It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by jokei
reply to post by Saul of Tarsus
Ok, you're definitely missing my question, one last time - I don't know how to make this more simple for you, so the main part of the question is in bold...
When this is an ongoing debate here on ATS, why can you not contribute to an ongoing thread (of which there are many) instead of just whipping up yet another pointless X Vs Y thread that ultimately will not satisfy either party.
As an aside to this, I would like to note that there have been some decent posts from both sides of the argument and it's been good to see some that I disagree with being polite and intelligent, I cannot extend this to the OP whom I see as a boring troll.
Originally posted by Saul of Tarsus
reply to post by jokei
If I accused you falsely, please accept my apology, your referring me to the rules and yours being the last post on the closed thread was my clue. Assuming that I have only read one book during all my incarnations on this planet is your prerogative. I offer however that wisdom is not found in books but in awareness. Many Blessings
Well, you've not been here that long, you may want to note that on the whole the moderators are very active and alert. It seems symptomatic of your attitude that you point the finger without thinking through. If I had reported you, I would clearly state so. I've had many of my own threads moved or even removed (never closed though (shrug)), I personally don't feel a need to point fingers nor sulk about it - maybe if you were more a man of christ you would have turned the other cheek?
I was not assuming you had only read one book, but from your glib interpretation of my comment it might be fair - the comment actually meant that you were sinking your belief into one book - that let's face it has a questionable history (which edition are you choosing etc) as opposed to many books (Science, philosophy, sociology etc) that are very well researched and sourced. I was not in any way assuming your whole scope of reading material and can only assume you've purposely misinterpreted my statement to further your (shoddy) rhetoric.
Originally posted by Saul of Tarsus
OK, here goes. And the answer is... What better way to understand what goes on in a person's mind than to criticize what they label themselves as and hear what they have to say about it.
Originally posted by Saul of Tarsus
Atheism is a cop-out. Non-belief in GOD is non-belief in self.
GOD is not a dead white male in the sky. G (generate) O (organize) D (deliver) are attributes of the one reality of which we are part, therefore attributes of ourselves.
Dualism (religion) and atheism are falsehoods. Truth is unity.
There is no separation between us and GOD, separation exists only in the mind.
Ah hah!, got your attention didn’t I? Now, for those who have seen this same thread in another category and were thinking of commenting, there is a good reason why this thread appears twice.
The Brahmin caste in India wears two threads over the shoulder symbolic of the possibility of a second birth.
The purpose of the examples quoted above is to stir up the quantum soup. If I have succeeded in doing so, anybody to whom this applies will be feeling a bit of discomfort, and that is good!
Although evolution is natural, dying and being reborn does not take place without a measure of discomfort.
Both religion and atheism can be likened to blockages in the nozzle of the airbrush we are painting our external reality with. Religion is like a partial blockage and atheism a total blockage.
So, if you are still generating, organizing and delivering you cannot be a true atheist, perhaps more of an agnostic (confused).
That’s OK, it is perfectly understandable. On at least two occasions during the present world age, this planet has suffered blockages in the essential flow of wisdom to humanity.
Perhaps this was part of the grand design all along.
Now that science has caught up with spirituality, the ancient wisdom that is starting to make sense of the all has miraculously become manifest.
Buddha was not a Buddhist and Christ was not a Christian.
For more than half a century a modern Buddha and a modern Christ have walked this planet, without anyone noticing (like thieves in the night). I will not do humanity the disservice of pointing them out to you and they would not appreciate it either. They have devoted their lives to bringing light into this world, and continue to do so with complete devotion, bless their souls. “Seek and ye shall find…”
The point is or should I say the points are the rest of us. Are we ready to clear our blockages? The question to keep asking yourself is “who am I?” When your answer finally brings the biggest grin imaginable to your face and in the next moment slips through your fingers as if it were never here, you have glimpsed it.
When you clear that, love and peace flows into this world through you unrestricted.
Originally posted by jokei
Originally posted by Saul of Tarsus
OK, here goes. And the answer is... What better way to understand what goes on in a person's mind than to criticize what they label themselves as and hear what they have to say about it.
Right, I understand that - but you're still not answering or avoiding the question of why start this at all when there are already a number of threads discussing this very topic?
For the most part, at least initially both sides were balanced, informative and polite, but it seems you've only served to encourage schism that is needless and (sorry to say) very boring when it's happened here to the Nth degree. This leads me to suspect you're either attempting to garner (meaningless) stars for your profile or you're just trolling for the fun of it - I'd like to think most of the members of ATS are above that.
Personally, I have no need for religion in my life, I'm content - as far as these troubled times allow, I always try to do the best I can and benefit people wherever possible... my whole take on any judgement I may receive is that I'll do ok - I can honestly say I've done more good than harm and actively tried to do good and avoid causing harm, but you know what, I actually think that applies to most of this community.
Again though, I think the thread has devolved into needless bickering that didn't need to occur (again).
If I do get judged at the gates, someone is going to get kicked in the nuts management has made some bad decisions. Example: Miley Cyrus.
Thanks for nosing through my profile, it's worth doing sometimes to size someone up.
Originally posted by Watcher-In-The-Shadows
I would argue that taking any absolute position *pro a higher power or con* in this particular debate is a cop-out and an excuse to stop looking and thinking and start wearing those blinders and reinforcing.
[edit on 12-7-2010 by Watcher-In-The-Shadows]
Originally posted by Watcher-In-The-Shadows
reply to post by K J Gunderson
*shrugs* If I knew the answer to that question I would not make the statement I did. The question of a higher power is a bigger question than that. Of course driven into trivialities by trivial people.
Your question was silly.
Originally posted by SaHasani1990
And this happens with pretty much every factory product in your life. You already ARE living a huge chunk of your life based solely on faith.
Originally posted by Saul of Tarsus
Atheism is a cop-out.
Originally posted by UmbraSumus
Originally posted by Saul of Tarsus
. For more than half a century a modern Buddha and a modern Christ have walked this planet, without anyone noticing (like thieves in the night). I will not do humanity the disservice of pointing them out to you and they would not appreciate it either.
At the substantial risk of blocking my nozzle even further , are you claiming to have knowledge of the whereabouts of " a modern Buddha and a modern Christ " ?