're going to take the word of the guy who came up with the model of the universe in which our planet was at the center on matters of astronomy? This is why I can't even get close to respecting this sort of stuff, you're not just working from outdated information, you're working from information that basically everyone knows is outdated.edit on 15/1/11 by madnessinmysoul because: One last thing
Originally posted by subject x
Here's my issue with astrology. How do you know when to stop?
If the position of planets and such has any impact on your life, which ones? All of them? Maybe seven of them? Just those in our solar system? Where do you stop, and why?
It seems to me that if we are affected by heavenly bodies, we must be affected by all of them. I seriously doubt that we have charted everything of size in space, so how could you even begin to think you can get any kind of accurate prediction when you don't have all the variables.
I also happen to know a fella who was born within an hour of me, same day, same year, same hospital.
Yet we could not be more different.
Were his attributes influenced by a different universe? If date, time, location of birth, and planetary position are what determines what kind of person we are, how could he be so different?
To me, it's a bunch of made-up hooey designed to part a fool from his/her money.
But if it makes you happy, then have a day!
Originally posted by SeaWind
It most definitely is related to human psychology, philosophy & metaphysics. Too bad Carl Jung and Dane Rudhyar (Jungian psychologist) aren't here to argue with you.
And because an astronomer of almost 2,000 years ago believed Earth was the center of the universe, you disparage on ALL of his work. So you don't believe ANY astronomer before Copernicus has ANY value.
I do not offer any theory as to WHY Astrology works, I KNOW it works.
Too bad Sir Isaac Newton isn't here:
"Sir, I have studied it, you have not" -Isaac Newton, Astrologer, said in defense of astrology to disbeliever in Halley (comet discoverer).
archure.net...
Originally posted by SeaWind
Subject X, you were NOT born at the same time as this other person. An hour can make a real difference, especially in the divisional charts. The planets (& asteroids) used are limited to our solar system. The bodies closest to Earth bear the most powerful influence. Why Astrology works it basically an unknown.
BTW, I do NOT charge money for my charts. I'm a research astrologer.
Originally posted by madnessinmysoul
reply to post by SeaWind
It's actually in my profile on ATS. My birth date is the 23rd December 1988, I was born at Latitude: 35° 53' 41 N, Longitude: 14° 29' 42 E. The charts are silly and more than suspiciously vague, so I doubt you'll gain anything of any value.
Originally posted by madnessinmysoul
reply to post by SeaWind
It's actually in my profile on ATS. My birth date is the 23rd December 1988, I was born at Latitude: 35° 53' 41 N, Longitude: 14° 29' 42 E. The charts are silly and more than suspiciously vague, so I doubt you'll gain anything of any value.
Originally posted by subject x
Originally posted by SeaWind
Subject X, you were NOT born at the same time as this other person. An hour can make a real difference, especially in the divisional charts. The planets (& asteroids) used are limited to our solar system. The bodies closest to Earth bear the most powerful influence. Why Astrology works it basically an unknown.
Why is it limited to our own solar system? Maybe further objects have less influence singly, but they must have an influence (there are no borders in space), and as the bodies outside our system vastly outnumber those within, they must add up to a mighty influence, I would imagine. To arbitrarily limit it to just our system sounds like "make it up as you go along". And if why/how it works is unknown, how can you know what does and does not influence things?
Not trying to be a douche here, just trying, again, to understand why anyone would put their belief in such an arbitrary system.
BTW, I do NOT charge money for my charts. I'm a research astrologer.
That's a good thing, I guess. Have you spent any money for other people's information on making charts?
Originally posted by Human_Alien
So very true OP.
Here's a 'quicky' free site to tell you your rising, moon etc signs. You have to know your hour of birth and of course, location.
Have fun.
alabe.com...