It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Quickfix
>Yeah, well then can you tell me whats causing all the new stronger >storms? (not global warming).
You are correct, it is not global warming, it is the Earths natural cycles.
>"because you don't have any proof it doesn't exist."
That is the worst logic ever! I can't prove it doesn't exist, therefore it must exist! Come on, you're not serious about that, surely?
>Nibiru's gravity I'm not sure what holds it, though common sense would >first say the sun since its freaken huge. So Nibiru could'nt possibly be >real because none of these things ever happened right?
OK, lets roll with the idea of the Sun being the central mass around which Nibiru orbits (because yes, all elliptical orbits have a central mass). So, if it was causing havoc by being next to earth, 3000 years ago, and it is 4 years away, it would have an approximate orbit of 3000 years, right? So, 4 years away, and we can't see it, so we have to assume that it is travelling fast, right? So, it travels fast, AND takes 3000 years to make an orbit. That would be an extremelly thin ellipse of an orbit, don't you think? In fact, it would be a type of orbit that we don't see anywhere else in the universe! Fancy that.
>1) No one has been around to actually proove that it doesn't exist, >because the orbit takes so long.
Dude, there's plenty of people can prove it doesn't exist, and not one who can prove it does. The burden of proof is on the Nibiru believers.
>2) Its written down in history. (Summerians)
No, it is an INTERPRETATION of Summerian tablets, and if you look back at the other Nibiru threads, you will see a lot of people that don't agree with Sitchins interpretaions.
>3) There was a global flood (Noah's flood due to Nibiru 20 times size of >earth) its recorded in almost every major city at the time. (Greeks etc.)
Did Nibiru drop water on Earth?
>No one said you had to believe in it. And no matter what you say your >right, cause theres no changing anyones mind, no matter what.
No, you can change peoples minds, when you present them with rational facts. I've read many posts on ATS that have changed my mind about things. It is usually because I didn't know much about a topic, or I had wrong information. That's what is good about sharing knowledge and opinions.
Originally posted by Quickfix
Yeah, i wonder what kind of soil, i'll do some digging later. If you didn't know tidal waves occur daily. Its pretty cool they have some stuff on youtube about it i think.
And I hope i'm wrong about Nibiru. I don't want that, but incase it does happen might as well be prepared and this forum is a good place to start talking with people to get ideas.
I also like the arguements.
Originally posted by Anuubis
Originally posted by Quickfix
Yeah, i wonder what kind of soil, i'll do some digging later. If you didn't know tidal waves occur daily. Its pretty cool they have some stuff on youtube about it i think.
And I hope i'm wrong about Nibiru. I don't want that, but incase it does happen might as well be prepared and this forum is a good place to start talking with people to get ideas.
I also like the arguements.
It's more of a debate than an arguement. I know tidal waves happen every day, but in order for the soil to be deposited from madagascar to south america the wave would have to be over a mile high. That don't happen everyday.
Originally posted by Essan
It's not a debate - there is no physical way in which soil can transfer from Madagascar to S America via a tsunami! I guess what they actually mean is that there is evidence of an impact in the Indian Ocean and evidence for a tsunami hitting somewhere in S America around the same time?
As for Nibiru - read my signature. It's more likely a 1,400ft rubber planet will hit Earth in 2012 than anything the scam merchants are telling you!
Originally posted by cruzion
Originally posted by Quickfix
>Yeah, well then can you tell me whats causing all the new stronger >storms? (not global warming).
You are correct, it is not global warming, it is the Earths natural cycles.
>"because you don't have any proof it doesn't exist."
That is the worst logic ever! I can't prove it doesn't exist, therefore it must exist! Come on, you're not serious about that, surely?
>Nibiru's gravity I'm not sure what holds it, though common sense would >first say the sun since its freaken huge. So Nibiru could'nt possibly be >real because none of these things ever happened right?
OK, lets roll with the idea of the Sun being the central mass around which Nibiru orbits (because yes, all elliptical orbits have a central mass). So, if it was causing havoc by being next to earth, 3000 years ago, and it is 4 years away, it would have an approximate orbit of 3000 years, right? So, 4 years away, and we can't see it, so we have to assume that it is travelling fast, right? So, it travels fast, AND takes 3000 years to make an orbit. That would be an extremelly thin ellipse of an orbit, don't you think? In fact, it would be a type of orbit that we don't see anywhere else in the universe! Fancy that.
>1) No one has been around to actually proove that it doesn't exist, >because the orbit takes so long.
Dude, there's plenty of people can prove it doesn't exist, and not one who can prove it does. The burden of proof is on the Nibiru believers.
>2) Its written down in history. (Summerians)
No, it is an INTERPRETATION of Summerian tablets, and if you look back at the other Nibiru threads, you will see a lot of people that don't agree with Sitchins interpretaions.
>3) There was a global flood (Noah's flood due to Nibiru 20 times size of >earth) its recorded in almost every major city at the time. (Greeks etc.)
Did Nibiru drop water on Earth?
>No one said you had to believe in it. And no matter what you say your >right, cause theres no changing anyones mind, no matter what.
No, you can change peoples minds, when you present them with rational facts. I've read many posts on ATS that have changed my mind about things. It is usually because I didn't know much about a topic, or I had wrong information. That's what is good about sharing knowledge and opinions.
Originally posted by Anuubis