It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by SpacePunk
reply to post by pteridine
There's no illusion that the draft is not voluntary. Your comparing an apple with an orange.
Originally posted by george_gaz
So if somebody drops litter and I force them to pick it up ... is that slavery?
If you fail to see how this can be beneficial to society then you really need to have a hard think. Oh no wait ... you already have a solution don't you
It will be like a summer holiday or a brief three month camp. It is not slavery because slavery had no "end date".
Originally posted by pteridine
Originally posted by SpacePunk
reply to post by pteridine
There's no illusion that the draft is not voluntary. Your comparing an apple with an orange.
Fruity analogies aside, what if the 'national service' evolves into a kind of selective service law? Other countries actually require national service from their citizens.
Originally posted by RcknShdw
Didn't Lincoln once say, "...that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth."? You know, OF the people, BY the people, FOR the people?
It works both ways, people. I'm disgusted by half of the comments here in this thread. People complaining about not wanting to help others. IT'S CIVIL SERVICE! It's not shipping you out to Iran to go fight a war! It's making sure you go out for an hour out of the day and pick up all that trash you threw out of your Hummer. Oh, and did ANY of you, and I'm sure the vast majority of you are past college, read the damn bill? It's required ONLY during years of schooling, presumably for children in the public school system. I see no harm in distilling respect for our earth and fellow members of society. They HAVE to make things like this mandatory because without it people start lacking in their social responsibilities, and YES that IS a part of being American!
It's people like you that refuse to give people like me canned goods and toiletries to send to the tent cities out in California that are popping up at astronomical numbers. I've been going around for weeks asking for donations, and even churches have refused to help!
As for the guy that said 700,000 soldiers would be needed for Iran. You ever research the war in Iraq or did you just look up US numbers? You do realize we wouldn't need to put near that number, seeing as we DO have allies. Those allies have numbers as well.
I'm all for this, then maybe the children that have socially inept parents can grow up and be responsible. Stop complaining! Most of you aren't even affected by this, and if your children are, put them in private school/university where, yes, the governments fingers do not touch as easily. You still have an option!
Edited to add - If you don't contribute don't expect anything in return. It's been a base philosophy of our country since it's start. It's like those wannabe sovereign activists. Don't like our laws? Don't drive on our streets, don't put your kids in our school system, unless you follow the law.
Also, this isn't illegal as it doesn't infringe on anyone's rights. Well, maybe the college level, but you all do realize that you have NO rights until you turn 18/21/25? BY LAW? Ergo, the government has every right to enforce this in schools IT pays for!
[edit on 19-3-2009 by RcknShdw]
Originally posted by RcknShdw
Didn't Lincoln once say, "...that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth."? You know, OF the people, BY the people, FOR the people?
It works both ways, people. I'm disgusted by half of the comments here in this thread. People complaining about not wanting to help others. IT'S CIVIL SERVICE! It's not shipping you out to Iran to go fight a war! It's making sure you go out for an hour out of the day and pick up all that trash you threw out of your Hummer. Oh, and did ANY of you, and I'm sure the vast majority of you are past college, read the damn bill? It's required ONLY during years of schooling, presumably for children in the public school system. I see no harm in distilling respect for our earth and fellow members of society. They HAVE to make things like this mandatory because without it people start lacking in their social responsibilities, and YES that IS a part of being American!
It's people like you that refuse to give people like me canned goods and toiletries to send to the tent cities out in California that are popping up at astronomical numbers. I've been going around for weeks asking for donations, and even churches have refused to help!
As for the guy that said 700,000 soldiers would be needed for Iran. You ever research the war in Iraq or did you just look up US numbers? You do realize we wouldn't need to put near that number, seeing as we DO have allies. Those allies have numbers as well.
I'm all for this, then maybe the children that have socially inept parents can grow up and be responsible. Stop complaining! Most of you aren't even affected by this, and if your children are, put them in private school/university where, yes, the governments fingers do not touch as easily. You still have an option!
Edited to add - If you don't contribute don't expect anything in return. It's been a base philosophy of our country since it's start. It's like those wannabe sovereign activists. Don't like our laws? Don't drive on our streets, don't put your kids in our school system, unless you follow the law.
Also, this isn't illegal as it doesn't infringe on anyone's rights. Well, maybe the college level, but you all do realize that you have NO rights until you turn 18/21/25? BY LAW? Ergo, the government has every right to enforce this in schools IT pays for!
[edit on 19-3-2009 by RcknShdw]
DON'T TREAD ON ME! Does that mean anything to you!
I don't give a rats ass what YOU think is good for me!
Originally posted by RcknShdw
reply to post by ProtoplasmicTraveler
I think your story of waiving your rights at 14 is BS, unless you don't live in America. You have protection rights as a minor, but any constitutional rights are NOT given to you until you reach 18 years of age. If you waived your rights at 14, you should have been able to vote then too.
Also, was this a MILITARY reform school or an "alternative" education school? One is backed by the US government the other is a private institution and I think the revelation of this fact would help me determine if your story is valid or misinforming.
I did not inquire or ask for detailed moral values from you. So I'm going to skip it all because it paints a rather skewed image that has no importance in this discussion. I brought up the targeted group, CHILDREN in school, and how it affects them and I agree that it should be that way. You also are no longer in the educational system, so I don't see how you are getting upset over something that does not concern you? Unless you own a H3 and toss your Starbucks cups out of the car.
Oh, did you sign your Social Security card, court papers, employment papers, your tax forms? Sorry to say, but there is a bit of truth to the corporate entity conspiracy. So, you already have signed away your rights to live in our beautiful country
Originally posted by RcknShdw
reply to post by ProtoplasmicTraveler
If it was legal emancipation from your legal guardians, in your stated case your mother, it makes sense. Emancipation grants you constitutional rights. Remember, in this country, you are granted rights by being a US citizen, however you must fulfill certain obligations before the government accepts and acknowledges said rights legally.
However, if you didn't sign any of those forms, then you don't get to express any of those "privileges" granted to you. The US government grants you rights if you pledge the constitution, etc. Common law may not work for or against you, but you also have no legal right to use anything funded by, created by, ran by (etc) the government or any legal protection by the government. Dangerous waters, but I respect you if that's how you chose to live.
But stating as such, unless the parents waive their rights and grant emancipation to their children (which can cause a whole slew of problems in itself), said children have no rights until they reach 18 years of age (which is a maturity issue to understand the rights you have been given). I can see where you're coming from, but we live in America, we have to play by her rules.
H.Amdt. 49: Amendment to prohibit organizations from attempting to influence... Amendment to prohibit organizations from attempting to influence legislation; organize or engage in protests, petitions, boycotts, or strikes; and assist, promote, or deter union organizing.
SEC. 1511. OTHER DEPARTMENTS. Section 162 (42 U.S.C. 12622) is amended-- (1) in subsection (a)--
(A) in paragraph (1)--
(i) in subparagraph (A), by inserting ‘National’ before ‘Civilian Community Corps’; and
(ii) in subparagraph (B)
(i), by striking ‘the registry established by’ and all that follows through the semicolon and inserting ‘the registry established by section 1143a of title 10, United States Code;’;
(B) in paragraph (2)(A),
by striking ‘to be recommended for appointment’ and inserting ‘from which individuals may be selected for appointment by the Director’; and
(C) in paragraph (3), by inserting ‘National’ before ‘Civilian Community Corps’; and (2) by striking subsection (b).
Originally posted by shrike071
Perhaps we should all cut & paste that letter, and change it to suit our representatives and send it out.
Nicely done
Originally posted by RcknShdw
I think there's enough tension going on in this thread and "yelling" isn't going to get a good discussion but cause a flame war. Also, I think it's a little immature to respond to me with things like:
DON'T TREAD ON ME! Does that mean anything to you!
I don't give a rats ass what YOU think is good for me!
I really do hope you're talking about the government and not myself personally. But I think your response is irrational and a little over protective of your conceived rights (ones you think you have but actually don't). Did you ever put your foot down to stop any of this from happening?
ones you think you have but actually don't
Also, yes, I spent time in China with my older brother, over a year. It's actually not as bad as people paint it. Most of the bad stuff comes from major blunders that get televised (but our country's get hidden, think about that one) and from major CITIES. Rural China is a country in it's own right. But what Obama is doing is far from communism and socialism. If you think it IS one of those two, you obviously have never lived in a country of those two governments or learned about them.
And, yes, I have fought for my rights. I have shed blood over my rights. I think a lot of young people around my age have. You don't have to be in the military out across the ocean at war to shed blood for your rights.
Like I said to the other guy, if you don't agree with the laws, the doors that-a-way. You don't HAVE to live in America,
PS - I don't understand the use of CHICK! in your post, but if you were referring to me, I have to say you're obviously wrong
Edited to ad: Also, you're not paying for all of these bailouts, China and other purchasers of US Treasury Bonds are. As for taxes, the only demographic seeing a mass increase in taxes right now are smokers. I went from paying ~$4 a pack to over $6 in two weeks.