It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by SpacePunk
I really don't know if the people that support these unconstitutional stop are Nazis or Communists.
Originally posted by Ian McLean
reply to post by stevegmu
If you're not breaking the law, why not allow police to search your house at their whim? What do you have to hide?
If you're not breaking the law, why should you mind if the police frisk you down at random, when you're walking down the street? What do you have to hide?
Where is 'the line' drawn? Who is responsible for making sure that 'line' is respected?
Originally posted by stevegmu
There's quite a difference between searching my house, and stopping my car on a public road and answering a simple question.
Originally posted by stevegmu
If someone isn't breaking the law, what do they have to hide? What 'rights' have they lost by simply answering a simple question? Are they so ashamed to admit they are American?
Originally posted by Ian McLean
reply to post by stevegmu
Yes. I know that, and you know that. Do the cops know that? And who advocates our point of view when the authorities decide what they think is reasonable?
In a Constitutional Republic, we cannot simply delegate those concerns to our elected representatives - we must each be prepared to 'walk to the line' and represent the side of 'individual rights'. If it seems like such action is bordering on the 'unreasonable', it only means that balance is being maintained - and I applaud those who give their efforts to such cause.
Originally posted by Chance321
reply to post by prionace glauca
Gotta give a big thumbs up to the officers for keeping their cool in the face of a person clearly trying to provoke something. Way to go officer
Originally posted by verylowfrequency
Originally posted by stevegmu
If someone isn't breaking the law, what do they have to hide? What 'rights' have they lost by simply answering a simple question? Are they so ashamed to admit they are American?
Let me ask you what rights have you lost when they ask you to search your basement or attic, to make sure your not hiding illegal aliens, contraband weapons or illegal drugs?
A line was drawn in the sand and that line is called the Constitution, once you begin to make exceptions to probable cause and the line begins to move, eventually it will become null and void.
Shall we have bloody battles again, slaughter and imprison people because some people think they have a right to invade my privacy in order to protect everybody from me? Nobody has a right to know who I am, where I come from or what I'm doing while I'm in the US and I'm a free citizen unless I choose to give them that information for the purposes of doing commerce or if I have broken a law.
I am innocent until proven guilty - that does not mean I have to prove my innocence on a daily or hourly basis. I don't give a god damn whether you or anyone else thinks I have anything to hide. The burden of proof is on them - not me. They can't invade my privacy for the purposes for searching for an infraction - they have to have probable cause that such an infraction has occurred - before conducting a search. Unless I do something wrong I don't have to answer to anybody - get it? That's why the Constitution was written - get a clue.
[edit on 11-2-2009 by verylowfrequency]
Originally posted by stevegmu
Can you provide some examples of the police going up to people's houses and saying they are going to search without a warrant?
Originally posted by finemanm
Originally posted by stevegmu
Can you provide some examples of the police going up to people's houses and saying they are going to search without a warrant?
There is a doctrine under the law called exigent circumstances that allows law enforcement to enter the home without a warrant. For example, if a police officer is walking past your window and sees you hitting your wife, he may enter your home to intervene. Another example is hot pursuit. If a cop is chasing you on the street for a crime he has probable cause to believe you committed, he may chase you into your home without a warrant. There are other examples like this, but they require probable cause that a crime is being committed and some sort of emergency.