It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Kandinsky
reply to post by Portugoal
This is an interesting story, thanks for posting it. I agree with Byrd that it's a maybe. I looked for more information and was surprised to find little supporting evidence. I noticed this pretty quick though...
An academic maverick is challenging conventional wisdom on Canada's prehistory by claiming an archeological site in southern Alberta
Copy and paste it into Google and see what you get Professor Freeman is for real. His ideas are genuine, but at this point there's little evidence to suggest that the Alberta Stonehenge is more extraordinary than the familiar Medicine Wheels.
There's a good article here that describes the Oxbow People and the Medicine Wheels of Alberta.
Maybe someone will post something more substantial to support his ideas? It seems to have more potential than the African Stonehenge, 'Adam's Calendar' in a recent thread.
Originally posted by Portugoal
Cool stuff. Never knew about contact with the Japanese and NW Natives.
Hans: just a note that sea travel between Asia and NW Canada was possible and was probably one of the ways of movement
In response to a previous post, he does seem to be too in love with his theory. But obviously there is something behind his thoery, looking beyond the fact that he's making amazing stretches in search of "truth".
Hans: This is a common occurance amongst scientists, going out of their area of expertise and getting overly protective on an idea. Once objectivity is lost, belief takes over and science takes a back seat.
If it was actually thought that Canada's ancient past was of any importance, wouldn't it be well-documented?
Hans: if it was known, if its unique and there money to do it.
What's so special about South American and Egyptian civilizations, while any possible Ancient Native civilization in the North gets no attention?
Hans: The cultures in the Meso and south America have a fair greater density of 'culture' versus the nomadic tribes of the far north.
Can anyone give a specific set of people that settled in Western Canada at this time?
Hans: they might be an off shoot of the pre-Dorset but I'm outside my area of knowledge when it comes to pre-historic Canada.
Source
Only a few medicine wheels have been excavated , but the central cairns of the largest are layered with artifacts – trade goods, projectile points and obsidian – the earliest belonging to the Oxbow people. Over the millennia, other cultures added to their size and importance, Medicine Wheels in Alberta, adding dart points, stone ornaments and other treasures under each new layer of stone. But not every culture used the stone circles.
In at least one case – the Majorville medicine wheel – it seems the monument sat unused for 1,200 years, until about 1,800 years ago. Then there seems to have been a renewal of interest (and additions to the cairn), lasting until Europeans arrived. When the south half of the enormous cairn, (nine metres or 30 feet in diameter and 1.6 metres or just over five feet tall) was excavated, 17,000 artifacts were recovered.
Originally posted by Kandinsky
I'm only an interested reader, others have expertise in this area and their opinions carry more weight. Has Professor Freeman dated any artifacts to support the early date given to the Canadian Stonehenge? If the radial points of the wheel are aligned to constellations from 5000 years ago, it would suggest a settled culture. As the link explains, they'd leave waste, animal bones, burials etc.
This Professor is pretty reputable. Not sure he would bother putting in 30 years of research and his name behind something he truly doesn't believe in. This just could be his claim to fame. Who knows? I might be curious to buy the book and look over his evidence.
The thing is, we never hear of ancient-Native Americans. If there really are structures like this, don't you think it would be talked about (us Canadians are very proud of anything that glorifies or puts us in top spot in our country, such as hockey).
Originally posted by coredrill
reply to post by Kandinsky
Mention Fell.....and Harte wont be too far.
Originally posted by Kandinsky
Originally posted by coredrill
reply to post by Kandinsky
Mention Fell.....and Harte wont be too far.
I'd be interested in an opinion on Fell. He has a dubious reputation but areas of his research are also supported. Like I mention above, there's seems to be some good work that is defeated by unsupported conclusions and speculation.
really, really, really, really bad
Originally posted by Portugoal
As for the pyramids being older than this structure, that is false. The pyramids are about 3000 years old
Originally posted by Anonymous ATS
Heard him on the radio tonight. Seems like a pretty down to earth guy. He claims the whoever build this thing had better knoledge of the Universe than the mayans.
He actually gave up trying to publish book do to it contradicting mainstream science. Years later,someone suggested reformating the book so that it would be accepted by a mainstream publisher. Im looking forward to the read.
Originally posted by tankthinker
Originally posted by Portugoal
As for the pyramids being older than this structure, that is false. The pyramids are about 3000 years old
actually recent study, or not so recent, has shown that the pyramids have water erosion, which would have been impossible for the time of 3000 years ago,
the actual amount of time would have to be closer from 7000 - 10 000 years
the only reason they hold on to the 3000 year old idea is because anthropologists say that 7000 - 10 000 years ago it would be "mpossible" for the primitive civilization living there at the time, to create these structures with their limited understanding and simple tools.
Originally posted by Portugoal
The problem with your theory is that the Pharoah's who ordered the Pyramids to be built weren't around 10000 years ago. Or did they suffer water erosion too
Originally posted by Portugoal
Anyone else with any info on North American ancient people and their belief system?
I can't find anything on the subject.
Originally posted by Portugoal
Anyone else with any info on North American ancient people and their belief system?
I can't find anything on the subject.