It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Kapyong
Gday all,
Originally posted by Bombeni
Is it absolute proof of Jesus' existence? No, not in and of itself.
No.
It isn't.
The existence of a real person in a work of fiction does NOT prove any such thing.
Just as the existence of London does not prove James Bond real.
Just as the existence of Mt Olympus does not prove Zeus real.
Originally posted by Bombeni
It is just one more of hundreds of clues that can only lead to one conCLUsion, that Jesus did in fact live and further that he performed miracles and that his life had an impact unrivaled by history.
That's faithful BELIEF, not a conclusion.
Originally posted by Bombeni
Consider the hundreds of Messianic prophecies fulfilled.
None of which stand up to scrutiny.
The NT was written by people who knew the OT, they just made up the alleged "prophecies" based on the earlier book.
This is no more miraculous than The Lord of Rings fulfilling "prophecies" in The Hobbit.
It means nothing at all.
Originally posted by Bombeni
Did the OT prophets as well as the NT prophets, disciples, historical writers, governors, emperors, etc. all play a part in a conspiracy to fabricate The Son of Man?
No.
The Jesus Myth argument is NOT about a conspiracy at all (of course, there are plenty of conspiracy claims on THIS site, nothing to do with NT scholarship though.)
If you think the Jesus Myth argument is about a "conspiracy" then you know nothing about the argument at all.
Kapyong
Originally posted by Bombeni
reply to post by Simplynoone
Hi Simplynoone, I agree, I think they are actually trying to convince themselves more than anyone else that Jesus didn't exist or wasn't God. They know they can't convince us so why would they even bother?
Wouldn't that be easier to just think this is all there is, we came from a rock and when we die we become nothing? But I believe the innate knowledge of Him is within all of us, and that we were put on this earth to choose. Remember, Jesus said "you can't serve two masters, you'll love one and hate the other" (Matthew 6:24).
The other side of the fight is US trying to convince THEM. So many times it seems completely futile, but then I think, what if on Judgement Day one of them looks at me and says "Bombeni, you knew. You knew and you didn't say anything. Why?"
[edit on 29-9-2008 by Bombeni]
I just love this -------"The NT was written by people who knew the OT, they just made up the alleged "prophecies" based on the earlier book" (your words). Every last one of them was in it. They all got together and agreed on events that would accurately coincide with ancient predictions. LOL. Mary, Joseph, Jesus, 12 disciples, Josephus, Pontius Pilate and his wife, Roman governors, etc etc etc, conspired to dupe the people with the OT prophecies. Wow, guess they did a bang-up job because by 325 AD, the following of Jesus, Christianity, became the official religion of the Roman Empire.
Within 500 years, even Greece's temples of Greek gods were transformed into churches for followers of Jesus. Thanks for the morning funny! I can skip the comic pages today.
Originally posted by Simplynoone
You know I find it really fascinating and inspiring just knowing that you athiests and agnostics and science guys ..are still in this thread ...for some reason I actually think that you believe more than you think you do (In other words your minds are telling you no and your HEART is telling you YES) ..........or you would not be so interested in all of this for so long even (days months years lol) ..I know you would have better things to do than this thread or this subject ... ..if you really did not believe (even a little bit) you would not waste your time ..would you ?
I dont buy that your trying to get us blindly led Jesus sheep (sarcasm yes lol)
to stop believeing that their is proof
So the only reasons I could come up with your here is because you WANT TO LET GO and BELIEVE ....because deep down you know its true ..
The Proof will come once you really for real are ready to really want to know ..(Not just say you do .. in your mind you are still being stubborn..so you have to really really want to know the truth (for once let you heart think before your MIND does) ... ..then the truth will set you free ..just watch and see ...the truth comes when you really ask for it ..but dont expect it to be a piece paper proving something ..but something real and spiritual that will BLOW YOU AWAY with enough proof to get you on your knees and sorry for all of this nonsense unbelief ..
Your so close ........
I think they are actually trying to convince themselves more than anyone else that Jesus didn't exist or wasn't God. They know they can't convince us so why would they even bother?
Wouldn't that be easier to just think this is all there is, we came from a rock and when we die we become nothing?
But I believe the innate knowledge of Him is within all of us, and that we were put on this earth to choose.
Remember, Jesus said "you can't serve two masters, you'll love one and hate the other" (Matthew 6:24). The other side of the fight is US trying to convince THEM. So many times it seems completely futile, but then I think, what if on Judgement Day one of them looks at me and says "Bombeni, you knew. You knew and you didn't say anything. Why?"
Originally posted by Deaf Alien
My heart has been open for a long time. I'm still waiting.
Just because we post on these posts does not mean it is being forced on you .None of you are being forced to read anything ..or even listen to what we may have to say ..you could just close your ears to it and put us on ignore . I dont see how so many say it is being forced just because we talk about it. I dont consider the Alien threads as them forcing their beliefs on me at all . In fact I just see them as expressing their beliefs and I can either read them and post if I want to or just walk away and not even take a peek ..
DA, do you really mean this? I think I have something that can help you. If you truly are interested in seeing it, I will u2u it. It is supposed to be a thread I was going to start in the BTS Faith forum and was a collection of some pretty interesting things that I believe are very strong evidence for the Judeo-Christian God's existence. But I'm so tried of the haters around here that I have been hesitant. May I u2u you the thread I created so far? The video information alone is about 3 hours worth of material and then the article links would take about a week to get through. If you want to see it, I'll u2u you but you mention religious people pushing their beliefs on others and I don't want you to see me that way.
Originally posted by Deaf Alien
WOW! All three ganged up on me! Many new posts since I talked with somebody on yahoo messenger. Gosh, I need to keep up!
Ashely, sure you can u2u me your thread. I haven't been on BTS in a while.
Mmm, well last time I checked, assuming you are American, Canadian or anywhere in the free world, you can choose how you believe. Now you have a point about muslims, however you might get your head chopped off for disagreeing with them if you live in their country.
As far as meeting up one day on the other side, and ME discovering I was wrong? I sincerely hope you are right.
So, who, please tell me, concccted Mary, Joseph, the disciples, Josephus, Pilate, Nero, etc.? They are all fictitious also? Go ahead, I'm following you. Don't stop now.
Originally posted by Deaf Alien
Have you seen Zeitgeist?
Zeitgeist has been debunked for over a year. In fact, actually, all the information they used in their video project was debunked possibly up to a century ago. Then Zeitgeist came out and people directly debunked the info in the video. It wasn't too hard- all the info had already been debunked. lol