It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Mr_skepticc
The majority of you believers seem so very upset over the results. I read that since the show does put peoples reputation on the line they have one of the best polygraph teams working for them. Travis thought they pulled it off once, why not now. So he decided to gamble on it, because he needed money of course. How do you think he would fail the most important question given to him, and fail! I will tell you why, short, sweet, and simple Hes A Liar!
Originally posted by Mr_skepticc
The majority of you believers seem so very upset over the results. I read that since the show does put peoples reputation on the line they have one of the best polygraph teams working for them. Travis thought they pulled it off once, why not now. So he decided to gamble on it, because he needed money of course. How do you think he would fail the most important question given to him, and fail! I will tell you why, short, sweet, and simple Hes A Liar!
Originally posted by sputniksteve
I am not sure what I believe about Travis's story, but I will say that I do NOT think that this is conclusive proof that he was not abducted by aliens. Like the poster above me noted, how could he have answered all of the other questions truthfully but somehow this one was a lie?
Is it possible that something did happen that night, and he was "abducted" but not by aliens? This being the reason that he failed the last question? So possibly he consciously believes he was abducted by aliens but he subconsciously knows he was abducted by someone/something else? Or he consciously knows he was abducted by something/someone else but for some reason or another can't/won't admit they weren't "aliens"?
I don't really know.
Originally posted by Jobeycool
Funny how the looney skpetics complained about inaccuries about polygrpah test,but this one is suddenly accurate..The people seem like they have been through hell and made fun of over this stuff all thier life. I think his body langauge proves He is telling the truth.Because He is angry at the skeptics and debunkers who have laughed and made fun of this stuff.In His case I think this is the real deal.
Originally posted by Jdawg9909
This was an obvious hit piece against Travis Walton. One thing I don't like about television is that people see it on here, most will believe it is true, when in reality it is merely entertainment.
Also polygraphs are not 100% accurate and they will not hold up in most courts.
After completing the exam, McCarthy determined that Travis was lying. Clark quotes from McCarthy’s official report: "Based on his reaction on all charts, it is the opinion of this examiner that Walton, in concert with others, is attempting to perpetrate a UFO hoax, and that he has not been on any spacecraft". (Clark, 640) Later, McCarthy would assert that "sometimes Travis would hold his breath, in an effort to 'beat the machine."[2]
The Waltons, APRO and the National Enquirer then agreed to keep the results of this polygraph a secret, due in large part, they insisted, to doubts about McCarthy’s methods and objectivity. Eight months later, when word of this decision was made public, there would be more charges of deception and cover-up. Travis would later take and pass two additional polygraph exams, though the suppressed results of the first exam would shadow him and earn mention in nearly every discussion of the case to the present.
This proves precisely nothing. If lie-detectors worked, we wouldn't need juries in courts of law. We'd just hook teh accused up to a polygraph and ask him a bunch of questions. But we don't. Because polygraphs aren't reliable. So umm...yeah. Proves nothing.
Originally posted by Mr_skepticc
Part 1
Part 2 (The Lie)
As we learned from this video, not only has he been lying, but was always obsessed with ufos and non-sense!
And how did you come by this "truth"? Please enlighten us all as to the source of your information.
Originally posted by Thibotham
Everybody who has had an alien abduction is lying.
Sorry, but it's the truth.
They need something magical in their lives and hold on to the idea as long as they can.
Originally posted by Kandinsky
It strikes me as a bias when an interest in UFOs is cited as a character flaw or used to suggest mental weakness. CSICOP associates like James Oberg, Phil Klass, Michael Shermer and guys like Ian Ridpath and Dr Clark surely fall into the same category?.
Originally posted by aliengenes
they ripped him off on purpose.
if everything he had said up to that point was true
then why would the being abducted one be a lie?
if that being said, then every other thing he said for this game would had to have been a lie.