Obama supporter attacks and carves "B" in Mccain supporter's face. (Udate - She Lied)

reply to post by Marcus Calpurnius


That's politics, dude.

But how does anything in these clips make Obama responsible for someone mugging a woman?

It doesn't.

Does it?

Originally posted by ItsTheQuestion

Originally posted by centurion1211
This is already being discussed here.

Hypocrisy test follows:

Before this thread is closed, I have to ask whether the people so desperately defending Obama would be willing to accept their very own arguments if the situation was reversed?

[edit on 10/23/2008 by centurion1211]

Defending Obama how, exactly?

What does Barack Obama have to do with this crime?

I'm not seeing much connection here. Apparently, some of you seem to feel that this criminal has something to do with the senator's campaign.

Would I be "willing to accept their very own arguments if the situation was reversed?" Yes, I would still call the man a punk and a criminal, and hope that he's apprehended, tried and convicted.

Some of you are getting really petty these days. My condolences...

I guess if you had been around here longer, you'd already know that the people on the thread (and many others) that are trying to minimize this crime are very definitely self-proclaimed Obama supporters.

So, perhaps a better question would have been from you to the Obama supporters, "Why are you here on this thread?"

Sort of paraphrasing Shakespeare; but instead of saying perhaps you protest too much, you could say to them, "Perhaps you defend too much.".

reply to post by thisguyrighthere
I heard this on Cavuto this afternoon. It was repeorted that while the victim was being held down and assaulted, the perpetrator was shouting anit-McCain statements.
If Obama wins, I fear we will see more and more of this.

Found a photo, hope she is OK after all this.


Link to photo

Just scroll down a bit.

[edit on 10/23/2008 by Kellter]

Wouldn't it make more sense to carve an 'O'?

Originally posted by Reddupo
Wouldn't it make more sense to carve an 'O'?

It would if we were talking about a rational person or people here, but by definition, I'd say we are not.

And please don't try and say we should now try to apply a "does it makes sense" litmus test before we can say it was politically motivated to anything going on in this campaign.

Originally posted by Marcus Calpurnius
Nobody outside of the reporter who reported it heard anyone say "kill him", yet its STILL being paraded about as fact in every major MSM outlet. Now you guys want to split hairs when it comes to a carved B in a woman's face? This is what happens when the media convinces everyone who doesn't support Obama is a racist!

[edit on 23-10-2008 by Marcus Calpurnius]

Don't forget that the Secret Service investigated the claim that someone shouted "kill him" at a McCain rally and their findings revealed nothing at all! But that means nothing to the ignorant agenda driven liberal media or the ignorant agenda driven liberals that are voting for o-boy.

I'll tell you one thing though. This election has been allot closer than people have been led to believe and it has been that way for quite some time now. Did you notice that the polls are produced mostly by o-boy supporters? The polls have been artificially inflated in favor of o-boy so that when he looses libs can come back and claim voter fraud, just like they did in 2000, 2002, and 2004. Also notice that when libs won in 2006 there were absolutely zero claims of stolen election or voter fraud from anyone, especially libs! Libs are so arrogant and ignorant in their belief they cannot possibly loose an election fairly. If they loose then it must be fraud!

The fact that this ideology is so dangerous that it must be stopped by any means possibly is underscored in actions like this. This poor young lady, who was just exercising her First Amendment right, was brutally and savagely attacked by what is so typical of the modern left.

I wish this young lady well and hope she is not intimidated by the criminal left.

They must be stopped at all costs!

Since this is AboveTopSecret, an people on these boards use the "its a conspiracy website" to back-up their outlandish claims I'll take one from their playbook and bring up the following questions:

Here's a picture of the cut

Why is the B backwards? Why is the cut so shallow? Why did this lady refuse medical treatment and update her Twitter with the picture in order to come out about it?

I'll wait till further coverage comes out about it to decide, we at least know she was mugged, but I am skeptical about the rest for now. I am surprised so many people are jumping on this considering the recent "Kill him" comments at Republican rallies were proven false. What's to say this isn't another false flag from the opposite side.

Even if this turns out to be true it's one crazy person doing this.

If you want to bring up "Well I am sure you were up in arms about the evil Republican rally, flip flopper, double standard!" like I am sure sos37 would like to do, since he did it earlier, I would encourage you to check my posts.

[edit on 23-10-2008 by davion]

reply to post by Erasurehead


Anyone who is this small brained,has too be an
escaped zoo animal who should be put too sleep.

Yeah, I have to change my opinion on this again. Something happened to that woman. Her face is beat up pretty good. Add the fact that he was shouting anti-
McCain slurs while e beat her is pretty interesting too.

[edit on 23-10-2008 by Marcus Calpurnius]

The backwords B looks like the knife was pushed hard against the skin...but never actually broke it. That would leave a mark similar to the one on her face. Will have to wait for more info on this one... It certainly looks like she took a few good punches to the face though.

Looks to me like a Hoax.

Politically Motivated Attack or Hoax?

Pittsburgh law enforcement sources tell TMZ they have serious questions about the authenticity of the alleged victim who says she had her face cut by a politically-motivated attacker.

More thoughts and questions here.

Originally posted by David9176
The backwords B looks like the knife was pushed hard against the skin...but never actually broke it. That would leave a mark similar to the one on her face. Will have to wait for more info on this one... It certainly looks like she took a few good punches to the face though.

The problem is that if someone knocks you down, punches and kicks you repeatedly, then says they are going to "teach you a lesson" and goes for your face with a knife you are going to struggle and try to get away. The cut is too shallow and too straight in my opinion, especially if this guy is as pissed off as he sounds, it'd be really deep and jagged from her fighting back and from his anger.

Couple that with the fact that she refused medical treatment right away after getting beaten up and cut.

Some people have been saying that he might have stood over her upside down to cut her, but that doesn't explain the straight cuts and the almost perfect 'B'. If he was standing over her he'd have to hold her and keep her from hitting him with her arms, etc and she could still move her face. He doesn't have enough hands to keep her still enough.

The picture to me, looks like she laid perfectly still and let him cut her, though in my opinion it looks more like a cut from a paperclip than a knife.

But I guess we'll see.

Originally posted by LiquidMirage

Originally posted by Tom_Proctor
Should've carved a Swastika in her face.

You are a very sick individual! Go away!

And I don't care if I get a warn for this responce!

It's a joke. There was a talk show host that carved a swastick on his face in front of a mirror so the swastika was backwards. Morton Downey Jr.?

How do we know he is an Obama supporter..??? Now thats the funniest thing I have read in months.. After he robs her, kicks her, slashes her, carves the bumper sticker off her car..Hmmmm..any idiot can see this one.. He probably could'nt spell Barack anyway.

Expect to see more of this under an Obama presidency.

Blacks have a deep hatred of whites. Possibly deserved, considering what whites did to them for 300 years. I'm sure deep down inside, just about every black person would secretly like revenge of some form on white people.


An Obama presidency will only fuel this desire, and it will ultimately empower blacks to do things they never dreamed of doing before- such as going to college, owning a house, voting, etc, etc ... and also finally lashing back at the white devil and taking what is rightfully theirs.

reply to post by Marcus Calpurnius


Right Obama is a dirt bag but something to think about, why is the B on her face backwards? If someone did it to her it would have been a regular B and backwards B is indiciative of someone looking in a mirror, perhaps a self inflicted wound? There are sickos on both sides here and trust me I would rather rot than see Obama in office