It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by RockHound757
Some highlights posted with respect to "Part 3".
Originally posted by CameronFox
chastized ? no sir... it's chastised
Conculsion ? no sir: conclusion
disintgrates ? no Captain: disintegrates
unfamilar ?no Bob: unfamiliar
alot ? no Robert: a lot
The rest of the laughable post by Bob.... yeah... laughable.
Originally posted by RockHound757
Awesome, loks like we have a persinal spell cheker for Balsamo's typo's.
(hint, thats not a typo. That is Mackey lack of attention to detail.)
And who is Bob? Again CF, are you accusing me of using a sock when you already
Originally posted by RockHound757
Part 3 has now been posted to google video. Here are some simple notes fatal to Mackey's presentation...
Ron plugs the mug. Priceless, especially when "troofers" are chastized[sic] when raising funds to keep operating. Conculsion[sic] - those who make excuses for the govt story will continue to attack the support structure of any group/organization attempting to raise funds while researching 9/11, but let Hardfire/Mackey slide on their shameless plugs. Read: Hypocrisy.
04:07 - Mackey, "Our model is very simple, we are going to leave out alot [sic] of very important things...", such as core columns in his illustration.
Mackey assumes upper floor mass remains constant, only to increase mass on the way down by adding floors - Conclusion = Logical Fallacy, deceptive.. the upper floors (as well as lower floors) were shedding mass outside floor surface area during collapse. Model is flawed.
Example: Upper floor Mass disintgrates/shed mass outwards as lower floors remain intact.
Mackey, "You should 'tweak' your model". Conclusion - Mackey has been caught many times "tweaking" his models towards his bias, not to mention flat out wrong.
19:55 - Blatant lie from Mackey. NIST does not feel "impact damage" contributed to WTC7 Collapse.
Mackey assumes highly flammable substances are allowed in skyscrapers.
Jet fuel is not an excuse as seen in the Fires were not "large" as claimed by Mackey.
Mackey completely omitted WTC 7 from entire series. Just as the 9/11 Commission.
End of show - Ron admits the show is about debate - not lecture. Claims "No one will step up for debate". Blatant lie.
Originally posted by samhouston1886
So funny this "NASA scientist" would say this is what 9/11 truth is all about because it really makes me question how well researched he is.
I would agree that this is simply a straw argument to make the movement look bad.
Too bad that that it’s not going to work.
Too bad that their arrogance was so great that it screwed up their plans.
(bolding by me)
posted by samhouston1886
I never met anyone who believed or endorsed NPT in my time with the 9/11 truth movement.
We knew than as now that CD was what happened.
As a matter a fact we all used to say that they were all disinfo.
So funny this "NASA scientist" would say this is what 9/11 truth is all about because it really makes me question how well researched he is.
I would agree that this is simply a straw argument to make the movement look bad.
Too bad that that it’s not going to work.
Too bad that their arrogance was so great that it screwed up their plans.
Originally posted by SPreston
Neither have I. NPT at the WTC is a 'theory' put out by disinformation specialists from the other side. NASA 'janitor' Mackey is just following through with the standard 'strawman argument' which he will beat down again and again and again unopposed with NOBODY on the other side of the debate. And CF will continue smirking and reposting the 'strawman argument' again and again and again.
posted by CameronFox
You then choose to discredit Mr. Mackey by suggesting that he is a "janitor" at NASA. Being a janitor is a very hard, honest living. It is not what he does at NASA.
Ryan Mackey is a research scientist at the NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory, specializing in vehicle autonomy and Integrated Systems Health Management for aircraft and spacecraft. He is a graduate of the University of California, Santa Cruz and the Graduate Aeronautical Laboratories at the California Institute of Technology (GALCIT).
911myths.com...
Originally posted by SPreston
hat was the highlight of the show other than the 'strawman argument' of NPT.
9-11 Truthers do not deny that a 150+ ton 500+ mph aircraft could and did penetrate the structural steel exterior structure of both towers.
.....and preventing fire from weakening the towers or melting any steel. Any melting of steel was accomplished with thermate/thermite/super thermite or an unknown device.
Demolition explosives or an unknown explosive device brought down each tower, and the 9-11 OFFICIAL STORY is self-destructing right before our eyes, with or without Ryan Mackey.
An 'Integrated Systems Health Manager' is not a rocket scientist.
It does not take a rocket scientist to see that Ryan Mackey is not a rocket scientist.
ROCKET:
any of a type of jet-propulsion device carrying either solid or liquid propellants that provide both the fuel and oxidizer required for combustion. The term is also commonly applied to any of various vehicles, including firework skyrockets, guided missiles, and spacecraft launch vehicles, driven by such a propulsive device.
NASA plans to develop a host of spacecraft and booster vehicles in order to replace the Space Shuttle and return astronauts to the Moon and then possibly send them to Mars as well. Currently, NASA is in the process of designing two boosters, the Ares I and Ares V. Ares I will have the sole function of launching mission crews into orbit. Ares V will be designed to launch other hardware for use on missions and will have a heavier lift capacity than the Ares I booster. In addition to these two boosters, NASA is designing a set of other spacecraft for use during Constellation. These will include the Orion crew capsule, the Earth Departure Stage and the Altair lunar lander.
Fire did not bring them down because the welded frames of the towers, including the powerful core structures were gigantic heat sinks, drawing the heat away from concentrating in any particular place, and preventing fire from weakening the towers or melting any steel. Any melting of steel was accomplished with thermate/thermite/super thermite or an unknown device.