It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by impressme
reply to post by DrEugeneFixer
You know as well as most people know in signing A&E petition that most of these experts found in the WTC dust samples.
That is the lie you have been repeating over and over, in an attempted appeal to authority. You have not presented a shred of evidence that the petition signers support Steven E. Jones, or the Thermite theory or that the signers are knowledgeable in the relevant disciplines to evaluate the paper. If neither of these is the case, then you should revise the OP.
So please present some actual evidence that the petition signers "have accepted Jones peered reviewed paper as evidence of explosive particles".
Originally posted by impressme
You have called me a liar not just once, but twice (ATS T&C no name calling accepted!)
Originally posted by impressme
Prove I have lied?
Originally posted by impressme
I appeal to what authority?
Originally posted by impressme
Here let’s twist your question around a bit, can you prove that the signers of the petition are not knowledgeable of Jones peer reviewed accepted science? ......
Please present some actual evidence that the petition signers "have “NOT ACCEPTED” Jones peered reviewed paper as evidence of explosive particles?
Do you have evidence that all these people who signed A&E petition do not accept Jones Science? No you don’t!
Originally posted by impressme
As I don’t have any proof that all the signers accepted Jones peer reviewed science,
Originally posted by impressme
You have a nice day.
First, it's impossible to prove a negative, and second, I have no access to the signers mental states, third, I never made that claim, so no, I can't prove that the signers all reject Jones' 'science'.
Originally posted by impressme
As I don’t have any proof that all the signers accepted Jones peer reviewed science,
That's all I was trying to point out. Thank you.
was literally in the first paragraph. Now thanks to my efforts you've admitted that you don't have evidence that it is true. We are making progress.
1,398 “Valid” signers put their name on a list in support of Steven Jones scientific Journal and support it 100%? These are scientists, Architects, Engineers, and professionals.
Your original post gave priority to a false claim.
Originally posted by impressme
reply to post by DrEugeneFixer
Your original post gave priority to a false claim.
There was no false claim,