It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by forestlady
My ancestors were burned at the stake by people like you
Originally posted by Roark
Doghead:
If Magick's goal is to expand the consciousness, how can it be "provably unsuccessful"?
Originally posted by DogHead
That is one big IF isn't it? I would have thought the goal of casting some spell would be to have the spell work. Apologists for the belief "system" involved can preach self-improvement all they like, in terms of casting spells it's nonsense and any remotely objective observer can prove it.
Originally posted by forestlady
reply to post by DogHead
Your hatred is so deep that you are completely refusing any and all historical facts about Pagans. Paganism was the first religion humans ever practiced, along with Shamanism.
You have shown a number of times that you don't even know what you're talking about.
I feel sad for you, with all that hatred in your heart.
Originally posted by mmmeat
I disagree with DogHead, but I also have to say that believing that Paganism or Shamanism is the 'first religion' is somewhat naive.
Meat.
Originally posted by LightinDarkness
And as much as you'd like to blame it being "demolished" by the inquisition, you should redirect that toward other eastern and pagan religions which often locked into struggles to demolish each other. This is one thing you can't blame on Christianity. Tolerance was often NOT a virtue of paganism, and temples were often warring each other to win new converts. [edit on 11-1-2008 by LightinDarkness]
Originally posted by forestlady
Originally posted by mmmeat
I disagree with DogHead, but I also have to say that believing that Paganism or Shamanism is the 'first religion' is somewhat naive.
Meat.
Why do you think it is naive? I regularly read books by established authors/anthropologists/etc. and this is what they all say. It's pretty much the established opinion of scholar who study these things. Do you have
knowledge that anothe religion was first, and if so what is it? Please explain why you think this and tell us what religion did come first, in your opinion.
Originally posted by LightinDarkness
reply to post by forestlady
I would like to point you you have asked me for sources while you have provided none that say "the 'paganism' practiced today is the oldest religion in the world," even though you say this is true. Nonetheless, here you go:
[edit on 12-1-2008 by LightinDarkness]
Originally posted by forestlady
Well, if you will note, I said "Paganism is the oldest form of religion". I didn't say Neo-Paganism now did I? We have done our best to reconstruct a religion which was all but demolished by the Inquisition and witchburnings in the Middle Ages.
Originally posted by forestlady
Could you explain what you're talking about? And could you provide sources? I can't respond to this because it's so vague. Are you talking about when the Barbarians were fighting with Genghis Khan, etc.? Because they were Pagan, too. Pagans have always been tolerant, it's what we're known for; we've never launched a war due to religion.
Originally posted by forestlady
And the witch burnings WERE a holocaust, when that many people die just because they belong to a certain group, that is a holocaust. What is your definition?
Originally posted by forestlady
That is because I NEVER made that claim,
Originally posted by forestlady
My ancestors were burned at the stake by people like you
Originally posted by forestlady
Paganism was the first religion humans ever practiced
What I'm asking of you is, where is the evidence that Paganism destroyed itself or was destroyed by the East?
Originally posted by forestlady
That is because I NEVER made that claim, nor do I believe Pagans are practicing what they did thousands of years ago.
Originally posted by forestlady
(Nor do Christians practice what they did 2,000 years ago.)
Originally posted by forestlady
I know better than that and I also know alot of the people/scholars that are trying to reconstruct Paganism through research. What I'm asking of you is, where is the evidence that Paganism destroyed itself or was destroyed by the East?
Originally posted by forestlady
Quit trying to put words in my mouth to make me look ignorant.